The way how you try to diminish his play after a good game tells me you have a fear.
I would like to get from you a simple yes or no on a straightforward question.
Are you afraid if he succeeds he would expose Heinen or Donato or push them down the roster?
We don't know if he is gonna stick in NHL. He could easily be the next Jimmy Hayes. However some us have seen him play both at Providence and Boston 2 seasons ago, last season and also this season. Hence we base our opinion on what we actually have seen of him. What do you base your opinion on?
That would be no. I’m not a huge fan of Donato’s game this year. Heinen I am, but I couldn’t care less if he played 3rd/4th line the rest of his career as long as he helped the team.
Please explain how me saying Cehlarik should make the team out of Camp back in October over Donato and Bjork and last night saying he had a good game, but I was concerned about his lack of speed and hope he adjusted, is me “diminishing” his play and being afraid? As if I have any control whatsoever about who plays and who doesn’t
I have consistently said that Donato should have spent a year in the AHL (and that it would have been good for Bjork as well). Cehlarik was a “dog” in PRO for the first 10-15 games according to people who watched him play. He was scratched for a game and was not moving his feet and getting to spots he needed to.
The only guy I recall saying in October and early November that he thought Cehlarik was playing well was BruinsNetwork. Then last night I’m hearing all of these Savants say that Cehlarik should have been up all season. Twelve points in his first twenty games didn’t scream call up to me. Cave had 6g/12a in 15 games and now people are trying to say he shouldn’t have been called up over Cehlarik (even though he also played a different position).
I don’t live near Providence/Boston and my son plays (and can’t drive), so I’m busy weekends and my exposure to the PB’s this year has been minimal. I rely on video, writers like Divver and the opinions of posters I trust that go to the games. At the end of November, someone asked Eric who he thought should be called up and he said Donato and Fitz for a Top 6 role, Blidh for a Bottom 6. No Cehlarik.
In December, he started producing more and playing better according to the people I listen to. However, this idea that he was on fire and forced a call up with his play, but was just being screwed by the organization is revisionist history.