Honestly he's a Hall of Famer if Mcree doesn't fumble the ball in the 2006 postseason.
They had Manning's #. I think they then would've obliterated Chicago in the SB.
But all in all, he makes my Hall of very good. He was sometimes a top 5 QB. But not once could you say he was the best in any season.
I do think he will make the hall eventually though. The Baseball hall of fame is the toughest to get in. The rest is underwhelming.
Rivers fumbled the ball in that one as well, one that the Patriots turned into their 3 points. Why is the onus on McRee and not him? He completed 14 out of 32 passes for 250 yards, fumbled, threw a pick without a TD, had a prime LT who racked nearly 200 yards per scrimmage, his running backs had 147 yards on 26 carries with 3 TDs, a defense that had 3 takeaways, etc, and still blew the game in which he wasn't asked to do more than manage it and keep them in it.