The line-matching by Babcock killed us tonight. They managed to completely neutralize the Duchene line. The Stone-Brassard line had its offensive moments, but they were guilty of defensive mistakes. That's when our defense should be able to pick up the slack, but they were completely exposed tonight.
It's in a game like this that Methot is missed the most. That stabilizing presence, the calm, the strength, the mistake-free play.
Another very noticeable difference is that when we have the puck in the O-zone, it's usually just our 3 forwards kind of left alone to fend for themselves (Toronto in contrast has a 5-man presence in our zone). Sure, Karlsson is there too, but when he's there things are fairly chaotic (which can be a good thing sometimes: to score goals it's not a bad thing to be unpredictable). But we don't have the kind of point guy who pinches in, provides a passing outlet, can move the puck around quickly, can be a shooting threat, just keep things simple and effective. We have each of these things individually in each defenseman, but the whole package is missing (Chabot should get there soon hopefully).
Amazingly, Boro seems to be the closest to the complete package these days. That's good for Boro and a bad sign for the rest of our defense.
If we want to compete again soon, we need a major upgrade to our top 4 defense.