Schmaltz will likely be better in the long run, but right now it's Danault.
It's without a doubt Schmaltz. Watch the kid play. He has something like 22 points in his past 25 games. And he has only played 58 games this season to PD's 79...
Schmaltz is the better player now, and will be the better player moving forward. Don't think there's any question of that.
Schmaltz puts up 50+ next year. Guaranteed. Wouldn't be surprised to see him hit 60. He has that kind of vision. Over his career he may only score 15 goals or so per season, but his vision... he'll put up 30-40 helpers per, IMO. Kid has been a stud since he was sent down to Rockford to build his confidence back up. So yeah... I see Schmaltz being a 50+ point top 6, two-way winger, with the ability to fill in at C when needed, and/or replace Anisimov if he can figure out his FO's. Because right now, that's the only thing the kid is bad at.
PD is only doing what he is doing because he's seeing top line minutes with a lack of a better 1C on Montreal. If he's seeing the standard 3rd line minutes that he should be as a 3C, then he's not putting up 50-60 points. No question about it.
Don't get me wrong. PD is a great player, and I still hate that trade from a Hawks perspective. But he's no 1C, and on a serious contender, he's a 3C at most.