Youtube: Simon Nemec vs Max Domi

[BM14]

Cute. Clearly you believe attacking another player, who isn’t a fighter and who isn’t agreeing to fight is just fine. The league has changed a lot over the 60+ years I’ve been watching. And one of the biggest changes is a move away from goonish fighting. What Max did was goonish. I’m guessing you would think it fine for a good fighter on another club to attack Nylander and only get 5 for fighting?

Do not touch a top 5 player in the game, and the greatest goal scorer of a generation.

End of story.

If you don’t like it, try the PWHL.

 

[Fatass]

Do not touch a top 5 player in the game, and the greatest goal scorer of a generation.

End of story.

If you don’t like it, try the PWHL.

So you’re suggesting a goon could attack Matthews and beat him silly and the response would be a Leaf player would later attack the goon? You do realize that is what the game will devolve into, right? Remember when John Scott went after Kessel? What if Scott did what Domi did to Nemec to Kessel and jumped him?
You actually think this is what the league wants?

 

[All Mod Cons]

How can Jersey not respond to that. They are so soft. Leafs bullying team again.

 

[BM14]

So you’re suggesting a goon could attack Matthews and beat him silly and the response would be a Leaf player would later attack the goon? You do realize that is what the game will devolve into, right? Remember when John Scott went after Kessel? What if Scott did what Domi did to Nemec to Kessel and jumped him?
You actually think this is what the league wants?

How did you get to that scenario from what I said?

I literally said do not touch a top 5 player the league.

Again, I think the PWHL is more your taste. Check them out.

 

[Fatass]

How did you get to that scenario from what I said?

I literally said do not touch a top 5 player the league.

Again, I think the PWHL is more your taste. Check them out.

Sadly the elite skill guys on the Leafs will become targets of goonish attacks if your thinking prevails.

 

[HugeInTheShire]

How did you get to that scenario from what I said?

I literally said do not touch a top 5 player the league.

Again, I think the PWHL is more your taste. Check them out.

when Matthews dropped Crosby, someone really shoulda beat the shit out him for it. Don’t like it? Try golf

 

[BM14]

Sadly the elite skill guys on the Leafs will become targets of goonish attacks if your thinking prevails.

Yes. By PUSHING BACK AND SHOWING HEART when one is touched they’ll become targets.

We have a CPA over here with that mental math.

when Matthews dropped Crosby, someone really shoulda beat the shit out him for it. Don’t like it? Try golf

Maybe, if Crosby was in Matthews’ tier anymore. But he’s not.

 

[Fatass]

Yes. By PUSHING BACK AND SHOWING HEART when one is touched they’ll become targets.

We have a CPA over here with that mental math.


Maybe, if Crosby was in Matthews’ tier anymore. But he’s not.

Please explain how your thinking the game should be played keeps the Leaf skilled players (Matthews, for example) from being attacked exactly how Domi attacked Nemec?

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Nemec fights like a pansy!

How can Jersey not respond to that. They are so soft. Leafs bullying team again.

They need a player like Brady Tkachuk!

 

[DaaaaB's]

How did you get to that scenario from what I said?

I literally said do not touch a top 5 player the league.

Again, I think the PWHL is more your taste. Check them out.

It's pretty clear how he got there but you can't seem to follow simple logic. You'd be crying if MacDermid had grabbed Matthews and fed him punches.

 

[HugeInTheShire]

Yes. By PUSHING BACK AND SHOWING HEART when one is touched they’ll become targets.

We have a CPA over here with that mental math.


Maybe, if Crosby was in Matthews’ tier anymore. But he’s not.

Shocker, moves goalposts when it would be his guy getting blasted.

 

[peconcan]

It's pretty clear how he got there but you can't seem to follow simple logic. You'd be crying if MacDermid had grabbed Matthews and fed him punches.

Why didn’t he just go do it then?

 

[DaaaaB's]

Why didn’t he just go do it then?

You'd have to ask him or his coach that but I'd assume they have enough class to not do something like that.

 

[BM14]

Shocker, moves goalposts when it would be his guy getting blasted.

I don’t think you understand what “move goalposts” means.

 

[Primary Assist]

Leafs fan weighing in:

What Domi did was a scumbag move. Oftentimes, those scumbag moves help you win hockey games and bring you closer together as a team.

