Rate These Prospects Please

[firstimekeeperpoolie]

Please rate these prospects by expected career points (not by the better all around player)

Forwards:
Pacioretty
Johansen
Ennis
Beach
C. Wilson
Hodgson
Landeskog
JT Miller
Petrov
Couturier
Tangradi
Granlund
Omark
Zuccarello

Defense
Larsson
Petry
Marincin
Faulk
Aulie
Kindl
Elliot
Gardiner

Click to read more...

 

[member 30781]

Forwards:

Ryan Johansen
Gabriel Landeskog
Mikael Granlund
Colin Wilson
Tyler Ennis
Sean Couturier
Tyler Ennis
Max Pacioretty
Eric Tangradi
Cody Hodgson
Linus Omark
JT Miller
Mats Zuccarello
Kyle Beach
Kirill Petrov - only because no one knows if he is ever going to come over or not.


Defense:

Adam Larsson
Justin Faulk
Stefan Elliott
Jake Gardiner
Jakub Kindl
Jeff Petry
Keith Aulie
Martin Marincin

Just my take.

 

[enthropi]

Forwards:

Ryan Johansen
Gabriel Landeskog
Mikael Granlund
Colin Wilson
Tyler Ennis
Sean Couturier
Tyler Ennis
Max Pacioretty
Eric Tangradi
Cody Hodgson
Linus Omark
JT Miller
Mats Zuccarello
Kyle Beach
Kirill Petrov - only because no one knows if he is ever going to come over or not.


Defense:

Adam Larsson
Justin Faulk
Stefan Elliott
Jake Gardiner
Jakub Kindl
Jeff Petry
Keith Aulie
Martin Marincin

Just my take.

Marincin, as a rookie, put up 23 pts more than Aulie's best season ever, I don't know how you can rate Marincin below, Aulie has next to zero offensive upside.

The rest seems about right except for Ennis being mentioned twice.

 

[urho]

Larsson may become the best d-man of that group but I don't think he'll have the most career points.

 

[NUhockey]

Forwards:

Ryan Johansen
Gabriel Landeskog
Mikael Granlund
Colin Wilson
Tyler Ennis
Sean Couturier
Tyler Ennis
Max Pacioretty
Eric Tangradi
Cody Hodgson
Linus Omark
JT Miller
Mats Zuccarello
Kyle Beach
Kirill Petrov - only because no one knows if he is ever going to come over or not.


Defense:

Adam Larsson
Justin Faulk
Stefan Elliott
Jake Gardiner
Jakub Kindl
Jeff Petry
Keith Aulie
Martin Marincin

Just my take.

You can end the thread with this great list (although i'm not too high on Landeskog), but did you want to put Ennis before or after Couturier? Personally, I'd put him after.

 

[QMJHLfollower]

Forwards:

Couturier
Granlund
Johansen
Landeskog
Ennis
Pacioretty
Wilson
Tangradi
Omark
JT Miller
Zuccarello
Beach
Hodgson
Petrov

Defensemans:

Larsson
Elliot
Faulk
Gardiner
Petry
Marincin
Kindl
Aulie

 

[member 30781]

You can end the thread with this great list (although i'm not too high on Landeskog), but did you want to put Ennis before or after Couturier? Personally, I'd put him after.

Meant to put him after.

 

[Crede777]

Forwards:

Ryan Johansen
Gabriel Landeskog
Mikael Granlund
Colin Wilson
Sean Couturier
Tyler Ennis
Max Pacioretty
Eric Tangradi
Cody Hodgson
Linus Omark
JT Miller
Mats Zuccarello
Kyle Beach
Kirill Petrov - only because no one knows if he is ever going to come over or not.


Defense:

Adam Larsson
Justin Faulk
Stefan Elliott
Jake Gardiner
Jakub Kindl
Jeff Petry
Martin Marincin
Keith Aulie

Just my take.

