Yes, I would prefer to have two studs on the back end and fill in around them. Not sure how long Drysdale has left here anyways. The bigger problem with the team right now is keeping goals out of the net imo. Part of that is the PK and part of that is the goaltending but they have issues on defense too. I think they have a decent chance to land one of their NCAA guys and they're better at finding impact forwards in the import draft than they are defenseman.
It’s pretty tough to draft defense first in two straight drafts but it isn’t completely uncommon.
It all depends on the construction of the rest of your roster and how confident you are in your 17 year olds development. IF you feel you have some solid pieces in deeper rounds from the 2018 draft then going after another D-Man isn’t so bad.
The negative side is doing what Ottawa did. They drafted Stratis, Bahl, and Robertson as their first three picks through the 2nd round. Then they picked Okhotyuk in the Import draft early. Plus they had Hoefenmeyer as a 2nd rounder that impressed from the previous draft. Then in the same draft as Hoefenmayer they picked Hudson Wilson and although he didn’t really play year one, he is in the top six now. That’s 6 guys in your starting six one year apart in age.
They were forced to deal Robertson (got a great return - two 2nd rounders) but you wasted all that development time on a player that would never have the right amount of ice to properly develop. They also dealt Stratis but got Rippon, a same age D-Man so that’s a push.
They will lose Hoefenmayer this year but will lose Okhotyuk, Bahl, Rippon, and Wilson the following year (Rippon may stick for an OA year). That is a lot of turnover.
So, like all drafts, it will come down to overall construction and how your team projects out. I know the 67’s loved having Nic Boynton and Bryan Campbell on the same roster. Hell, Sean Blanchard was two years older but he nabbed a Kaminski on that same roster so depth on Defense, as long as it is mobile and offensive, is a good thing.