Superteam A vs. Superteam B

[VoluntaryDom]

Kind of mind boggling that anyone would pick B.

idk about that, they do have orr and the advantage in goal

but like its wayne gretzky

 

[God King Fudge]

idk about that, they do have orr and the advantage in goal

but like its wayne gretzky

And Jagr. And Lemieux. And Yzerman.

 

[Krewe]

Kind of mind boggling that anyone would pick B.

Depends on context. Give both teams equal training and development and you pick A anyday. But with their actual real life levels, B could be the better choice due to having more modern talent. On talent alone A wins out, but they didn’t have the benefits team B had

 

[qqaz]

You could replace 3rd line with Samsonov-Bozak-Umberger and I'd still pick team A.

 

[tony d]

I went with Team A.

 

[Master P]

the other team has Howe-Orr... you can at least look at the whole teams.

No

 

[authentic]

Well the question was who would win a 7 game series if everyone was at their peak. Forsberg, Lindros and Bure were rarely healthy at their peak. And if they've had to play a regular season before to get there they might all be injured. And if not, Pronger would most likely take them all out during that 7 game series and team A would be forced to play without them for most of the time.

Lemiuex was also fragile and he would most likely miss some of those 7 games. So team A would have to make up for that somehow. The most injury prone player on team B is probably Malkin and he's been healthier than all 4 of those on team A...

All 3 rarely missed any time during the playoffs actually, but I don't take you seriously to begin with though lol.

 

[authentic]

You could replace 3rd line with Samsonov-Bozak-Umberger and I'd still pick team A.

Odd.

 

[MattMartin]

The 3rd line on team A has Modano-Messier-Bossy.

Messier 6 cups
Bossy 4 cups
Modano 1 cup.

 

[Nathaniel Skywalker]

I saw peak Lemieux and Gretzky and automatically voted

 

[SupremeNachos]

We doing 80-90s almost anything goes rules or post 12-13 lockout rules? Cause if it's the former I'm going A.

 

[DFF]

Lemieux > Ovechkin
Gretzky > Crosby
Jagr < Howe
Forsberg < Hull
Lindros < McDavid
Bure < Lafleur
Modano < Sakic
Messier >= Malkin
Bossy < Kucherov
Marchand < Zetterberg
Yzerman > Datsyuk
Bergeron < Fedorov

Bourque < Orr
Karlsson < Lidstrom
Stevens = Coffey
Chelios < Pronger
Chara > Hedman
Doughty = Burns

Roy < Hasek

B

Good comparison except
Messier>>>>Malkin
And doughty >> burns

 

[North Cole]

I scrolled down and saw A's top line, scrolled back up and voted.

Didnt really bother reading further...no point

 

[PuckMasterZero]

Well the question was who would win a 7 game series if everyone was at their peak. Forsberg, Lindros and Bure were rarely healthy at their peak. And if they've had to play a regular season before to get there they might all be injured. And if not, Pronger would most likely take them all out during that 7 game series and team A would be forced to play without them for most of the time.

Lemiuex was also fragile and he would most likely miss some of those 7 games. So team A would have to make up for that somehow. The most injury prone player on team B is probably Malkin and he's been healthier than all 4 of those on team A...

Lemiuex wasn't fragile. He had cancer and a bone disease due to an infection. How does that constitute fragile? Jesus Christ

 

[illpucks]

Team B
Sakic-Malkin-Kucherov is GOAT 3rd line

 

[thadd]

I vote team A, but I'm pretty sure they have a lot of problems staying out of the penalty box.

 

[Voodoo Child]

Gretzky and Lemieux?

Come on, at least try to make it interesting.

A, 4 games to zero, maybe one.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Team A forwards >>> Team B forwards
Team A defence < Team B defence
Goaltending a saw off

I’ll take Team A in 6.

 

[Bouboumaster]

I read the first line of Team A and I stopped there.