Value of: Ryan Poehling to Det.
- Thread starter LazyT
- Start date
Bouboumaster
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2014
- 9,679
- 7,728
It will depends of Bergevin's plan for Danault I guess, but I'd be open to look at a trade.
We don't need bodies, picks would be sufficiant I guess
We don't need bodies, picks would be sufficiant I guess
Ghost of Ethan Hunt
The Official Ghost of Space Ghosts Monkey
Maybe Mantha+ Bernier@50% for Romanov+Poehling+Allen as a base?
MTL has to move salary out/back.
Bernier 5th best 5on5 SV% in NHL, .750 Win%, I wanna retain Bernier & resign him as UFA, hate to lose him.
EDIT: Poehling....27gp, 2pts, -4 in NHL 19/20. Is he a probable bust?
Too soon to tell?
MTL has to move salary out/back.
Bernier 5th best 5on5 SV% in NHL, .750 Win%, I wanna retain Bernier & resign him as UFA, hate to lose him.
EDIT: Poehling....27gp, 2pts, -4 in NHL 19/20. Is he a probable bust?
Too soon to tell?
Ghost of Ethan Hunt
The Official Ghost of Space Ghosts Monkey
Dr Quincy
Registered User
- Jun 19, 2005
- 28,697
- 10,544
Dr Quincy
Registered User
- Jun 19, 2005
- 28,697
- 10,544
Ghost of Ethan Hunt
The Official Ghost of Space Ghosts Monkey
I don't follow the Habs or their prospects, so let's hear your feedback on Poehling, the trade etc.
That moment when a Poehling thread goes off the rails.
Dr Quincy
Registered User
- Jun 19, 2005
- 28,697
- 10,544
Feedback: A Det fan asked about Poehling. You throwing Romanov into the deal would again be like someone asking about Rasmussen and then adding Seider into the deal.
As I said... Poehling's value/floor/ceiling are all similar to Rasmussen.
Bouboumaster
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2014
- 9,679
- 7,728
Poehling is no offensive juggernaut, that's for sure lol
This year he had the misfortune to play behind Suzuki, Kotkaniemi, Danault and Evans. We don't know what the future holds for him, but he's a lottery ticket, in a way. Still a big player able to play 200 ft games with an edge.
Romanov can't get out. He's already our best LD (better than Edmunson and Chiarot) and so we can't part way with him (positional needs :/ )
Can we replace him by another prospect? Or a player with picks (we already have to send you salary, so...)
For Poehling alone, picks would suffice
you serious? As a base? montreal isn't giving up that for a 50 pt, injury prone winger. Yes I know how great mantra is, montreal would like him blah blah.
They're not dealing Romanov period, and will hold poehling until they figure out what to do with Tatar and Danault - as they could use his size on the wing.
and allen has been better than price, so that aint happening. not a chance.
terrible trade
working off of hockey DB i see. His ceiling is probably a no.3 C with size who can chip in 15-20 goals - or a two-way winger in a top 9 role.
He's not a bust. yet. Injuries derailed him last year. He's been progressing in laval this year
So ignoring the Romanov stuff. Would something around like Svech+3rd be in the ball park? Or am I still totally off base? Like I said I’m not sure how he’s viewed in Montreal still. Or is it just a case of a trade not really working between the 2 teams?
Ceiling is a third line center at best . Bottom 6 forward . Change of scenery could help . Commitment issues are prevalent
If the Habs are sellers, then this pairing of teams doesn't make a lot of sense. Why trade Poehling for picks? Just keep him and develop him if the team is looking to the future.
If the Habs are buyers to get into the playoff mix and stay there, then Poehling for pieces that can help this season might make sense.
If the Habs are buyers to get into the playoff mix and stay there, then Poehling for pieces that can help this season might make sense.
What? That never happened unless you can prove it
Don't see any reason to trade Poehling right now. We won't get decent value anyway. Better look letting him develop in the AHL under Bouchard.
After scoring a hat trick in his first game he thought he was already belonging and stopped working (hard enough at least). Got a few injuries last year too.
I want to see what a full year in the AHL does for him, if he busts, well shit happens. We're used to 1st round bust in Montreal anyway...
After scoring a hat trick in his first game he thought he was already belonging and stopped working (hard enough at least). Got a few injuries last year too.
I want to see what a full year in the AHL does for him, if he busts, well shit happens. We're used to 1st round bust in Montreal anyway...
Kudo Shinichi
Registered User
- Apr 20, 2012
- 20,512
- 26,530
If poehling is traded, it will be in a package for a better player.
Doesnt really make sense to trade him for a pick or a similar caliber prospect.
Doesnt really make sense to trade him for a pick or a similar caliber prospect.
If the Habs are sellers at the TDL then I don't really see them as realistic partners with the Wings. Both teams would want to use roster players to acquire picks, rather than the other way around.
If the Habs are buyers at the TDL, then maybe as part of a package to acquire Mantha would be the only trade I see working. And he wouldn't be a centerpiece in the deal, but a throw in.
If the Habs are buyers at the TDL, then maybe as part of a package to acquire Mantha would be the only trade I see working. And he wouldn't be a centerpiece in the deal, but a throw in.
pth2
Registered User
- Jan 7, 2018
- 3,140
- 2,325
A 2nd rounder and he's yours now, a 3d rounder on draftday if some of great intrest is still available.
Ideally, an equivalent stalled prospect who also might blossom after a change of scenery.
Guys, stop taking every thread and asking for other team's bext players, a minor deal can work.
Ideally, an equivalent stalled prospect who also might blossom after a change of scenery.
Guys, stop taking every thread and asking for other team's bext players, a minor deal can work.
Captain97
Registered User
We can't trade him until the Danault situation is sorted out.
Cause if we don't resign Danault Poehling will be our 3C in a year or 2.
The answer from what poehling is likely Lars Eller with a mean streak. 30-40 points solid defefensively, and likes to hit people.
Could be better, could be worse. But physical, checking, 3C is likely.
Cause if we don't resign Danault Poehling will be our 3C in a year or 2.
The answer from what poehling is likely Lars Eller with a mean streak. 30-40 points solid defefensively, and likes to hit people.
Could be better, could be worse. But physical, checking, 3C is likely.
Ghost of Ethan Hunt
The Official Ghost of Space Ghosts Monkey
Thanks for the feedback. The "likes to hit people" part is the kinda old school hockey that is missing from today's NHL. Most players that hit, do so to earn TOI, coaches/teammates trust & respect, a bigger contract etc. Often though, many just go through the motions. Konstantinov approves of Poehling, send over the papers.
FrankMTL
Registered User
- Jan 6, 2005
- 12,196
- 13,088
I personally wouldn't trade him right now, especially for a pick. We have enough picks, especially 2nd and 3rd rounds picks. We might as well hold onto him to see him he can develop into a competent NHL centre. He has the size and speed for sure.
