TV: Survivor 37 David vs. Goliath discussion

[Glenn Isildur Healy]

Great episode!

Anyone else here listens to RHAP?

 

[TP]

Great episode!

Anyone else here listens to RHAP?

Rob is still my favorite player ever.

 

[Glenn Isildur Healy]

Rob is still my favorite player ever.

Forget about his strategic mind, wittiest player in survivor history

 

[Glenn Isildur Healy]

As someone who's pretty much watched every season since the beginning
IMO 10 Greatest Survivor players of all-time

1) Sandra Diaz Twine
2) Parvati Shallow
3) Kim Spradlin
4) Rob Mariano
5) Todd Herzog
6) Brian Heidik
7) Tony Vlachos
8) Jeremy Collins
9) Cirie Fields
10) Richard Hatch

 

[MAHJ71]

I was a bit down on this season but this past episode won me over.

 

[Cor]

As someone who's pretty much watched every season since the beginning
IMO 10 Greatest Survivor players of all-time

1) Sandra Diaz Twine
2) Parvati Shallow
3) Kim Spradlin
4) Rob Mariano
5) Todd Herzog
6) Brian Heidik
7) Tony Vlachos
8) Jeremy Collins
9) Cirie Fields
10) Richard Hatch

No Hantz?

 

[SPV]

Another great episode, this has been a very good season IMO. I'm glad that they Davids & maybe the 'strikeforce' are still intact. I'm not confident those six can hold it together though. I feel like Alec is playing a very good game though; but we'll see if he has finishing power.

 

[Glenn Isildur Healy]

No Hantz?

Hantz is maybe a Top 50 player

He's not better than most winners and lots of non winners I have ahead of him too like Cesternino, Cirie (as mentioned), Yau-Man, David Wright, Dominic, Wentworth and Amanda Kimmel (this one is debatable)

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Bad play Dan-0. Should have just let Angelina go and kept the idol for yourself.

 

[TheBeastCoast]

Bad play Dan-0. Should have just let Angelina go and kept the idol for yourself.

She wasn't going regardless.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

She wasn't going regardless.

Correct, so it was a dumb move and now he has no idol.

 

[TheBeastCoast]

Correct, so it was a dumb move and now he has no idol.

It was dumb and he has 1 left.

 

[Rob Brown]

Arguably it would have looked worse for him if he didn't play it for her, because he'd have openly said screw you to his alliance and still lost a key member since she wasn't actually going to be voted out. At least this way he tried to keep his alliance in tact and can still work with them.

 

[hoglund]

As someone who's pretty much watched every season since the beginning
IMO 10 Greatest Survivor players of all-time

1) Sandra Diaz Twine
2) Parvati Shallow
3) Kim Spradlin
4) Rob Mariano
5) Todd Herzog
6) Brian Heidik
7) Tony Vlachos
8) Jeremy Collins
9) Cirie Fields
10) Richard Hatch

Russell should be there in the top 10.

 

[Glenn Isildur Healy]

Russell should be there in the top 10.

He's maybe top 50 on my list
One of the worst social players in survivor history

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Russell is easily a top 20 player. If it wasn't for his end game he'd be top 10. He had players eating out of his hand, not sure how you could say his social game was the worst in survivor history.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

As someone who's pretty much watched every season since the beginning
IMO 10 Greatest Survivor players of all-time

1) Sandra Diaz Twine
2) Parvati Shallow
3) Kim Spradlin
4) Rob Mariano
5) Todd Herzog
6) Brian Heidik
7) Tony Vlachos
8) Jeremy Collins
9) Cirie Fields
10) Richard Hatch

Some of those players should not even sniff top 50.

Cirie? REALLY? The lady who is scared of a f***ing leaf?? Sandra shouldnt be 1, Parvati has no business in top 10. Rob should be 1

 

[Hurricane28]

David’s absolutely killing it. Best part is Kara doesn’t even get credit for that move

 

[SensBrawler]

Such a hilariously tragic ending for Dan.

 

[Prairie Habs]

Fantastic play by the Davids. Another great episode from what could be one of the top seasons all-time.

Great episode!

Anyone else here listens to RHAP?

I use to listen to pretty much all of his survivor podcast when I could listen to them at work. I still catch Know it Alls every week and usually the Wiggle Room as well.

 

[Avalanche]

What a 2 weeks for Dan

Sitting pretty with 2 idols on the majority
Wastes an idol on an alliance member he didn't even like, only to see his boy go home
Gets dumped by Kara
Uses idol on himself only to get it nullified and gets voted out

Brutal.

 

[TheBeastCoast]

Man I can not get over how fast Mike's game has gone down the drain since the merge. He had himself set up so well, got cold feet and really isn't doing anything at this point.

 

[Peasy]

Hypothetically speaking...

If Dan never used his idol last week. After he saw that his idol was nullified tonight, would he have been able to use his second idol on himself? Because that would have made amazing TV. Then Christian most likely uses his idol on himself and Angelina goes home.

 

[Avalanche]

Hypothetically speaking...

If Dan never used his idol last week. After he saw that his idol was nullified tonight, would he have been able to use his second idol on himself? Because that would have made amazing TV. Then Christian most likely uses his idol on himself and Angelina goes home.

I wonder if they have a time limit where they can say whether they are using a HII or not. Jeff did have to reach into the basket to pull out the nullifier, so maybe it's too late then. idk lol

 

[spintheblackcircle]

Another top flight episode. Hope it finds a way to maintain the level of the last few episodes somehow.