Rank these young wingers

[Kafka]

It's a tought one for me, so I guess I will find different opinions here. Who will be the best player at 28? If you feel this thread should be on an other forum, please mention it. I tought it had its place here since it's not for fantasy games.

- Maxim Afinogenov
- Mike Cammarelli
- Mattias Weinhandl
- Peter Sejna
- Vaclav Nedorost

Click to read more...

 

[Marchy79]

It's a tought one for me, so I guess I will find different opinions here. Who will be the best player at 28? If you feel this thread should be on an other forum, please mention it. I tought it had its place here since it's not for fantasy games.

- Maxim Afinogenov
- Mike Cammarelli
- Mattias Weinhandl
- Peter Sejna
- Vaclav Nedorost

Good question... My list of these 5 talents would be as such;

Mike Cammalleri
Maxim Afinogenov (could be # 1 if he can successfully rebound from those head injuries from a few years back)
Vaclav Nedorost
Peter Sejna
Mattias Weinhandl

Afinogenov could be the best by far if he ever got back his fearlessness to go through the traffic zones... Until then, he'll be stuck at being a decent talent, but having management pulling their hair out because it's obvious he can do so much more. Nedorost I put # 3, but that's only if he gets a shot on another team (I don't think he'll live up to his potential in Florida... to many young guns to fill in roles down there)...

 

[NewHabsEra*]

It's a tought one for me, so I guess I will find different opinions here. Who will be the best player at 28? If you feel this thread should be on an other forum, please mention it. I tought it had its place here since it's not for fantasy games.

- Maxim Afinogenov
- Mike Cammarelli
- Mattias Weinhandl
- Peter Sejna
- Vaclav Nedorost

Afi
Weinh
Cammal
Sejna
Nodorost

 

[Big McLargehuge]

Afinogenov
Cammallerri
Nedorost
Sejna
Weinhandl

 

[Eb0la11]

I would probably put them in this order.
Afinogenov
Weinhandl
Sejna
Cammaleri
Nedorost

Im a little biased toward Weinhandl, I think he could be a decent 20-25 goal guy

 

[surixon]

I would probably put them in this order.
Afinogenov
Weinhandl
Sejna
Cammaleri
Nedorost

Im a little biased toward Weinhandl, I think he could be a decent 20-25 goal guy

camms plays center does he not?

 

[Chartrand]

camms plays center does he not?

I believe he was moved to winger this past season.

 

[Kafka]

He is listed as a center/right winger, but like Lundmark or Marcel Hossa, was moved to the wing after arriving in the NHL.

With the responses I got, I see I was right to say it's a tought one. My personnal ranking is:
1 - Afinogenov
2 - Cammarelli
3 - Nedorost
4 - Weinhandl
5 - Sejna

.... altought, I placed Nedorost third only cause I think he can really play a two-way game while I'm not sure for Weinhandl and Sejna.

While I was sure many of you would have put Afi first, I couldn't expect the others.