Ranking Defenseman #3

[Digitalbooya]

Continue on. I added Mike Reilly!

1. Suter
2. Brodin
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.

Click to read more...

 

[Spurgeon]

Still Spurge for me.

 

[AKL]

The correct answer was Scandella last time, so it's Scandella again this time as well.

 

[Digitalbooya]

Gotta go with the big man Scandella. Sorry Jared.

 

[Minnesota]

Brodin can't carry a paring like Scandella/Spurgeon.

My personal top-4:

Suter
Scandella
Spurgeon
Brodin

 

[Digitalbooya]

Brodin can't carry a paring like Scandella/Spurgeon.

We'll never know until Suter and him aren't paired together.

 

[Minnesota]

We'll never know until Suter and him aren't paired together.

Yeo has experimented with Suter - Spurgeon.

 

[Spurgeon]

Bunch of Sizeists voting, I tell ya!

 

[TaLoN]

Marco Time!

 

[Wild11MN]

Give me Spurgie again. Dare I say underrated just because he may be the odd one out contract-wise?

Obviously some disagree regardless.

 

[Dr Jan Itor]

Looks like the big shot is swaying some minds. Must say I'm pretty surprised.

 

[Spurgeon]

Looks like the big shot is swaying some minds. Must say I'm pretty surprised.

He had a great year, I'd still like to see him repeat it before I put him over the blueliner that's been with this team the longest and has proven himself.

2-4 is just very close. They're all great players.

 

[Wild48]

Looks like the big shot is swaying some minds. Must say I'm pretty surprised.

I think it's the overall game. Big shot, mobile, physical. I don't argue that Spurgeon didn't have a statistically better year (he killed those fancy stats)... I look at this vote more as who I think will be better next year.

 

[TaLoN]

I think it's the overall game. Big shot, mobile, physical. I don't argue that Spurgeon didn't have a statistically better year (he killed those fancy stats)... I look at this vote more as who I think will be better next year.

I look at it as a combination of what they bring on the ice and the value the individual carries for the team moving forward.

 

[Lapa]

Give me Scandy. Was tempted to pick him ahead of Brodin.

 

[Marlowe Syn]

Scandella all the way for me. He seems to have all the tools you need for a top 4.

 

[grN1g]

Suter missed a few games where Brodin was the man to be #1 and he played liked he belonged in that role if you ask me, it may be premature but his ceiling is alot higher than Scandella/Spurgy and the flashes have been there.

Spurgeron is my #3, his numbers speak very loud, its unfortunate because im one of the fans advocating for him to be traded... cause in reality if im Spurgy i realize my next contract will be my biggest, and im cashing in no matter what... and we(the wild) are not in a position to give him that contract next year or commit long term to him with who we have already signed and in contract + who we have in the pipeline.

in the end hes my #3

Suter
Brodin
Spurgeron
Scandella
Folin
Reilly
Olofsson
Belpeido

 

[TaLoN]

Suter missed a few games where Brodin was the man to be #1 and he played liked he belonged in that role if you ask me, it may be premature but his ceiling is alot higher than Scandella/Spurgy and the flashes have been there.

Spurgeron is my #3, his numbers speak very loud, its unfortunate because im one of the fans advocating for him to be traded... cause in reality if im Spurgy i realize my next contract will be my biggest, and im cashing in no matter what... and we(the wild) are not in a position to give him that contract next year or commit long term to him with who we have already signed and in contract + who we have in the pipeline.

in the end hes my #3

Suter
Brodin
Spurgeron
Scandella
Folin
Reilly
Olofsson
Belpeido

No Dumba?!?!?

 

[Engebretson]

Spurgeon is over Scandy in my book, at this point, but the gap is getting smaller every year.

 

[TZM]

I like Scandy more but Spurgie is still more consistent.