Prospect Poll Questionnaire & Individual Summer 2018 Rankings

[Stizzle]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?


2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?


3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?


4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)


5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?


6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.

Click to read more...

 

[Rebels57]

1. Frost, Morgan - 84%
2. Myers, Phil - 80%
3. Farabee, Joel - 84%
4. O'Brien, Jay - 42%
5. Allison, Wade - 41%
6. Ratcliffe, Isaac - 61%
7. Morin, Sam - 39%
8. Rubtsov, German - 47%
9. Vorobyev, Mikhail - 85%
10. Laczynski, Tanner - 50%
11. Aube-Kubel, Nicolas - 67%
12. Kase, David - 26%
13. Linus Hogberg - 32%
14. Friedman, Mark - 22%
15. Strome, Matthew - 30%
16. Lycksell, Olle - 36%
17. Ginning, Adam - 25%
18. Cates, Noah - 46%
19. Sushko, Maxim - 44%
20. Kalynuk, Wyatt - 54%
21. Bunnaman, Connor - 27%​

 

[Rebels57]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?

Samuel Morin - Could be an elite shutdown dmen and they become invaluable in the Playoffs.


2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?

Wyatt Kalynuk

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?

David Kase

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)

German Rubstov


5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?

Danick Martel


6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.

1. Carter Hart
2. Morgan Frost
3. Philippe Myers
4. Joel Farabee
5. Jay O'Brien
6. Wade Allison
7. Samuel Morin
8. German Rubstov
9. Isaac Ratcliffe
10. Felix Sandstrom
11. Nicolas Aube-Kubel
12. Tanner Laczynski
13. Mark Friedman
14. Matthew Strome
15. Linus Hogberg
16. Kirill Ustimenko
17. David Kase
18. Wyatt Kalynuk
19. Noah Cates
20. Olle Lycksell

 

[Adtar02]

Really like this thread.

 

[Adtar02]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?
Morin. Still have a lot of faith in him. Just keeps working hard.

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?
German. Really like his game. Seems smart and selfless doesn’t try to be too flashy. Put him with other really smart players and he will excell. Much like g and coots

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?
Not sure but 5&6 seem out of place. Had great number but just don’t feel sold yet

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)
Rubtsov. Think he is going to surprise people by earn the respect of the coach quickly do to playing smart.

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?
Bunny. Throwing Captin a bone

 

[Stizzle]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?

Tanner Laczynski.

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?

Wyatt Kalynuk. I have him 10 spots higher than the consensus. Seemingly overlooked because he was an older freshman and a 7th round pick.

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?

Samuel Morin. I thought his 16-17 season was pedestrian. 17-18 was a wash. Now he's, 23 and out until February.

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)

David Kase.

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?

Wyatte Wylie.

6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.

1. Myers
2. Frost
3. O'Brien
4. Farabee
5. Vorobyev
6. Laczynski
7. Ratcliffe
8. Allison
9. Hogberg
10. Kalynuk
11. Rubtsov
12. Friedman
13. Morin
14. Lycksell
15. Kase
16. Wylie
17. Aube-Kubel
18. Ginning
19. Cates
20. Sushko

 

[FlyTimmo]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?

Isaac Ratcliffe

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?

Wyatt Kalynuk

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?

German Rubstov

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)

David Kase

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?

Jack St. Ivany

6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.

Skaters

1. Frost
2. Myers
3. Farabee
4. O'Brien
5. Ratcliffe
6. Allison
7. Vorobyev
8. Laczynski
9. Morin
10. Rubstov
11. Aube-Kubel
12. Kalynuk
13. Hogberg
14. Kase
15. Cates
16. Lycksell
17. Strome
18. Friedman
19. Sushko
20. Ginning


Goalies

1. Hart
2. Sandstrom
3. Ustimenko
4. Lyon (Does he still count?)
5. Stolarz

 

[dats81]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?

nobody (unless major injury or unexpected health issues)

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?

Adam Ginning

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?

Sam Morin

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)

David Kase

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?

Carsen Twarynski

6.
too lazy to do it right now

 

[Doodootheclown]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?
Wade Allison. He will follow in the footsteps of fellow ginger winger legends Clode and Yake.

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?
Aube-Kubel

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?
Rubstov

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)
Kase

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?
Martel

6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.
Coming soon..

 

[Chuck Downie]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?

Wade Allison

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?

Noah Cates

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?

Matthew Strome

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)

David Kase

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?

David Bernhardt

6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.

Top 10 with goalies

1. Frost
2. Hart
3. Myers
4. O'Brien
5. Farabee
6. Allison
7. Ratcliffe
8. Sandstrom
9. Aube-Kubel
10. Morin

 

[flyersjim73]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?

Morin. Big guys often take longer than smaller guys to develop. He seems like he’s being punished for taking the path we thought he’d take (and dealing with Hakstol).


2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?

Tough one - I like most of the rankings. Maybe Ginning. Seems like anyone that plays a physical game at all gets hated on now. Ginning looks like he can skate really well along with the physical game. I think he might end up being better than people think.



3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?

Ratcliffe. Put up the goals due to his size, but size isn’t everything in the NHL. Major lack of assists concerns me. Not sold on his hockey IQ.


4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)

All around Rubtsov due to his two way game. I bet Kase puts up some surprising offensive numbers though.


5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?

St Ivany

6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.

1) O’brien (Not based on what he’s already done, but based on what I believe he will do. Just a feeling we hit the jackpot with him)
2) Myers
3)Frost
4)Farabee
5)Morin
6)Allison
7) Rubstov
8) Vorobyev
9) Kase (he might end up doing absolutely nothing, or he might end up a huge steal. Skill level is as high as almost anyone on this list)
10) Laczynski
11) Aube Kubel
12) Ratcliffe
13) Ginning
14) Lycksell
15) Cates
16) Friedman
17) Sushko
18) Kalynuk
19) Strome
20) Hogberg



Edit to add my answers to the other questions are listed in the original quote.



