Should Minnesota begin a full rebuild?

Hischier and Hughes

“I love to hockey”
Jan 28, 2018
9,408
4,357
After creating a trade thread for Jonas Brodin I came across some Minnesota fans who explained to me the direction Minnesota’s GM Fenton is likely headed and it had me wondering:

Shouldn’t Minnesota be going into a full rebuild? Well lets take a closer look:

Their top three point producers last year are 34 years old in Parise Staal and Suter (since they traded Granlund). Obviously I think Dumba could have contested if he stayed healthy. Then Koivu whos 35 was their sixth highest producer.

Minnesota has some nice young pieces on the NHL offense like Fiala, Greenway, Kunin, Donato, and Eriksson-Ek. But nothing in the higher end category and some of these guys are very young and will take a few years or so to develop properly.

Then on defense: great defense with some nice young pieces. Dumba, Brodin, and Spurgeon although hes 29 (and is rumored to be available). Suter obviously isnt getting any younger but can mentor the youth coming up for a while longer.

Goaltending - Dubnyk and Stalock are both over 31 years old. Prospect wise I cannot attest to what they have but its not common for a starting goaltender to bloom immediately when he hits the league. Granted Dubnyk is only 32 turning 33 - if they have a prospext coming up he’d have to start getting some sheltered time in the next year or two.

I cannot speak to the prospects Minnesota has so Im sure they have a few guys who may compete to step up next year. However, unless their prospect pool is overflowing with tons of middle to high end talent just waiting to hit the NHL.... even then that would takes 2-3 years to develop to a level where youd likely see results befitting of their status.

For a team who has not passed the first round in quite some time - as well as missing entirely last year - their GM seems to be content with making some moves to be competitive next year (according to the fans I spoke to here on HF). So to that I ask:

What gives? A roster thats up there in the top 5-7 oldest teams with barely any success to show for it. And unless their prospect pool is packed with high-end talent to replace three of their best players and then some over the next few years...

Do you think Minnesota should blow it up? Have they been mediocre for too long to begin a sustainable run of success? Is their prospect pool in line with their roster’s current age?

Curious to hear other teams’ opinions on the matter as to me it seems like Minnesota is a team who should be moving on to a new direction when the last hasn’t worked for the majority of this decade.
 

Hischier and Hughes

“I love to hockey”
Jan 28, 2018
9,408
4,357
Parise and Suter are untradeable with their contracts. They're stuck like Detroit was with Zetterberg/Datsyuk until they're off the books.
Dont we all think Detroit wasted some years not beginning the rebuild?

Wouldnt be the end of the world to keep these guys as mentors for the young ones coming in. Problem is if the owners want to pay that much for it.
 

IWantSakicAsMyGM

Registered User
Oct 13, 2011
9,718
3,934
Colorado
He's also attempting to come back from a career threatening injury that cost him this past season, IIRC.

That was Brandon Sutter. Ryan Suter has played 82 games in 3 of the last 4 seasons.

As for Suter, I don't know many teams that are interested in acquiring a 34 year old D making $7.5m for the next 6 years. He's still worth it now, but the last 2-4 years of that contract could be ugly.
 

zxc55555

Registered User
Oct 19, 2018
13
4
That was Brandon Sutter. Ryan Suter has played 82 games in 3 of the last 4 seasons.

Ryan Suter had an injury prior to last year's playoffs. We played against Winnipeg shorthanded without him. I do not know how bad the injury was, but I know his quality of play this season was in question.
 

IWantSakicAsMyGM

Registered User
Oct 13, 2011
9,718
3,934
Colorado
Ryan Suter had an injury prior to last year's playoffs. We played against Winnipeg shorthanded without him. I do not know how bad the injury was, but I know his quality of play this season was in question.

Yes, he broke his ankle, and there was some question about whether he'd be ready for the season. But, at the end of the season, he still played all 82 games, still averaged 26+ minutes per game, and was 4 points off from his career high in scoring.
 

BHD

Vejmelka for Vezina
Dec 27, 2009
38,124
16,511
Moncton, NB
They already are. They moved on from Granlund, Niederreiter, Coyle; almost did the same with Zucker; and might be doing so with Spurgeon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricky Bobby

TheTwelfth

Registered User
Jan 6, 2014
1,107
227
The Tardis
I dont get this. They are in a rebuild. They are not trading Parise and Suter because they cannot find buyers that wont send crap returns, or ask for a lot of retention most likely. This isnt EA NHL where you can trick the opposing franchises into taking your expensive contracts. Similar to Detroit, they are handcuffed by some contracts signed under previous CBA.
 

