Should they be Hall of Famers?

Should they be Hall of Famers?

  • Pete Rose

    Votes: 16 72.7%
  • Shoeless Joe Jackson

    Votes: 14 63.6%
  • Barry Bonds

    Votes: 17 77.3%
  • Roger Clemens

    Votes: 16 72.7%
  • Don Mattingly

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • Lou Whitaker

    Votes: 5 22.7%
  • Fred McGriff

    Votes: 6 27.3%
  • Mark McGwire

    Votes: 6 27.3%
  • Dale Murphy

    Votes: 2 9.1%
  • Orel Hershiser

    Votes: 1 4.5%
  • Thurman Munson

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • Tommy John

    Votes: 5 22.7%
  • Gil Hodges

    Votes: 2 9.1%
  • Dave Parker

    Votes: 3 13.6%
  • Curt Schilling

    Votes: 1 4.5%
  • Scott Rolen

    Votes: 1 4.5%

  • Total voters
    22

HajdukSplit

Registered User
Nov 9, 2005
11,034
762
NJ
Rose, Bonds, Clemens, Jackson absolutely
I would put both Mattingly and McGriff in, similar numbers but I understand most see them as borderline. Reluctantly voted for McGwire, just for the home runs alone even though it’s tainted. Voted for Hodges too but I’m a biased Mets fan :nod:
 

Neutrinos

Registered User
Sep 23, 2016
8,587
3,597
I wouldn't put Rose in the Hall while he's still alive

Once he's dead, and can no longer enjoy the perks of being a Hall of Famer? Sure, put him in
 

Kaners Bald Spot

Registered User
Dec 6, 2011
22,704
10,812
Kane County, IL
I wouldn't put Rose in the Hall while he's still alive

Once he's dead, and can no longer enjoy the perks of being a Hall of Famer? Sure, put him in
I believe anyone who received a lifetime ban, should be allowed to go in after they pass.

Except roiders, because you don't know if they would have been HOFers without the roids. (Notable exception to Barry Bonds)

I disagree with the term "permanently ineligible" and agree with the term "lifetime ban" and a lifetime ban is over when that person's life ends.
 

MS

1%er
Mar 18, 2002
53,362
83,417
Vancouver, BC
Outside of the obvious Bonds/Clemens situation, the one guy on that list who should obviously be in the BHOF is Lou Whitaker. Especially now that Trammell is in.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->