Great idea for a thread.

 

[Stizzle]

1) O’brien (Not based on what he’s already done, but based on what I believe he will do. Just a feeling we hit the jackpot with him)

Ballsy pick. I like it. There's a surprising amount of O'Brien footage available on YouTube. He is a joy to watch. A real predator around the puck and plays with swagger.







Jay O'Brien Shift by Shift pt.2

2018 World Junior Hockey Summer Showcase | Team Canada vs Team USA | Full Game

 

[wasup]

# 1 Allison
#2 NAK
#3 Strome
#4 Kase
#5 Martel

 

[deadhead]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?

O'Brien, you could easily swap him for one of the top four.

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?

Hogberg, flying under the radar right now

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?

Morin, until proven otherwise, he's just a bigger version of Hagg

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)

Twarynski, he's got size and speed and has developed a scoring touch, he's made for AHL hockey.

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?

St Ivany, b/c a big RHD with some mobility will get every opportunity to fail.

6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.
​

1. Carter Hart
2. Morgan Frost
3. Philippe Myers
4. Joel Farabee
5. Jay O'Brien
6. Isaac Ratcliffe
7. Wade Allison
8. German Rubstov
9. Samuel Morin
10. Tanner Laczynski
11. Felix Sandstrom
12. Nicolas Aube-Kubel
13. Linus Hogberg
14. Mark Friedman
15. Noah Cates
16. Olle Lycksell
17. Carson Twarynski
18. Wyatt Kalynuk
19. David Kase
20. Pascal Laberge
21. David Bernhardt
22. Matthew Strome
23. Kirill Ustimenko
24. Jack St. Ivany
25. Marcus Westbalt
    

 

[LegionOfDoom91]

1. Tanner Laczynski
2. Wyatt Kalynuk
3. German Rubtsov or Samuel Morin
4. David Kase (I don’t think we get a whole lot of impact in general from that group next year)
5. David Bernhardt
6. ....

1. Morgan Frost
2. Philippe Myers
3. Joel Farabee
4. Jay O’Brien
5. Wade Allison
6. Tanner Laczynski
7. Isaac Ratcliffe
8. Mikhail Vorobyev
9. Nicolas Aube-Kubel
10. Samuel Morin
11. German Rubtsov
12. Matthew Strome
13. Wyatt Kalynuk
14. Maksim Sushko
15. Mark Friedman
16. Noah Cates
17. David Kase
18. Linus Hogberg
19. Adam Ginning
20. Jack St. Ivany

1. Carter Hart
2. Kirill Ustimenko
3. Felix Sandstrom
4. Samuel Ersson
5. Ivan Fedotov
6. Matej Tomek

 

[TB87]

1. Which prospect, ranked outside the consensus top 4, is most likely to end up a better player than one of our current consensus top 4?
Wade Allison

2. Who is the prospect most underrated by the consensus poll?
Wyatt Kalynuk

3. Who is the prospect most overrated by the consensus poll?
Sam Morin

4. Most impactful newcomer to the Phantoms roster this year at forward? (Rubtsov, Kase, Laberge, Twarynski, Bunnaman, other)
German Rubtsov

5. Which prospect, other than Goulbourne, ranked outside the consensus top 20 ends up playing the most career NHL games?
Carsen Twarynski

6. Ok, let's see your personal top 20 prospect list.

My personal top 20 list is based on my perceived view of their NHL upside:

1 - Philippe Myers
2 - Morgan Frost
3 - Carter Hart
4 - Wade Allison
5 - Joel Farabee
6 - Jay O'Brien
7 - Isaac Ratcliffe
8 - Tanner Laczynski
9 - Nicolas Aube-Kubel
10 - Olle Lycksell
11 - Mikhail Vorobyev
12 - German Rubtsov
13 - Noah Cates
14 - Linus Hogberg
15 - Mark Friedman
16 - Wyatt Kalynuk
17 - Maksim Sushko
18 - David Kase
19 - Felix Sandstrom
20 - David Bernhardt

 

[GapToothedWonder]

My personal top 20 list is based on my perceived view of their NHL upside:

1 - Philippe Myers
2 - Morgan Frost
3 - Carter Hart
4 - Wade Allison
5 - Joel Farabee
6 - Jay O'Brien
7 - Isaac Ratcliffe
8 - Tanner Laczynski
9 - Nicolas Aube-Kubel
10 - Olle Lycksell
11 - Mikhail Vorobyev
12 - German Rubtsov
13 - Noah Cates
14 - Linus Hogberg
15 - Mark Friedman
16 - Wyatt Kalynuk
17 - Maksim Sushko
18 - David Kase
19 - Felix Sandstrom
20 - David Bernhardt

Solely based on upside I'm surprised you don't have Hart number one.

 

[TB87]

Solely based on upside I'm surprised you don't have Hart number one.

Goalie’s are weird and hard to project. He’ll be number one if he rips up the AHL this season (A’ la Matt Murray). I have to see how he plays at the professional level first before vaulting him up my rankings.

 

[Stizzle]

1. Carter Hart
2. Kirill Ustimenko
3. Felix Sandstrom
4. Samuel Ersson
5. Ivan Fedotov
6. Matej Tomek

Dropping Sandstrom because of the chronic stomach issue or just a big Ustimenko believer?

 

[LegionOfDoom91]

Dropping Sandstrom because of the chronic stomach issue or just a big Ustimenko believer?

A little of both. It’s honestly just a total guess but I got a feeling about Ustimenko.