Odd to say but the expansion draft rules actually REALLY benefited Vegas a LOT, as did some absolutely baffling decisions by other GMs (looking square at Florida for that one). They basically, at worst, had 2nd/3rd line forwards or #4 defensemen to pick from on most teams, and on some they had some players that were even further up in the pecking order (Methot, Neal, Fleury) and were given REALLY good assets just to take bad contracts off the hands of other teams (CBJ 1st, Karlsson, WPG 1st, Theodore) or not pick certain players.
I’m not singling you out on this, because this is a common take, but hearing this is one of my least favorite things from this last season.
Prior to the expansion draft: league-wide consensus was that Vegas would end up with a decent goalie, below average but passable defensemen, and the worst forward group in the league. Vegas only succeeds in the expansion draft if they use it as an opportunity to play defenseman and goalie broker for the rest of the league, picking up futures for their service, as well as getting picks to take on less desirable players from other teams.
(A select few pre-draft: there will be enough quality defensemen available, and the Pacific is weak enough, that if Fleury plays lights out this team may barely squeak into the playoffs.)
During the draft: what are they doing? Passing on Mrazek for Nosek? Alex Tuch isn’t enough incentive to stay away from Matt Dumba. With all the great goalies out there, that’s who you ended up with after Fleury???
(The same select few after the draft: yeah this team isn’t making the playoffs I’m not sure what I was thinking.)
(Me, an intellectual, post-draft: gosh I love what they did. No point in getting the best players to push to finish ~20th in the league, pick up draft picks everywhere you can, and fill your prospect cupboard within a year or two so you’re up to par with the other guys. And in doing so, set your team up to get Dahlin. Bravo Mr. McPhee, way to keep the long game in sight.)
Preseason: Vegas is understandably positioned to be the worst team in the league, they’re an expansion team.
The general point being: if the rules were rigged to get Vegas to have the season they had (or even to compete for a playoff spot), there would have been some indication on paper prior to the season that they could do so. There was absolutely none. The rules may have been more lax than previous expansion teams more than 15 years ago, but Vegas absolutely should not have done what they did last year and it’s still an absolute miracle that they did. One of the most impressive things in NHL history, and absolutely due in major part to the chemistry/culture they were able to build in a brief period of time.