Carrick is okay for a 6th/7th D man on a somewhat weaker squad.. Actually by the time he got back in the lineup on NJD roster last season he was actually looking pretty good all things considered. It was clear though, he was not in the picture for Ruff (for whatever reasons), which pretty much ended his chances with NJ. I felt he maybe could have had a more opportunities last season, but Ruff didn't go to him until late in the season. Not faulting Ruff, just stating the facts.
I wasn't so low on him as some other NJD posters, but I don't see his potential being much better than a 6th.. but who knows. One thing I can say is from all the interviews, off-ice media, he trains hard, he's good with his nutrition, competes hard, and has a strong willpower/character work-ethic.
In a way, I will kind of miss him.