I hope Chevy does everything he can to make the team better while our window for the cup is open. I would do the Stastny pickup 10/10 times.
I hope Chevy does everything he can to keep the window for the cup open for as long as possible.
Rentals are less likely to get us a cup than having 5-10 more years of contending will.
As good as Stastny was, he cost us a likely Little replacement - plus Erik Foley. And he didn't get us a cup.
Next TD we will probably lose another Little replacement or even a Trouba replacement. The return probably doesn't make the difference between getting a cup and not that time either.
Then, in another year we will lose Trouba, still with no replacement in sight. Buff will be entering the last year of his contract. Myers will be playing 2nd pair on a contract he can't live up to. Roslovic will be a 3C playing 2C. Also with no relief in sight. We will be a cap strapped bubble team.
The prices of rentals are massively disproportional to their contribution. Occasionally they may get a team a cup but they always shorten the window of contention. You pay the same price for 2-3 mos of a player as you would otherwise have to pay for 7-15 years of an equivalent player.