Player Discussion Player's Grades (Season 2018-2019)

[ahmedou]

Kind of Grades-Sheet during each post-games of the Pre/Regular/Playoff(lol) Season

A la "Bulletin" (school)

Alongside some explanations ( unbiased,fair,etc) justifying your reasoning and reflection (optional)

Why? :
1)An overview for those who havent spotted the game/s
2) Ill do a average for the player's grades (every Month/End of the season)

Click to read more...

 

[ahmedou]

Example (Preseason#1 2018 by @BaseballCoach ):

My ratings:
7.5 Niemi
7.0 Lindgren
8.5 Mete
7.5 Juulsen
7.0 Valiev
7.0 Schlemko
5.5 Alzner
5.0 Despres
6.5 Danault
6.5 Gallagher
7.0 Tatar
7.5 Kotkaniemi
6.5 Lehkonen
5.0 Deslauriers
6.0 Plekanec
6.5 Hudon
7.5 Chaput
7.0 DeLaRose
6.5 Froese
5.0 Shinkaruk
The penalty killers are given some recognition, they were very good.

 

[Genesis76]

Invisble Casperetty

 

[ProspectsFanatic]

A+ for Domi, ready for the tank!

 

[BaseballCoach]

Preseason Game 2 vs Florida

7.0 Price
4.5 Niemi
6.0 Petry
7.0 Reilly
5.5 Brook
4.5 Ouellet
5.0 Benn
5.0 Lernout
2.5 Domi (will likely be suspended)
7.0 Drouin
5.5 Armia
7.0 Peca
6.5 Byron
5.5 Scherbak (only because he drove the net and scored once)
5.0 Suzuki (not looking ready yet, skating behind Kotkaniemi's)
6.0 Bitten
5.5 Agostino
4.5 McCarron (ça sent la fin)
4.5 Grenier
6.0 Teasdale (looking like he might get an ELC)

 

[Yoshidas Island]

What's the grading scheme? @BaseballCoach @ahmedou
0.0 to 10.0?

 

[BaseballCoach]

What's the grading scheme? @BaseballCoach @ahmedou
0.0 to 10.0?

I use the one RDS uses for the Impact.

5.0 is barely passing grade. Anything over 8.5 is miraculous, a threat on every shift. Very often the game's best player gets 7.5 or 8.0

 

[BaseballCoach]

My ratings:

7.0 Lindgren
6.0 Sklenicka
5.5 Moravchek
6.0 Valiev
6.5 Schlemko
5.0 Ouellet
4.0 Despres
7.5 Danault
7.5 Gallagher
7.5 Tatar
7.0 Kotkaniemi
5.5 Lehkonen
5.5 Alain
5.5 Vejdemo
6.5 Hudon
6.5 Chaput
7.0 DeLaRose
7.0 Peca
6.0 Ward

 

[BaseballCoach]

Pre-season Game 4 ratings:

6.5 Price
5.5 Petry
4.5 Alzner
7.5 Reilly
5.0 Benn
6.0 Mete
5.5 Juulsen
7.0 Tatar
7.0 Danault
6.5 Gallagher
7.5 Drouin
8.0 Kotkaniemi
5.0 Armia
7.0 Byron
5.5 Plekanec
5.5 Scherbak
5.0 Shinkaruk
6.0 McCarron
5.5 Ward