Speculation: Post Full-Season Lockout All Star Team

[Eye of Ra]

Curious to see how everyone would construct an All Star lineup from the 2005-06 season to the current one. The idea being to build a lineup assuming everyone is at their peak season during that timeframe. So longevity isn't important, but they can only play at the level they played at for your team.

My team:

Justin Williams - Eric Staal - Cory Stillman
Alexander Semin - Rod Brind'Amour - Ray Whitney
Erik Cole - Jordan Staal - Sergei Samsonov
Tuomo Ruutu - Brandon Sutter - Scott Walker

Justin Faulk - Andrej Sekera
Joni Pitkänen - Dennis Seidenberg
Joe Corvo - Tim Gleason

Martin Gerber
Cam Ward

Click to read more...

 

[BrindAmours Army]

No Glen Wesley?

 

[HisIceness]

Yeah Wesley has to be in there. We possibly go down 0-2 to Buffalo if it wasn't for him stopping that shot in game 2 of that series. Not to mention he made some other big plays during that playoff run.

 

[Navin R Slavin]

Can I have the same player at more than one position?

 

[nobuddy]

Jeff Skinner - Eric Staal - Erik Cole
Ray Whitney - Rod Brind'Amour - Justin Williams
Cory Stillman - Jordan Staal - Alex Semin
Jussi Jokinen - Matt Cullen - Tuomo Ruutu

Glen Wesley - Justin Faulk
Andrej Sekera - Bret Hedican
Joni Pitkanen - Dennis Seidenberg

Anton Khudobin

 

[Joe McGrath]

Skinner-Staal-Semin
Whitney-Brind'Amour-Williams
Stillman-JStaal-Cole
Jokinen-Sutter-Ruutu

Wesley-Faulk
Pitkanen-Sekera
Gleason-Babchuk

Ward

 

[RodTheBawd]

Jeff Skinner - Eric Staal - Erik Cole
Ray Whitney - Rod Brind'Amour - Justin Williams
Cory Stillman - Jordan Staal - Alex Semin
Jussi Jokinen - Matt Cullen - Tuomo Ruutu

Glen Wesley - Justin Faulk
Andrej Sekera - Bret Hedican
Joni Pitkanen - Dennis Seidenberg

Anton Khudobin

I'd go with this, possibly sneak Gleason in there. I'd also probably take Ward over Dobby. He had the numbers that season, but I don't think it was sustainable for a full season + playoffs (as evident by his play since).

 

[VAcaniac]

lol Khudobin

 

[Sens1Canes2]

lol Khudobin

Seconded.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

The OP's directions leaves a little to interpretation though. He said.

assuming everyone is at their peak season during that timeframe

In Khudobin's peak season he had the best save % of any Canes goalie ever. It's fair to say though, that it was only 36 games and discount it for that, but I could see how someone would pick him based on the OP's criteria. Personally, I think you have to include peak performance and some level of longevity.

 

[RodTheBawd]

The OP's directions leaves a little to interpretation though. He said.



In Khudobin's peak season he had the best save % of any Canes goalie ever. It's fair to say though, that it was only 36 games and discount it for that, but I could see how someone would pick him based on the OP's criteria. Personally, I think you have to include peak performance and some level of longevity.

Thus the qualifier I added.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

Thus the qualifier I added.

Yeah, I wasn't aiming that at you, because, as you said, you added that qualifier.

 

[nobuddy]

i thought putting khudobin in but not a backup was enough to make it obvious that it was a joke.