St Louis Cardinals vs Brooklyn Dodgers

Who wins?

  • St Louis Cardinals

  • Brooklyn Dodgers


Results are only viewable after voting.

Say Hey Kid

it's better to burn out than to fade awa
Dec 10, 2007
23,614
5,494
ATL
3zhma0aeq17tktge1huh7yok5.gif


Manager: Tony LaRussa

Captain: Hank Aaron

Lineup:

1. L Joe Morgan - 132 OPS+, 689 SBs
2. Robin Yount - 271 SBs
3.
4.
5.
6. Jeff Bagwell - 149 OPS+, 202 SBs
7. L Eddie Mathews - 143 OPS+
8. Gary Carter

Defense:

C Gary Carter - 70.1 WAR
1B Jeff Bagwell - 79.9 WAR
2B Joe Morgan - 100.6 WAR
3B Eddie Mathews - 96.6 WAR
SS Robin Yount - 77.3 WAR

Bench:

C Gene Tenace - 136 OPS+
1B/2B L Rod Carew - 131 OPS+, 353 SBs
3B Ron Santo - 125 OPS+
SS/PR Luis Aparicio - 55.8 WAR, 506 SBs
OF/1B/PH L Larry Walker - 141 OPS+, 230 SBs

HoF Starters:

1. Greg Maddux - 132 ERA+, 16 GGs
2. Tom Seaver - 127 ERA+
3. John Smoltz - 125 ERA+
4. L Steve Carlton

Bullpen:

Closer - L Billy Wagner - 187 ERA+, 23.7 JAWS
Setup - L Bobby Shantz - 29.7 JAWS
Setup - Tom "Flash" Gordon - 29.1 JAWS
Short - L RP John Hiller - 28.4 JAWS
Short - Craig Kimbrel- 195 ERA+, 19.6 JAWS
Short L Chris Sale - 140 ERA+
Medium L Johan Santana - 136 ERA+
Long Stephen Strasburg - 130 ERA+

VS

u8p4zxhiep08twlfgigpppyqe.png


BROOKLYN DODGERS:

MANAGER: John McGraw

LINEUP:

1 - Ichiro Suzuki
2 - Ty Cobb
3 - Honus Wagner
4 - Tris Speaker
5 - Eddie Collins
6 - Johnny Mize
7 - Brooks Robinson
8 - Johnny Bench


Defense:

C - Johnny Bench
1B - Johnny Mize
2B - Eddie Collins
3B - Brooks Robinson
SS - Honus Wagner
LF - Tris Speaker
CF - Ty Cobb
RF - Ichiro Suzuki

Bench:

1 - Pete Rose
2 - Bill Mazeroski
3 - Roy Campanella
4 - Tony Gwynn
5 - Manny Ramirez
6 - Omar Vizquel
7 - Jim Thome

Starters:

1 - Walter Johnson
2 - Christy Mathewson
3 - Clayton Kershaw
4 - Eddie Plank
5 - Jim Palmer

Bullpen:

Closer - Mariano Rivera

Setup Men:

1 - Goose Gossage
2 - Bruce Sutter
3 - Robb Nen
4 - Jeff Reardon
 
Last edited:

Say Hey Kid

it's better to burn out than to fade awa
Dec 10, 2007
23,614
5,494
ATL
1. Greg Maddux - 132 ERA+, 16 GGs
2. Tom Seaver - 127 ERA+
3. John Smoltz - 125 ERA+
4. L Steve Carlton - lefty with best slider ever

I like my new rotation much better. Maddux has 16 Gold Gloves, the most ever by a starter.

----------------------------------------------------

Hall of Famer Larry Walker (141 OPS+) is my pinch hitter and Luis Aparicio (506 stolen bags) is my pinch runner. If we're winning after 8 innings, Aparicio will be the defensive replacement at shortstop for Robin Yount.

Good luck, Dr Pepper!
 
Last edited:

Vegeta

God Dammit Nappa
May 2, 2009
4,194
528
Capsule Corp.
Really tough call. In this ATD, I always put a lot of stock into power.

I feel mistakes from these pitchers will be few and far between, and you need to have hitters that can capitalize on it. In that regard, the Cards blow the Dodgers out of the water.

But Cobb, Wagner, Speaker, and Walter, Matthewson, Kershaw are filthy trios.

This is a good one, no doubt.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->