Proposal: Pageau and Duclair to the Oilers

[Crosside]

I think both of those are reasonable, although I think Holland will be more inclined to package Puljujarvi for a skilled winger with team control. A mid round pick for Ennis is something the Oilers should have done weeks ago.

Do you have any idea what kind of RFA contract Tierney will get?

Something around 3-3.5m for 2 or 3 years

 

[Sweoilers]

he factually is an all star

So was John Scott. That doesn't mean his value high. If he would have continued to preform as he did in December his value would have been high. Now I am not so sure

 

[TkachukNorris79]

Tennis (Tierney/Ennis) to Edmonton for Pulj+ makes way too much sense at this point, but Duclair could make sense as well, if Holland is willing to pay up. Duclair is an RFA and could be a forever winger for mcjesus

 

[alfstheman]

Duclair is worth a second IMO.

Facepalm. Duclair is rfa and sens best forward now. He is better than his points show he creates tons of chances every game and playing on worst offensive team in the league.

There is 0 chance he is traded. Especially for a 2nd lol

 

[Mark Stones Spleen]

Pageau with a 2G 2A performance tonight. Going into the deadline strong.

 

[FameFlame069]

Calgary 2nd 20 + Reider + 4th/3rd 21 for Pageau

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Duclair > Coleman, he got 2x 1sts, pretty sure sellers will see that as a benchmark (does not mean they will get it but it means HF board fans are overvaluing their prospects and picks ). Next to that Hayes last year does not seem so high of a price

Coleman is signed next year at 1.8. That held tremendous value to a cap strapped Ligntning club. Duclair is going to command what 5 million per?

 

[TKB21]

Calgary 2nd 20 + Reider + 4th/3rd 21 for Pageau

Hahahahaha. Hahahahaha. Hahahaha

 

[FameFlame069]

Hahahahaha. Hahahahaha. Hahahaha

What?

 

[armani]

Calgary 2nd 20 + Reider + 4th/3rd 21 for Pageau

I counter with Ryder, Halak, and a 2nd.

 

[FameFlame069]

I counter with Ryder, Halak, and a 2nd.

Great so Pageau and Anderson for Reider, Talbot, 2nd 2nd

 

[PoutineSp00nZ]

I


Don't know that Senators fans would be upset with another prospect, of that was the only hang up. But again, I don't speak for Ottawa fans.

No interest in pool party. Guy bails on his team and heads to Russia after failing to live up to expectations.

Bad attitude, poor performance and quickly heading to bust territory.

 

[LTIR]

No interest in pool party. Guy bails on his team and heads to Russia after failing to live up to expectations.

Bad attitude, poor performance and quickly heading to bust territory.

So much wrong here.
First of all he did not go to Russia.
He exercised his right as a player without contract to sign with Karpat after falling out with Oilers organization. His stock hasn't gone down considering his point totals abroad. If anything his value is much higher than what it was last season.
One can argue that Logan Brown is closer to becoming a bust than Puljujarvi

 

[PoutineSp00nZ]

So much wrong here.
First of all he did not go to Russia.
He exercised his right as a player without contract to sign with Karpat after falling out with Oilers organization. His stock hasn't gone down considering his point totals abroad. If anything his value is much higher than what it was last season.
One can argue that Logan Brown is closer to becoming a bust than Puljujarvi

If he had decent value he would have been traded by now

 

[bert]

Calgary 2nd 20 + Reider + 4th/3rd 21 for Pageau

Absolutely not thats a garbage return.

 

[bert]

No interest in pool party. Guy bails on his team and heads to Russia after failing to live up to expectations.

Bad attitude, poor performance and quickly heading to bust territory.

For Tierney it makes sense, raw talent is still potentially there, he didnt head to russia either.

 

[bert]

So much wrong here.
First of all he did not go to Russia.
He exercised his right as a player without contract to sign with Karpat after falling out with Oilers organization. His stock hasn't gone down considering his point totals abroad. If anything his value is much higher than what it was last season.
One can argue that Logan Brown is closer to becoming a bust than Puljujarvi

Was fine with your post until the last sentence. Brown is scoring alot at the AHL level and is continuing to evolve and show improvement while not abandoning his organization. Neither are busts yet. Both are big players and can still turn out.

 

[LTIR]

If he had decent value he would have been traded by now

One can argue that if he had low value he would have been traded by now.
Holland has said that he isn't giving him up for a rental.

 

[LTIR]

Was fine with your post until the last sentence. Brown is scoring alot at the AHL level and is continuing to evolve and show improvement while not abandoning his organization. Neither are busts yet. Both are big players and can still turn out.

I added Brown comparison for dramatic effect. I don't think he is a bust.
Puljujarvi in his rookie year (4 yrs ago) put up great AHL numbers as well. He was PPG in his short AHL stint last year as well. Pulju could/would have easily out produced Brown in AHL this year.

He is done with Oilers but is far from a bust.

 

[topshelf15]

TBH Ottawa should just keep both,sign Duclair to a 1 year show me again deal ...And try to get something reasonable done with JGP...Much rather this then just give them away for more prospects and picks...We have plenty

 

[guyzeur]

TBH Ottawa should just keep both,sign Duclair to a 1 year show me again deal ...And try to get something reasonable done with JGP...Much rather this then just give them away for more prospects and picks...We have plenty

Unless Dorion is going for the jugular and gets a 1st for Pageau.

 

[topshelf15]

Unless Dorion is going for the jugular and gets a 1st for Pageau.

I kinda torn,a late 1st or keeping a great leader and player,to help guide the kids...This team has lost so much,and the kids on the team need to see the exodus come to a end sooner or later..

 

[Homesick]

The Oilers wont be making any moves like this(cap and assets just dont exist) and I doubt that the Sens will be totally gutting their team

 

[TS Quint]

So much wrong here.
First of all he did not go to Russia.
He exercised his right as a player without contract to sign with Karpat after falling out with Oilers organization. His stock hasn't gone down considering his point totals abroad. If anything his value is much higher than what it was last season.
One can argue that Logan Brown is closer to becoming a bust than Puljujarvi

Points in Liiga are raising his value.....only to Oiler fans. Who cares about points in a 5th rate league? We already knew he could score in minor leagues. No one cares.

He couldn't produce in the NHL dispute playing significant time with McDavid and RNH.

I have to feel after the Oilers changed management and coaches he has a problem with a couple of significant players in the locker room. Possibly One of three players he hopes to play with, Drai, RNH or most likely McDavid as he is the franchise.

I doubt there is any interest in trading a valuable asset for him. The Oilers need to get him back on the team and show he has NHL value if they want to move him for anywhere near the value many vocal Oiler fans have for him around here. There are zero guarantees with JP and a huge risk.

Right now I'd say he probably gets a 3rd. No One cares about points in Finland.

 

[guyzeur]

The Oilers wont be making any moves like this(cap and assets just dont exist) and I doubt that the Sens will be totally gutting their team

If Melnyk is seeing a monetary gain, he would approve a trade regardless of the impact on the team.