the award is a toss up. not much is known about what managers actually do to help their team. the narrative tells us that farrell rode into town and kicked the **** out of everyone in the dressing room and took the title back to boston.
that's not really the only narrative though. i think it's fair to bring up the red sox's payroll compared to other teams. i think it's fair to look at what other teams had to do without the resources that the red sox gave farrell.
again, this could have gone to about five different managers and i wouldn't have had a problem with it. same with the nl rookie of the year. could have gone to puig or fernandez. al rookie could have gone to myers or archer. the al manager could have gone to melvin, showalter, girardi, francona, farrell or maddon. any one of them could have won it and i wouldn't have had a problem with it.