If he went in as some kind of contributor instead of a player would that change your %?McGriff, Murphy, Herschiser and Hodges are my only 'No' votes there
Tommy John is borderline, but I think he makes a good yes/no line
I believe anyone who received a lifetime ban, should be allowed to go in after they pass.I wouldn't put Rose in the Hall while he's still alive
Once he's dead, and can no longer enjoy the perks of being a Hall of Famer? Sure, put him in
Go on...I totally agree. He has .1 WAR less than Bench and 1.1 WAR more than Reggie Jackson. I found a stat I like better than WAR and it ranks him as the 5th best 2B since 1920.