Pastrnak or Kane

[Nabrules]

Easily PK

 

[Namikaze Minato]

Easily PK

Agreed, Phil Kessel is easily the best.

 

[wasunder]

Close in the regular season, but Kane is a different animal in the playoffs(not that Pastrnak is bad). If I had to build a cup winning team, I would take Kane specifically for that. I'm not sure if there is another player in the league I would take over Kane in the playoffs

 

[libertarian]

Going forward? Pastrnak.

When both careers are done? Kane.

 

[ODoyle]

Kane easily for me.

 

[b in vancouver]

Crazy that this is even a poll - and that it's close. I mean this in the way that I had to flip a coin. Both players are amazing.
How the hell was Pastrnak picked 25th OA?

 

[loosemoose]

Kane is more well rounded offensive player. Defensively they are both non-factors. Pastrnak is probably the best goal scorer in the league though and scoring goals is the hardest thing in hockey, so I'll go with Pasta.

 

[veganbruin]

Love Kane and when all is said and done he will have had the better career IMO. However today and likely the next 5 years Pasta is the better goal scorer and just the salary difference alone makes him far more valuable to a contending team.