They can also backfire and cause the other team to rally against you - case in point, when Max's dad pulled the ultimate scumbag move and sucker punched Niedermayer followed by the Devils embarrassing the Leafs to close out the series.

 

[CharasLazyWrister]

He attacked a guy for no reason.

I get it as a chest pounding moment for a hometown fan, but you can’t just permit players to start beating the shit out of unsuspecting players because they had the audacity to play hockey.

Do not touch a top 5 player in the game, and the greatest goal scorer of a generation.

End of story.

If you don’t like it, try the PWHL.

lol

There is no way in hell you’d be okay with this if it wasn’t your guy doing the beating up.

 

[Neil Racki]

leafs players do something- it was cheap and dirty!
leafs players dont do anything- this team is soft!

i loved what domi did. Was what Nemec did worth a scrap? not really. But id rather a response over nothing. Send a message to other teams.

Last year when Gudas dummied Kampf in the playoffs with a late hit, the entire Toronto line just stood there and did absolutely nothing. Id like to think if that happened this year, that guy is getting jumped by 4 leafs players.

Shoe on other foot ... yall would make a thread on the main boards crying and demanding suspensions

Domi is a POS and this is a perfect example why

 

[Blackjack]

Domi a shit. If i'm a jersey fans, I would be piss off by the lack of response from my team. You can jump a 19years old kid for no reason. Macdermid should have done something useful

We're pretty used to it. I'm surprised our guys weren't patting him on the back and picking up his gloves for him. You could probably drive a car onto the rink and run Jack Hughes over and everyone would just shrug.

 

[tom leafers]

Shoe on other foot ... yall would make a thread on the main boards crying and demanding suspensions

Domi is a POS and this is a perfect example why

that's literally every fan base ever. Show me a fan that doesn't love when someone on their team does something greasy, but hates when it happens to someone on their team.

also obligatory you have Tom Wilson on your team

 

[Neil Racki]

that's literally every fan base ever. Show me a fan that doesn't love when someone on their team does something greasy, but hates when it happens to someone on their team.

also obligatory you have Tom Wilson on your team

mehh .. I generally do subscribe to the "every fan base" notion but I do think there is a line.

Domi just jumps unsuspecting people as his MO. its such a scum bag move that hes done so many times that this is beyond "every fanbase" thing.

if I was leafs fan i wouldnt be defending Domi .. and Id bet most leafs fans thought he was scumbag Steve before he joined the Leafs.

i guess easy enough for me to say as a non leafs fan

 

[tom leafers]

mehh .. I generally do subscribe to the "every fan base" notion but I do think there is a line.

Domi just jumps unsuspecting people as his MO. its such a scum bag move that hes done so many times that this is beyond "every fanbase" thing.

if I was leafs fan i wouldnt be defending Domi .. and Id bet most leafs fans thought he was scumbag Steve before he joined the Leafs.

i guess easy enough for me to say as a non leafs fan

Just like i hate Wilson and another example Marchand but would absolutely love having either of them on my team.

Im not disagreeing with you about Domi, but i would much rather have him then not have him. He plays that fine line that gets people rattled but also isnt an offensive black hole. you need as many of those guys as you can get come playoff time.

 

[bov]

Typical Domi.

"Don't touch the best goal scorer in the game then"

He wouldn't have done a damn thing if MacDermid roughed up Matthews. Domi is very selective when it comes to being a stand up teammate. Hopefully the day comes when someone gives him a taste of his own medicine.

 

[Sheppy]

Typical Domi.

"Don't touch the best goal scorer in the game then"

He wouldn't have done a damn thing if MacDermid roughed up Matthews. Domi is very selective when it comes to being a stand up teammate. Hopefully the day comes when someone gives him a taste of his own medicine.

He spotpicks like no other, and again, rarely ever gives a guy a chance.

 

[tarheelhockey]

Do not touch a top 5 player in the game, and the greatest goal scorer of a generation.

End of story.

If you don’t like it, try the PWHL.

Wait, how are you gonna pull the “try the PWHL” card in the SAME POST that you’re saying players should literally not be allowed to touch each other?

It’s not like he cheapshotted Matthews. He just bodied him off the puck. If Matthews can’t handle that, there’s always the PWHL, no?