TP
Global Moderator
- Dec 2, 2008
- 50,458
- 23,768
Should we continue, though?
Rogue One was a mess. Even with the issues this has, I'd much rather watch RoS again.
Rogue One was a well made movie, but the characters were cardboard cutouts and the main character had a textbook example of informed attributes.Rogue One was a mess. Even with the issues this has, I'd much rather watch RoS again.
No, this movie is so awful it doesn't even generate interesting discussions.
At least TLJ discussions helped identify a whole bunch of scumbags.
I did have one bit of fun with this. I turned to my wife and said "The only way this can get worse is if dead Jedi Masters help her" and a second later they did.
They took everything good from the first six films and destroyed it to make a horrible movie.
If the rumour from the other thread is true about there being 7 hours in the original cut that had to be edited down... not sure why they didn't pull a Harry Potter and split this into two releases, Dec and May.
Then you'd have the time to set up the finale properly AND close it out without everyone going WTF.
Please elaborate
If the rumour from the other thread is true about there being 7 hours in the original cut that had to be edited down... not sure why they didn't pull a Harry Potter and split this into two releases, Dec and May.
Then you'd have the time to set up the finale properly AND close it out without everyone going WTF.
Do I really need to? I mean a lot of the toxicity associated with TLJ was just bigoted garbage. We even saw some of it just last thread.
Yes, you can take issue with TLJ without being a bigot. Bigots just really hated TLJ.
You’re painting with an awful wide brush. It was executives on the Disney side who suggested the reason people didn’t like TLJ was their bigotry. The executives saying that are the simple minded bigots whose egos are ofc the charts. TLJ was a farce of a movie. It’s beyond trash. RoS isn’t much better but look at what it had to follow.
Can you provide evidence of how many people who didn’t like TLJ are indeed bigots vs how many aren’t??
You’re painting with an awful wide brush. It was executives on the Disney side who suggested the reason people didn’t like TLJ was their bigotry. The executives saying that are the simple minded bigots whose egos are ofc the charts. TLJ was a farce of a movie. It’s beyond trash. RoS isn’t much better but look at what it had to follow.
Can you provide evidence of how many people who didn’t like TLJ are indeed bigots vs how many aren’t??
The problems with TLJ are things like stupid subplots that go nowhere, the movie ending with Kylo getting owned, not really setting up a third act etc....
I'll let you imagine what kind of criticism constitutes bigotry.
The only way this is true is if you have zero imagination.
The problems with TLJ are things like stupid subplots that go nowhere, the movie ending with Kylo getting owned, not really setting up a third act etc....
I'll let you imagine what kind of criticism constitutes bigotry.
You’re the one making grand statements about bigotry. You made it sound as if there was this massive revelation when discussing TLJ that identified for you a vast amount of bigots. All I’m asking for is some kind of numbers or evidence or really anything.
You’re the one making a claim. I’m just asking you for any proof.
Indeed I did make such a claim. Reading comprehension is clearly not your strong suit so I'll leave it at that.
If you identify with the bigots, that is your problem. Not mine.