MNRube

Registered User
Oct 20, 2013
5,972
2,830
Parise and Suter are still worth their contracts. Parise had a good year.

Kaprizov is probably coming after next season. Add a pick at #12 like Newhook

Greenway, Kunin, Kaprizov, Newhook, Eriksson Ek, Fiala, Donato is a decent young group of forwards.

Blueline will stay good for awhile so dont have to worry too much there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Al Lagoon

PerimeterPlier

Registered User
Mar 8, 2019
59
53
Well, they are doing a rebuild of sorts. They're just keeping a handful of highly paid underperforming veterans on the team as well, because trading them isnt an option for one reason or another. There's the contracts, especially of Parise, and getting rid of Koivu could be a PR nightmare.

Trading Niederreiter for Rask was a quality tank commander move, but Fenton needs to do more. The team still looks mediocre, and that's not good enough for a top pick, so to speak. And boy do they need that top pick bad, I'd say they need it the most in the league..
 

Hischier and Hughes

“I love to hockey”
Jan 28, 2018
9,408
4,357
They already are. They moved on from Granlund, Niederreiter, Coyle; almost did the same with Zucker; and might be doing so with Spurgeon.
I was told by a 3-4 Minnesota fans over in the Trade section that Fenton plans on only moving players for better assets and doesnt want to stockpile picks and prospects. Apparently Fenton will try to be competitive for a playoff spot again next year instead of just sell sell sell
 

Hischier and Hughes

“I love to hockey”
Jan 28, 2018
9,408
4,357
I dont get this. They are in a rebuild. They are not trading Parise and Suter because they cannot find buyers that wont send crap returns, or ask for a lot of retention most likely. This isnt EA NHL where you can trick the opposing franchises into taking your expensive contracts. Similar to Detroit, they are handcuffed by some contracts signed under previous CBA.
So why keep Zucker, Spurgeon, Brodin, Staal, etc.?

And again I was told Minnesota plans on being competitive next year. That doesnt scream rebuild to me when they havent had any playoff success for over five years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IlikeEich

IceBoxHockey

Registered User
Feb 14, 2016
625
531
So why keep Zucker, Spurgeon, Brodin, Staal, etc.?

And again I was told Minnesota plans on being competitive next year. That doesnt scream rebuild to me when they havent had any playoff success for over five years.

That’s why Fenton has been trading our underperforming playoff performers for younger players with upside. Well, minus Rask. You can still be competitive well retooling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Al Lagoon

Hischier and Hughes

“I love to hockey”
Jan 28, 2018
9,408
4,357
That’s why Fenton has been trading our underperforming playoff performers for younger players with upside. Well, minus Rask. You can still be competitive well retooling.
But does that really make much sense?

Im not saying tank tank tank, but youll be picking 12-17 over and over if you keep trying to be competitive. Look at Detroit, they did this and now theyre falling off hard for a few years and are getting high picks for it.

Why extend how long it takes to rebuild when you can just bite the bullet and move some of your better guys for better assets and speed it up - even if the falloff is quick and harsh?
 

IceBoxHockey

Registered User
Feb 14, 2016
625
531
But does that really make much sense?

Im not saying tank tank tank, but youll be picking 12-17 over and over if you keep trying to be competitive. Look at Detroit, they did this and now theyre falling off hard for a few years and are getting high picks for it.

Why extend how long it takes to rebuild when you can just bite the bullet and move some of your better guys for better assets and speed it up - even if the falloff is quick and harsh?

We still have one of the better defensive groups in the league. It doesn’t make sense to go full rebuild mode with that group intact.

You seem to think that a rebuild guarantees success. It doesn’t, that can be seen with many teams in this league. At this point, I’d much rather try a retool than a full rebuild.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bun Cook

Uncle Scrooge

Hockey Bettor
Nov 14, 2011
13,479
8,022
Helsinki
I think they're in a similar situation as Anaheim.

The veteran core isn't worth trading as their value is low compared to what it used to be either because of regression in performance or contract.

For the Wild, Zucker-Spurgeon-Dubnyk is the big trio from value perspective and 2 of those guys have modified NTC's. Are the assets you get back really worth sucking for many years to come ?

Maybe you get something for Staal but he just signed there and also has a M-NTC, perhaps Pateryn can get you a pick.

But i don't think there's enough to make it worth it. It would be a different story if Parise and Suter got them big hauls. Just like with the Ducks if they could trade Perry and Kesler.

Re-tool just makes the most sense in the current situation if you're looking for change. You have the veteran core, might as well do what you can with it. It's inevitable the bad years will come anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bun Cook

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->