Dread Clawz
LAWSonic Boom
It's funny that everyone only sees that part of his game. It is certainly frustrating to see so many unnecessary turnovers from bad decisions, but it is worth noting that his other numbers are quite good. Sometimes it's worth gambling and hoping you have other players who can make up for the mistakes.
We're seeing right now in the playoffs how much it helps to have multiple mobile puck-moving defensemen (Heiskanen-Klingberg, Hedman-Sergachyov-Shattenkirk, Makar-Girard etc.). We're spoiled because we have Yandle and Ekblad, but the Penguins have suffered when Schultz hasn't offloaded Letang like he did a few years ago. It's obviously a gamble but even without too much improvement in Matheson, he could still be a net positive for them.
It's likely that Matheson does improve and he becomes decent enough playing with Crosby and Malkin to overlook some occasional gaffes. But it wasn't going to happen here. Matheson needs a change of scenery, he needs a shock to the system, to realize he needs to make changes or else. Read these comments from him in this article....
Mike Matheson traded to Penguins after two disappointing seasons with Panthers
That sounds eerily similar to Dylan Olsen before he crashed and burned. Matheson is an over-thinker, he doesn't do well when things don't go his way, he lets things snowball. He really needs a reset, and playing in Pittsburgh likely helps him.