Edited for how I think they'd go (and removed one Ennis). Top 3 between Johansen, Landeskog, and Granlund is debateable depending on what you're looking for. Also, Couturier will surprise many who expect him to top out as a 2nd line 2-way player.

 

[HockeySauce]

Forwards:

Johansen
Couturier
Ennis
Landeskog
Granlund
Hodgson
C.Wilson
Beach
Miller
Pacioretty
Omark
Tangradi
Zuccarello

Petrov - don't know anything about him

Defense:

Larsson
Elliot
Gardiner
Faulk
Kindl
Petry
Marincin
Aulie

 

[buffaloburger]

I see Pacioretty as the real deal here. Has great vision, moves the puck well and doesnt lose battles along the boards. Hockey IQ is very high.

 

[ESH]

Ryan Johansen
Mikael Granlund
Gabriel Landeskog
Sean Couturier
Tyler Ennis
Cody Hodgson
Maxim Pacioretty
Eric Tangradi
Linus Omark
J.T. Miller
Kyle Beach
Mats Zuccarello
Kirill Petrov
Colin Wilson

Adam Larsson
Stefan Elliott
Justin Faulk
Jake Gardiner
Jeff Petry
Martin Marincin
Keith Aulie
Jakub Kindl

 

[Phion Keneuf]

Ryan Johansen
Mikael Granlund
Gabriel Landeskog
Sean Couturier
Tyler Ennis
Cody Hodgson
Maxim Pacioretty
Eric Tangradi
Linus Omark
J.T. Miller
Kyle Beach
Mats Zuccarello
Kirill Petrov
Colin Wilson

Adam Larsson
Stefan Elliott
Justin Faulk
Jake Gardiner
Jeff Petry
Martin Marincin
Keith Aulie
Jakub Kindl

lol what ?

 

[Phion Keneuf]

Granlund
Johansen
Ennis
Wilson
Landeskog
Pacioretty
Couturier
Tangradi
Miller
Hodgson
Omark
Zuccarello
Petrov
Beach



Larsson
Elliot
Gardiner
Marincin
Kindl
Faulk
Petry
Aulie

 

[R S]

Good to see Stef getting listed high on these orders. This question last year would have had him near the bottom of the pack of those blueliners just bc of a lack of exposure on here.

 

[Barzilla]

Out of all the islander prospects you choose Petrov? Strange choice any sort of classification or grouping what soever? Nope

 

[R S]

Out of all the islander prospects you choose Petrov? Strange choice any sort of classification or grouping what soever? Nope

It's probably for a fantasy league where he holds the rights to certain players. It likely has nothing to do with "choosing" Petrov over other Islander prospects.

 

[Havok89]

I see Ennis as the best pure offensive player in that forward group, but his overall game won't compare to a few others on that list.

 

[R S]

I see Ennis as the best pure offensive player in that forward group, but his overall game won't compare to a few others on that list.

Granlund over Ennis

 

[Samzilla]

I see Pacioretty as the real deal here. Has great vision, moves the puck well and doesnt lose battles along the boards. Hockey IQ is very high.

I c wut u did there.

 

[firstimekeeperpoolie]

Thanks for the help guys - really appreciate it.

The only thing that was "news" to me, was how high most of you have Faulk, and how low many of you have Kindl?

Any expansion on that? Is it even close between those 2? Have many of you seen both of them play?

Thanks.

 

[ItsTheBGB]

I'm stunned about Petry being this under rated. Maybe I'm just blinded by love, but I see him as a number 2 defenseman, like legit.

 

[Selanne138]

I'm stunned about Petry being this under rated. Maybe I'm just blinded by love, but I see him as a number 2 defenseman, like legit.

OP just looking for point totals not overall skill as a defenseman.

 

[ItsTheBGB]

Forwards:
Landeskog
Johansen
Couturier
Granlund
Ennis
Pacioretty
Wilson
Omark
Tangradi
Miller
Zuccarello
Hodgson
Beach
Petrov

Defense
Larsson
Elliot
Petry
Gardiner
Marincin
Kindl
Aulie
Faulk