Player Discussion Rank our prospects

[Kcb12345]

Title says it all. Honestly not sure of my own rankings yet but want to see what you all do

Click to read more...

 

[BfantZ]

I would say something along the lines of :
Heiskanen
Hintz
Dellandrea
Oettinger
Point
Tufte
Guryanov
Eriksson
Baereuther
Mascherin
Robertson
Caamano
Nyberg

 

[Satan]

1. Miro Heiskanen
2. Jason Robertson
3. Colton Point
4. Adam Mascherin
5. Roope Hintz
6. Nicholas Caamano
7. Jake Oettinger
8. Denis Guryanov
9. Ty Dellandrea
10. Riley Tufte
11. Alban Eriksson
12. Jacob Peterson

bunch of dweebs after this point

 

[AveryStar4Eva]

1. Heiskanen
2. Hintz
3. Robertson
4. Point
5. Oettinger
6. Dellandra
8. Tufte
9. Mascherin
10. Gurianov
11. Caamano
12. Eriksson
13. Bayreuther
14. Nyberg
15. Cecconi

 

[Smelling Salt]

I like Satan's rankings though I would be extremely disappointed if he was correct about his 8/9 order.

 

[Satan]

I like Satan's rankings though I would be extremely disappointed if he was correct about his 8/9 order.

nothing matters to me after #4 because we got our f***in boy

 

[jballa95]

1. Miro Heiskanen
2. Jason Robertson
3. Colton Point
4. Adam Mascherin
5. Ty Dellandrea
6. Roope Hintz
7. Jake Oettinger
8.Nicholas Caamano
9. Riley Tufte
10. Denis Gurianov
11. Alban Eriksson

You could switch around most of these except #1.

 

[Kcb12345]

1. Miro Heiskanen
2. Jason Robertson
3. Colton Point
4. Adam Mascherin
5. Roope Hintz
7. Jake Oettinger
8.Nicholas Caamano
9. Riley Tufte
10. Denis Gurianov

You could switch around most of these except #1.

No Dellandrea or Eriksson?

 

[Klumppa]

1. Heiskanen
2. Point
3. Hintz
4. Robertson
5. Oettinger
6. Tufte
7. Dellandrea
8. Camaano
9. Mascherin
10. Eriksson

 

[jballa95]

No Dellandrea or Eriksson?

I had him in at 5, and he got erased some how (HFboards is acting up). I'm not huge on Eriksson so I placed him at 11, but I don't know much about him at all.

 

[joshik]

1. Miro Heiskanen
2. Ty Dellandrea
3. Roope Hintz
4. Jason Robertson
5. Oskar Bäck
6. Albin Eriksson
7. Colton Point
8. Jake Oettinger
9. Nicholas Caamano
10. Riley Tufte
11. Denis Guryanov
12. Jacob Peterson
13. Adam Mascherin
14.Fredrik Karlström
15.Curtis Douglas
16. John Nyberg
17. Jakob Stenqvist
18.Joseph Cecconi
others doesn´t have NHL potencial. Yes Bayreuther too.

​

 

[M88K]

1. Miro Heiskanen
2. Jason Robertson
3. Colton Point
4. Roope Hintz
5. Nicholas Caamano
6. Jake Oettinger
7: Gavin Bayreuther
8. John Nyberg
9. Ty Dellandrea
10. Joseph Cecconi

 

[marty182]

1. Heiskanen
2. Hintz
3. Dellandrea
4. Point
5. Robertson
6. Tufte
7. Oettinger
8. Mascherin
9. Caamano
10. Bayraither
11. Cecconi

 

[Satan]

1. Miro Heiskanen
2. Jason Robertson
3. Colton Point
4. Roope Hintz
5. Nicholas Caamano
6. Jake Oettinger
7: Gavin Bayreuther
8. John Nyberg
9. Ty Dellandrea
10. Joseph Cecconi

Cecconi is as good as gone bro. Not missing out on much anyway.

 

[FirstRowUpperDeck]

I guess we consider Dickenson to have graduated? He is on no one's list?

 

[M88K]

Cecconi is as good as gone bro. Not missing out on much anyway.

Didn't say he wasn't, but he's still a "prospect" for a year and better than most that we have in the system

 

[BfantZ]

I guess we consider Dickenson to have graduated? He is on no one's list?

I didn’t include anyone who’s played in the nhl other than gury

 

[Kcb12345]

Gonna go with

1. Heiskanen
2. Dellandrea
3. Mascherin
4. Robertson
5. Point
6. Hintz
7. Oettinger
8. Caamano
9. Bayreuther
10. Gurianov
11. Eriksson
12. Tufte

May swap #2 and 4

 

[Satan]

I guess we consider Dickenson to have graduated? He is on no one's list?

