OK, we've seen HF's prospects 50-11....

[madmike77]

Tim Erixon has to be in there somewhere.

Frankly top-10 seems a bit high to me, but I would find it impossible to believe he wouldn't be in the top-50 at all and I haven't seen his name so far (unless I missed it).

 

[SwissButch]

1. Brayden Schenn
2. Ryan Johanssen
3.
4. Curtis Hamilton
5. Emerson Etem
6.
7. Nino Nieterrieter (SP)
8.
9.
10.

Thats what I can predict out of the WHL prolly quite off but I don't know other leagues that well.

Is allready on the list... #32

 

[Colezuki]

I really have to say I don't know how Louis Leblanc can be 27th on THN, and yet not even top 50 on HF, especially when not much has changed between then and now

 

[loadie]

I really have to say I don't know how Louis Leblanc can be 27th on THN, and yet not even top 50 on HF, especially when not much has changed between then and now

I'm going to assume Leblanc will be on the HM list when the top 10 are released. I don't expect him in the top 10, but I did expect him in the top 50.

 

[umwoz]

If Granlund, Johansen, Schenn and Tarasenko aren't in, I will ignore the list all together.

 

[magic school bus]

1. Schenn
2. Johansen
3. Tarasenko
4. Kuznetsov
5. Ekman-Larsson
6. El Nino
7. Bernier
8. Rundblad
9. Ellis
10. Blum

Subban, Skinner, Couture, Hall, Sequin graduated so ommited. forgive me if they already made the list.

 

[Hunter Gathers]

Since this list has been the worst I have ever seen on this site and pieced together, seemingly, through a darts competition, who the **** knows what the top 10 will be?

I really have not seen such a bad list on this site in ages.

 

[YNWA14]

1. Brayden Schenn
2. Ryan Johanssen
3. David Rundblad
4. Curtis Hamilton (doubtful)
5. Vladimir Tarasenko
6.
7. Nino Nieterrieter (SP)
8.
9.
10.

Thats what I can predict out of the WHL prolly quite off but I don't know other leagues that well.

My thoughts.

 

[helicecopter]

I really have not seen such a bad list on this site in ages.

that's something bold to say!

 

[helicecopter]

Kuznetsov should be top 10 but they gave him a 7.5C, so I would not be suprised if he was left off the list.

that would be something even for HF standards..

as for the 7.5C, i guess it's just a matter of the rating not being updated in quite some time.

 

[bananaz]

Tim Erixon has to be in there somewhere.

Frankly top-10 seems a bit high to me, but I would find it impossible to believe he wouldn't be in the top-50 at all and I haven't seen his name so far (unless I missed it).

couldnt find him in the top 50 which is very surprising. i would be shocked if he was in the top 10

 

[madmike77]

couldnt find him in the top 50 which is very surprising. i would be shocked if he was in the top 10

Yeah I figured he would be somewhere between 15 and 30. It's a pretty big oversight in my opinion if he missed the top 50 given the year he has had. But I also don't think he belongs in the top 10.

I'm fairly confident he will be in the NHL at some point next year which is a lot more than you can say for some of the defencemen on this list.

 

[Flameshomer]

Yeah I figured he would be somewhere between 15 and 30. It's a pretty big oversight in my opinion if he missed the top 50 given the year he has had. But I also don't think he belongs in the top 10.

I'm fairly confident he will be in the NHL at some point next year which is a lot more than you can say for some of the defencemen on this list.

I posted this exact sentiment last night in the other thread... If he's in the Top 10, all the better, though Im not sure he really deserves to be. If he's left out completely, just a massive oversight

 

[hdtrax]

1. Schenn
2. Johansen
3. Tarasenko
4. Kuznetsov
5. Ekman-Larsson
6. El Nino
7. Bernier
8. Rundblad
9. Ellis
10. Blum

Subban, Skinner, Couture, Hall, Sequin graduated so ommited. forgive me if they already made the list.

Ellis and Blum already made the list. OEL might count as a graduate but he'd be in there for me.

 

[Manny*]

In no particular order:

Brayden Schenn
Mikael Granlund
Ryan Johansen
Nino Niederreiter
David Rundblad
Vladimir Tarasenko
Evgeny Kuznetsov
Johnathan Bernier
OEL
Brett Connolly

Yes.

If I had to put them in order:

Ekman-Larsson
Johansen
Schenn
Connolly
Tarasenko
Rundblad
Niederreiter
Bernier
Granlund
Kuznetsov

 

[magic school bus]

i dont think Brett Connolly deserves to be in the top 10, but he should be in the top 50. the list is definitely screwed up.

 

[Hooch314]

1. Brayden Schenn
2. Ryan Johanssen
3.
4. Curtis Hamilton
5. Emerson Etem
6.
7. Nino Nieterrieter (SP)
8.
9.
10.

Thats what I can predict out of the WHL prolly quite off but I don't know other leagues that well.

You don't seriously think this....

 

[Saabman0508]

I might be wrong but i believe Conolly was already in one of the other list so i don't think he is in the top 10.

Never mind i was wrong so he should be in the top 10.

 

[Nalens Oga]

couldnt find him in the top 50 which is very surprising. i would be shocked if he was in the top 10

The dmen on this list are really messed up, started off with Stefan Elliot at #48. Anyways, I'm gonna assume that they forgot Erixon and also de Haan since they already included guys like Ellis, Elliot, McDonagh, Gudbranson, etc. THN's Future Watch top 50 list is looking a lot better right now.

 

[R S]

Yeah, I don't like to hate on the HF staff, because everyone will have a complaint with a list like this...but there is no defending this list. It's simply not very good.

 

[SomE*]

Is allready on the list... #32

even that's way too high

 

[Wheatking]

Hall and Paajarvi graduated but Eberle is ranked as the Oilers #1 prospect. Will he be in the top 10?

 

[His Beardliness*]

If he's still a prospect he should be number 1.

This list would make even less sense, though.

 

[Yashin for President]

I love El Nino but Tarasenko is an animal. This kid really impressed me in the last WJC. I would go with Tarasenko for the top spot. El Nino second.

 

[TheKingSlayer]

I doubt Bernier would be there. He has played 32 games, and I could have sworn that after 25 games, a goalie is no longer a 'rookie'.
Still.
Top 10
1. Brayden Schenn
2. Ryan Johansen
3. OEL
4. Tarasenko
5. Kuznetsov
6. Runblad
7. Nino
8-10: Granlund, Ellis, Kyle Beach(?), Gormley etc. etc. (I have no clue really)