Let's talk for a moment about roster management as I see it. If you are trying to construct a team that is competitive year after year (like the Greyhounds seem to be trying to do), lets's assume that on any given season, you want your 24 man roster made up of the following:
3 - 20 year olds
6 - 19 year olds
6 - 18 year olds
7 - 17 year olds
2 - 16 year olds
A roster constructed in such a way gives you the most stability from year to year. Each year you would sign 2 new 16 year olds, and 5 more 17 year olds. Pretty straight forward. Trades to add premium players are rare on such a team, since you aren't planning on selling big to recoup those lost assets.
Now let's look at the current Greyhounds roster for 2019-2020 (24 players signed so far - 16 forwards, 6 defense, 2 goalies):
2 - 20 year olds
6 - 19 year olds * *
9 - 18 year olds
5 - 17 year olds
2 - 16 year olds
The * are reminders that both Barrett Hayton and Brett Jacklin may not actually return this season. If we assume neither returns, we will need to replace them (probably with an 18 year old import and another prospect signed). So far so good. We should just sign another 17 year old defenseman, right?
Wrong. Here is why. Let's assume we signed that 18 year old import plus that 17 year old prospect and now look forward to the 2020-2021 season (22 players signed - 13 forwards, 8 defense, 1 goalie)
4 - 20 year olds **
10 - 19 year olds
6 - 18 year olds
2 - 17 year olds (2003 born)
0 - 16 year olds
The ** flags too many overagers, but even dropping one overager leaves us only 3 roster spots to fill. 2 will likely be 16 year olds and we need a goalie to replace Propp. We have room to sign only 1 more 2003 born player. Let's look at our 2003 born prospects:
2019, 1st - Holmes, Jacob (D)
2019, 3rd - Boudreau, Marc (F)
2019, 4th - D'Intino, Jordan (F)
2019, 5th - Parsons, Owen (F)
2019, 6th - Brzustowski, Luc (D)
2019, 7th - Taylor, Coulter (G)
2019, 8th - Haymes, Luke (F)
2019, 9th - Chiddenton, Rhys (F)
2019, 10th - Brown, Hunter (D)
2019, 11th - Savard, Tyler (F)
2019, 12th - Di Pasquo, Luca (G)
2019, 13th - Miller, Connor (F)
2019, 14th - DeVries, Luke (D)
2019, 15th - Heroux, Logan (D)
How are we going to get these good 2003 born prospects on our roster next year? I believe you have to sign one more this season instead of another 2002 born. It sucks for Cole McGuire and Matthew Halushak, but whoever shows best at training camp between Jordan D'Intino, Owen Parsons, and Luc Brzustowski should get on the team. The only reason to sign McGuire or Halushak would be if you somehow think they have a higher ceiling than any of these 2003 born prospects.
Obviously, if Raftis moves out some roster players then that makes it easier. But Raftis hasn't traditionally made many moves like that, so it remains to be seen if he has the appetite to do it. If not, don't be surprised to see a third 2003 born make the squad this year.
Thoughts?