Where do you think a mediocre AHLer should be ranked?

 

[FirstRowUpperDeck]

At least above the total bust that is DG, given JD is likely to play in Dallas next year. Brass obviously has higher ranking. Probably a few others, too.

 

[MrHeiskanen]

Where do you think a mediocre AHLer should be ranked?

Higher than your #8 Gurianov.. the AHL scratch.

 

[MrHeiskanen]

1) Heiskanen
2) Robertson
3) Hintz
4) Dellandrea
5) Oettinger
6) Tufte
7) Mascherin
8) Dickinson
9) Point
10) Caamano
11) Nyberg
12) Gurianov
13) Eriksson
14) Bayreuther
15) Stenqvist
16) Peterson
17) Back
18) Karlstrom
19) Hansson
20) Cecconi

 

[Morry83]

Dickinson sucks

 

[Kalamazoo Wings]

Heiskanen
Dellandrea
Robertson
Hintz
Point
Oettenger
Mascherin
Eriksson
Back
Tufte

 

[WhoahNow]

Elite: Heiskanen
Top line/ top paring: N/A
Mid 6 / 2nd pairing: Mascherin, Dellandrea, Eriksson, Back, Hintz, Nichushkin
Bottoms 6/ bottom pairing: Loewen, Caamano, Douglas, Damiani, Barteaux, Tufte, Dickinson, Vala, Heatherington
AHL: Davis, Calderone, Hawel, Peterson, Gurianov, Bayreuther, Stenqvist, Nyberg, Karlstrom

Probably forgetting a lot of prospects

 

[M88K]

Elite: Heiskanen
Top line/ top paring: N/A
Mid 6 / 2nd pairing: Mascherin, Dellandrea, Eriksson, Back, Hintz, Nichushkin
Bottoms 6/ bottom pairing: Loewen, Caamano, Douglas, Damiani, Barteaux, Tufte, Dickinson, Vala, Heatherington
AHL: Davis, Calderone, Hawel, Peterson, Gurianov, Bayreuther, Stenqvist, Nyberg, Karlstrom

Probably forgetting a lot of prospects

Robertson being the big one

 

[FirstRowUpperDeck]

Dickinson sucks

Nice deep analysis. Thanks.

 

[FirstRowUpperDeck]

Elite: Heiskanen
Top line/ top paring: N/A
Mid 6 / 2nd pairing: Mascherin, Dellandrea, Eriksson, Back, Hintz, Nichushkin
Bottoms 6/ bottom pairing: Loewen, Caamano, Douglas, Damiani, Barteaux, Tufte, Dickinson, Vala, Heatherington
AHL: Davis, Calderone, Hawel, Peterson, Gurianov, Bayreuther, Stenqvist, Nyberg, Karlstrom

Probably forgetting a lot of prospects

Nice deep analysis. Thanks.
(for real)

Seems about right. Would love one (hopefully two) or your mid six forwards to become a 20-25 goal scorer at the NHL level. While hopeful that they all work out, history says even two will be lucky to make it.

Mascherin, Dellandrea, Eriksson, Back, and Nichushkin seem to fit Nill's high risk, shoot for upside strategy. Maybe Robertson, too. 2 of 6 make it tp consistent 20+ goal scores? OMG, 3 would be heaven on earth for Stars fans.

Things have to balance out for Nill at some point, at least statistically. So, I predict Mascherin, and Robertson eventually contribute some offense. Nuke, maybe. Dellandrea will probably fall to 3C at some point.

 

[Morry83]

Nice deep analysis. Thanks.

After top stud NHL prospect Jason Dickinson produced 5 points in almost 40 NHL games, I’ve determined that he’s trash

 

[Mr Misty]

I have a great idea: lets take the one thing that is hockey related that we do in the hockey desert of August/September and put it in one thread right between the draft and free agency.

 

[Kcb12345]

After top stud NHL prospect Jason Dickinson produced 5 points in almost 40 NHL games, I’ve determined that he’s trash

He may be nothing special, but around 5-8 minutes of ice time on a a Hitchcock team isn't going to get you anything at all. I could see Dickinson being a good 3rd/4th liner for us that puts up 15 goals a year as long as he gets fair ice time. He's better than Ritchie/Elie easily in my opinion. Wouldn't be surprised if he ends up better than Shore either

 

[FirstRowUpperDeck]

Agree he looked list last year, but figured Hitch can do that to you. And the Stars development process stunts a lot of youth, usually D, but maybe its spreading, not LOL.

Monty might correct that to a degree. We hope, especially if they sign JT. We will need a lot of cheap players to do well.