Kane is not a complete player-he can't backcheck his grandmother (he is more effective on the forecheck-not that he knocks anyone off the puck-he can't-but his quick stick on the forecheck does let him come aaway with the puck in scrums;obn the back-check he is useless because: 1. He is not strong enough to battlee the opposing forward off the puck and 2. He doesn't sustain his effort long enough when he is even with the guy he's trying to check (again a strength issue) ..and 3. He doesn't have enogh straight-line recovery speed to catch up to back check a guy who has gotten away from him/gotten by him (as opposed to say Kessel who is very speedy and could do so IF he appliedhimself); Kane it seems to me realizes these deficiencies on his backcheck and so gives up futilley toooften once a guy tries to get by him or succeeds in doing so...It also seems to me that Kane has little positioning clue at times in defending the lanes in his own zone--THAT,unlike the backchecking issue,is rectifiable with good coaching...the backcheck problem has more to do with strength and straight -line speed WHICH HE LACKS ( Kane when attacking with the puck is speedier than most but that is more due to agility/quickness in zig-zagging through and around defenders like they were pylons
rather than just sustained straight line speed ,or if he does go straight line on attack,it is more from anticipation and intial quick step accleration than the longer sustained catch-up speed one uses in backchecking--they are really 2 quite separeate manifestions of using speed..WHat I am saying is that guys CAN PULL AWAY from KANE quite easily and counter attack,but conversely on his attack,he can control the puck and is hard to check not so much from straight on speed,but more from his agility to turn at his top speed on a dime,Or if you do manage to get to him,the puck gets off his stick so fast on a shot or a pass to a linemate that you simply don't have time to check him effectively...
Thus KANE is NOT A COMPLETE 2-way player--but he is a MAGNIFICENT OFFENSIVE
ATTACKER...this means he still might be a great pick--but "safe" only inthat he can put up points,NOT SAFE in that he won't do much to prevent points being scored against his shift --you need to rely on others on your team to "cover" for his defensive liabilities.