Rank These Offensive (Minded) D Men....

[swiftwin]

Read the OP, it says ROOKIE Dmen

No **** sherlock. Im just pointing out that he is younger. Read my post.

 

[Fire Sweeney]

McQuaid is nothing offensively, but he's the best overall of that bunch.

 

[Granlund2Pulkkinen*]

I like the list, but is this for overall, or offense? I am just asking as Fowler and Shatty are kind of low, so I am assuming this is for overall and not offensive dmen?

Yeah this was for overall. If it was offensive I'd have Carlson and EL lower and move up Fowler and Shattenkirk.

 

[Bjindaho]

For offense, it is pretty safe to go with Carlson for tops. His abilities plus Washington's system make him a pretty good bet to be the best in this regard. After him come Fowler, Subban and Shattenkirk in some order. Personally, I think Subban is the best of this bunch and think Fowler/Shattenkirk is pretty much a toss up at this point for offense.

Overall, I am a big Subban fan. I think he will be very good for a very long time. Behind him, I'd have OEL and McBain.

 

[TheRedViper]

No **** sherlock. Im just pointing out that he is younger. Read my post.

Which has no bearing on the thread.

 

[Granlund2Pulkkinen*]

No **** sherlock. Im just pointing out that he is younger. Read my post.

True but irrelevant.

Adam Larsson is younger.

 

[Jayevs]

Overall- Carlson
Offensive-Fowler