I'll just comment on the NCAA guys since that's who I see most often...
1. Montoya
2. Howard
3. Schneider
Al has the most potential of the group and the most talent. Who knows how it'll all package together as far as an NHL career but he should be a good one.
Howard has the tool box, he's inconsistent though. If he can improve on his consistency he could be relied on as a starter at the next level (NHL? AHL?) but otherwise he's going to find himself opening the doors for his teammates.
Schneider, I was never completely sold on him and after seeing him a few times this year plus his Frozen Four meltdown, kids got a lot of work to do. Goalies take longer to develop so by no means am I writing him off (especially since he was only in high school last year) but you expect a little more from a first rounder than just a regular kid coming out of high school. Jerry York should've yanked him after the 3 goals vs. UND in the Frozen Four but he didn't and only god knows what that did to the kids confidence. He was less than stellar vs. Mercyhurst in the Frozen Four, (18 saves, 4 goals allowed). His one shutout, he faced 11 shots.
That's how *I* rank them today, that can change at any point based on their continued development.