I've tried to get into other games, I got Witcher 3 complete edition, GTA5, Assasins Creed Odyssey....but nothing else has hooked me like Spider-Man did.
I think a big problem is getting into the story. I hate videogame stories (Witcher is actually very interesting what I have seen, but its so dense its intimidating) but with Spider-Man, I already have a ton of basic knowledge about the character so the story is very easy to follow.
I am close to 100%'ing it again by finishing the main story in New Game + on the highest difficulty (which isn't that difficult because at that point Spider-Man is fully powered up, has all his gadgets, and the player knows how to use them).
All the new costumes are amazing but my favourite is still the 90's Scarlet-Spider. I will be forever grateful that they included that suit.