PensFreak
Registered User
- Jun 5, 2007
- 2,331
- 1
Staying at one level for too long. Say a player that could have played in the NHL one season, but was sent back to juniors and regressed.
Any names come to mind?
Any names come to mind?
Nyquist, Brendan Smith, Kindl, Tatar...
The problem with this topic is how can you definitively say that being held back or being rushed is the reason why a player didn't reach his potential?
I guess it should be specifically for players who were highly touted teenagers on the bubble of making an NHL team or got a 9 game try out then sent back to junior and never panned out long term despite going back and dominating junior.
Still no way to prove it one way or another though...
3 of the 4 are still children
Kindl is 26, Nyquist and Smith are 24 and Tatar is 22. At what point between 24 and 26 are they no longer considered children?
In Red Wing age, they are only 16, 14 and 12...
I think Nyquist could've stayed one year less in college, one year less in the A, and been an NHL regular in 11/12. Honestly if Detroit put any merit into the training camp when it comes to winning a spot on the team -- he would've won it that year. He's been playing all but one of our playoff games the last two seasons and he's still not a regular on the team. It's so stupid. But he hasn't regressed, he continues to tear it up with the Griffins at least. He's earning his call-ups tenfold.
I would say Granlund stayed one year too long in FEL. His development did not improve much after the spring of 2011 imo. He was like a deer in headlights coming to north america, I'm really happy he has improved his skating and physicality in the summer, and he's also lost some visible babyfat from his cheeks.
0+1 tonight after 1 period
Yeah It fels like his career went backwards. He didn't become any better.
At times, it feels like Detroit considers their newly drafted guys twelve year olds, the way they talk about them becoming players for them in 5 or 6 years.
I think Nyquist could've stayed one year less in college, one year less in the A, and been an NHL regular in 11/12. Honestly if Detroit put any merit into the training camp when it comes to winning a spot on the team -- he would've won it that year. He's been playing all but one of our playoff games the last two seasons and he's still not a regular on the team. It's so stupid. But he hasn't regressed, he continues to tear it up with the Griffins at least. He's earning his call-ups tenfold.
Alex Pietrangelo had two 9-game stints in St.Louis and I thought he was going to make the team both times. Not that it hurt his development at all, but he could've had more of an impact in the NHL much sooner.
You could argue getting the 9-game stints benefitted Pietrangelo though. Not a very good example IMO.
Was pretty clear early he had to work on his defensive game, and now he's a top 10 defender in the league.
To me, he's a pretty good example of a player not hurt by playing his full junior career.