It was 3 years and how did he just come back seeing as he pitched this entire past season? As previously stated, the A's bullpen was utter trash last year and this was a necessary risk. It may not work out, but I thoroughly enjoy the fact that management diagnosed the biggest issue the team had and are trying to fix it.
You're grasping at anything at this point.
It's the fact that Oakland, a team that's always been tight with the budget, is doing this. I can see the point if they were going to trade another relief pitcher and use Madson to replace the guy, basically adding free prospects, but nope.
We saw how poorly Madson dealt in pressure situations. You can even argue that Ryan Madson was Kansas City's worst player in the post season nearly blowing 2 games.
It just isn't a logical move.