Wouldn't this be a more balanced look?
Reider-McDavid-Chiasson
RNH-Draisaitl-Puljujarvi
I'm perplexed as to why 2 veteran coaches insist on giving the best player on the planet the best wingers and leaving the scraps for the #2 centers then wind up shuffling around the lines constantly because of lack of secondary scoring.
Wouldn't the best chance at achieving secondary scoring be to load up the 2nd line and let McDavid carry his own line? Not only does this spread out scoring but it gets either McDavid or the stacked 2nd line away from tough matchups. With the current setup, all the attention of the defense can focus on the McDavid line with not much fear of the 2nd line feasting on weaker matchups. It just boggles my mind that Mclellan and now Hitchcock haven't tried this in 2+ seasons (not including the Hall-Drai 2nd line season). Switch McDavid and Draisaitl or switch Reider and RNH, am I the only who sees this as an obvious move?
Nuge and Drai don't work at that much even on the PP, completely out of sync. They play different games. Drai will be looking for a one timer and it'll never come. Nuge will be shooting himself.
Would be interesting to see historically how many Drai goals have even come from Nuge setups or even vice versa. Really I would wonder how many scoring plays feature both, even on PP and that don't involve McD.
Theres just very little in Drai-Nuge that seems to work together. I've noted that always and every coach does too. But why they are ever on the same PP I have no idea.
That said I agree with your general premise. If we had Hall still it would definitely work very well. But not with Drai and Nuge.