Both are meh. However, JP has looked solid for short stretches in the NHL (personally never felt he got a good shot on the PP or a top 6 skill line, but a convo for another time). Hes also done very well in Finland last season. So atleats JP has a shot at an NHL future and is only not in the NHL because of a hold out (which could signal attitude issues). Whereas, with OJ and his injuries and stalled development, he likely will never make the NHL no matter how good his attitude is
If this trade were made, I wouldnt be upset- JPs time with the Oilers is likely over. But I wouldnt expect OJ to do much, just more AHL fodder for a few years before going back to Finland