My apologies if I've missed them, but curious your take on Owen's comments whilst making the rounds as well as his time with Newcastle.
Luke Edwards of the Daily Telegraph, who worked for the Newcastle Journal in 2008-9, tellingly pointed out that while it had been common knowledge within football that Shearer wasn't happy with Owen, Shearer never went public. But Owen has a book to sell, and a shortfall of integrity. Note his body language during moments in the interview when he falls silent - once biting his nails, another time inspecting them. Hardly indicative of a man at ease with himself and the purported truth he's peddling.
The contempt his book expresses for Newcastle United and the city it represents is no revelation - from the first there was a sense he'd only come because Liverpool didn't want him. But if you want a notion of his reliability as a witness, consider his comments about how uncomfortable he, with his strong affection for Liverpool, felt in 2009 about having a choice of whether to sign for Everton or Manchester United. In fact, Owen is famously a boyhood Everton fan. He chose Manchester United for ambition, just as he left Liverpool in 2004 because he thought he'd outgrown them. There's nothing wrong with looking out for yourself first - until you try and pull on people's heart strings to look like the good guy.
On twitter, Owen accused Shearer of wanting to leave Newcastle for Liverpool when Bobby Robson was manager. The exact opposite was true - as far back as 2004 it was being reported that in the summer of 2003 Robson had wanted to move out the then 33-year old Shearer and build his attack around Emile Mpenza (that he was thwarted, and Shearer scored 22 EPL goals in 03/04, is one of many examples of Robson being saved from his own erratic instincts). Embarrassingly, plenty of journalists who covered the club around then corrected Owen (not that the correction achieved as much attention as Owen's initial untruth).
Owen objected to Shearer supposedly taking his comments about not enjoying his last six or seven years in football out of context. I think the justice of Shearer's response to that self-pitying quote is borne out by Owen's overcompensatory remarks in the interview you've linked about how many marvellous memories he had of his years at Old Trafford. There he scored 17 goals in 52 games over three years - a lesser appearance and strike rate than the spell on Tyneside that he regrets so much.
As to the 'Shearer blames me for Newcastle's relegation' bleat - Owen plays loose with the facts. As he tells it, you'd think Shearer was trying to rush him back from a long absence to save him. The reality is that Owen played in the first six of Shearer's eight game in charge, scoring a grand total of zero goals. Five of those were starts, and he played every single minute of four. It was before the seventh game, Fulham at home, that, according to Newcastle's then physiotherapist Paul Ferris, Owen complained of "feeling his groin". After a scan showed no muscle tear, Owen said, "What if I rip my groin on Saturday? I'll not get a contract at another club if I'm injured."
An ironic comment in itself when you remember that Real Madrid signed Jonathan Woodgate to accompany Owen to Spain while injured. But I digress. More pertinently, Paul Ferris is a qualified barrister, and Michael Owen has never sued him for libel. Ferris, himself a highly-rated teenage striker whose career was ruined by injury, writes positively about Owen as a person and professional. He empathises with Owen's fears on that occasion, but the undertone of disappointment is palpable.
If you care to contrast, in 1997, approaching his 27th birthday, about to lead his childhood club into their first ever European Cup campaign and captain his country in a World Cup finals, Alan Shearer simultaneously broke his right leg and dislocated the ankle. His foot was hanging loose, and pointing at six o'clock instead of twelve. The diagnosis was he'd be out for nine months; Shearer returned in five and a half. If anything, his haste to bail out a struggling NUFC probably came at a cost to his general conditioning. It wasn't until four years later, following international retirement and three operations to cure tendinitis of the knee, that Shearer ceased to struggle with injuries. His pace was gone. But he adapted. Owen, a boy wonder at the age of 17, retired aged 33. Shearer, who at 17 became the youngest player to score a top-flight hat-trick in England, underwent surgery more than 15 times during his career, but retired at 35 second only to Jimmy Greaves as the English elite division's leading goalscorer since the Second World War.
My perspective on Owen's actual play at Newcastle is a minority one - he wasn't quite the disaster he was portrayed to be with hindsight following the bitterness of relegation. In the first half of 2005-6, Newcastle only scored two goals from open play with him off the field. In 2007-8 his goals helped Kevin Keegan's side achieve the late run of wins that helped them avoid relegation.
The problem was that once he lost a gear following that knee injury prior to the 2006 World Cup the limitations of his game were laid bare. A club record signing, earning £120,000 a week (50% more than NUFC's best-paid player earns
today), went from being an outstanding player to a merely good one. And since he was playing for a declining power, apart from a double against sunderland in the Tyne-Wear derby, none of his goals provided especially memorable highs. Compare with Tino Asprilla, an signing who wasn't notably successful, but whose hat-trick against Barcelona in the Champions League casts all his failings into the shadows.
Owen never wanted to be at Newcastle in the first place, and even when he was at Liverpool there were plenty fans felt he put country before club. He says he's shy, but crucially not in a way that comes across sympathetically - he's always exuded calculation and a sense of being enclosed, to which he's now added a sense of sitting miserably on his vast fortune nursing grudges. So when, having used NUFC during his playing career he uses the club again to help flog his book, and spouts a heap of inconsistencies and worse, to my mind the abuse many other Geordies have long given him has now been earned.