Rangers Prospect Poll (Summer 2023) - #7 Prospect

[The Crypto Guy]

Rangers Summer 2023 Prospect Ranking

1. Gabriel Perreault (F) (2023 Draft - 1st round) [ Not Ranked ]
2. Brennan Othmann (F) (2021 Draft - 1st round) [ 1st / 3rd / 4th / 8th ]
3. Will Cuylle (F) (2020 Draft - 2nd round) [ 3rd / 7th / 9th / 12th ]
4. Adam Sykora (F) (2022 Draft - 2nd round) [ 5th / 9th ]
5. Zac Jones (D) (2019 Draft - 3rd round) [ 2nd / 3rd / 6th / 7th / 17th ]
6. Dylan Garand (G) (2020 Draft - 4th round) [ 6th / 8th / 10th / 15th ]

Added: Maxim Barbashev (F)

Please tell me who you want added next

​

Player	Pos.	Sh.	DOB	Ht.	Wt.	Acquired
Boyko, Talyn	G	L	10/16/02	6'8"	200	Drafted R4 #112 2021
Brouillard, Nikolas	D	L	02/07/95	5'10"	172	Signed as UDFA 2023
Chmelař, Jaroslav	RW	R	07/20/03	6'5"	202	Drafted R5 #144 2021
Ciccolini, Eric	F	R	01/14/01	6'0"	170	Drafted R7 #205 2019
Edström, Adam	F	L	10/12/00	6'8"	225	Drafted R6 #161 2019
Fortescue, Drew	D	L	04/28/05	6'3"	170	Drafted R3 #90 2023
Henricks, Ty	LW	L	06/28/05	6'5"	205	Drafted R6 #183 2023
Henriksson, Karl	C/LW	L	02/05/01	5'9"	176	Drafted R2 #58 2019
Hughes, Riley	W	R	06/27/00	6'2"	195	Drafted R7 #216 2018
Karpa, Zakary	C	L	03/25/02	6'2"	190	Drafted R6 #191 2022
Kempf, Hank	D	L	04/15/02	6'2"	200	Drafted R7 #208 2021
Kjellberg, Simon	D	L	02/17/00	6'3"	210	Drafted R6 #163 2018
Korczak, Ryder	C	R	09/23/02	5'11"	173	Drafted R3 #75 2021
Laba, Noah	C	R	08/04/03	6'2"	190	Drafted R4 #111 2022
Lamb, Brody	RW	R	08/30/03	6'1"	175	Drafted R4 #104 2021
Larsson, Rasmus	D	L	02/09/04	6'3"	198	Drafted R5 #152 2023
Lindbom, Olof	G	L	07/23/00	6'2"	183	Drafted R2 #39 2018
Mancini, Victor	D	R	05/26/02	6'4"	215	Drafted R5 #159 2022
Ollas, Hugo	G	L	04/24/02	6'8"	253	Drafted R7 #197 2020
Pajuniemi, Lauri	RW	R	09/12/99	6'0"	196	Drafted R5 #132 2018
Rempe, Matt	C/RW	L	06/29/02	6'7"	207	Drafted R6 #165 2020
Roobroeck, Dylan	C	L	07/27/04	6'7"	204	Drafted R6 #178 2023
Scanlin, Brandon	D	L	06/02/99	6'4"	216	Signed as UDFA 2022
Tärnström, Oliver	C/LW	L	08/30/02	6'0"	159	Drafted R3 #92 2020
Trivigno, Bobby	LW	L	01/19/99	5'7"	160	Signed as UDFA 2022
Väisänen, Kalle	LW	R	01/28/03	6'4"	181	Drafted R4 #106 2021

Click to read more...

 

[apoptygma]

BMB, considered Berard, but he did have a recession statwise in his College season compared to the year before. Both are good prospects, but as they also both are ways of NHL quality. Having that year to year improvement is vital if they will ever get to the NHL, so ranking the one with no lesser season yet higher.

Ready to eat crow on this one as Berard really takes the AHL with storm later this fall.

Add Edström.

 

[cwede]

add Fortescue

 

[bernmeister]

rob
add Fort, Scan

 

[nyr2k2]

BMB, add Edstrom.

 

[RangersFan1994]

Voted Barbashev add Fortescue


Why is Brouillard on the list of choices? He is too to be considered a prospect.

 

[GoAwayPanarin]

BMB, Chmelar

 

[Savant]

BMB add Chmelar

Thought about Berard but I think he took a step back; and BMB took a step forward.

 

[nyr2k2]

Voted Barbashev add Fortescue


Why is Brouillard on the list of choices? He is too to be considered a prospect.

I provided the explanation for why I included him in the first poll. I know he's 28, but it's his first NHL contract. He took an unusual and circuitous route to get here. To me, he was no different than Gustav Rydahl, who was 27 when we signed him and 28 when the season started. Those guys, I give one year of prospect eligibility. It's not based on Calder eligibility or anything.

The old HF criteria which is what we still go by, always included this piece: "These are general guidelines and should be followed the majority of the time but certain players may still be listed as prospects if circumstances warrant." Brouillard is my liberal application of that provision. No one is going to vote for him, anyway.

 

[Chalfdiggity3]

BMB easy.

 

[n8]

add Chmelař

 

[kovazub94]

BMB, Chmelar

Same again

 

[kovazub94]

BMB, considered Berard, but he did have a recession statwise in his College season compared to the year before. Both are good prospects, but as they also both are ways of NHL quality. Having that year to year improvement is vital if they will ever get to the NHL, so ranking the one with no lesser season yet higher.

Ready to eat crow on this one as Berard really takes the AHL with storm later this fall.

Add Edström.

Berard is not a first line player. It’s not his skillset and IMO his drop in production is primarily attributed to this. Berard performed his best when put in supporting roles down the line - where’s he be slotted if he were to become a successful NHLer. BMB ceiling was higher the moment he got drafted and after his D+1 year - his floor is at least not lower.

 

[Raspewtin]

Berard is not a first line player. It’s not his skillset and IMO his drop in production is primarily attributed to this. Berard performed his best when put in supporting roles down the line - where’s he be slotted if he were to become a successful NHLer. BMB ceiling was higher the moment he got drafted and after his D+1 year - his floor is at least not lower.

He led his team in scoring last year?

all of Providence saw big drops in scoring and struggles with it, not just him.

 

[Clark Kellogg]

add Edstrom

 

[kovazub94]

He led his team in scoring last year?

all of Providence saw big drops in scoring and struggles with it, not just him.

Not really my point though. Berard is not and will not be expected to be a point producer when / if he gets to the nhl. I was responding to the post where Berard was “compared” to BMB in terms of scoring dynamic year over year. My point was that this change was more of a symptom rather than the underlying factor for preferring BMB over Berard in the rankings.

 

[Shesterkybomb]

Took Robertson but BMB is the obviously most talented guy in there. I just think there's a clear path for Robertson to eventually be atleast the 3rd pair dman for this team. I think they're taking their time with him and it should pay off. Berard i love his style but I'm not sure if he has the size to play that way at the nhl level, i hope so.

 

[Amazing Kreiderman]

Berardi

Add-ström