I say eye for an eye. How do you think Karlsson would do against Thornton?
Carkner will lose for sure
Better than whatever Bruin Carkner goes after afterwords.
Not a chance, and I'm a Chara fan. Carkner has put Boogaard and Godard on the shelf. Chara isn't a heavyweight. Yes, he hammered Koci (a meh heavyweight, not overly impressive), but he isn't a heavyweight, and he shouldn't be seeing as how he's one of the best defensemen in the world.