I would think it amazing too if he actually was. Thing is you're only counting wins and regular time losses. To get an accurate gauge you should count OTL as well. (Logically speaking at least because the NHL DOES include OTW in the win stats. Seems silly to not count both ways.)
Given that Dubs record over last two years is 32W 33L 11OTL
If you don't count OTL nearly every team or goalie in the league is near .500.
Actually, I do count OTL. I go by % of points - so an OTL is basically a tie (or at least better than a regulation loss).
Dubnyk last year in the 43 games he got a decision on went: 20-20-3. So he captured 43 of a possible 86 points - exactly .500
I don't want to get into a big semantics argument, but surely you will concede that even if not as good as a tie used to be, an OTL is certainly better than a regulation loss.
Khabibulin last year in his 39 decisions was 12-20-7 (including a ridiculous October) - 31 out of a possible 78 points (39.7%)
The previous year, Khabi went 10-32-4. So 24 points of a possible 92 for 26.1%.
Dubnyk went 12-13-8. 32 of a possible 66 points for 48.5%. Total over the last 2 years 75 of 152 - so 49.3%. About as close to 50% as you can get (just wanted to explain how I got my "almost exactly 50%")
