Proposal: Oilers - Avs

[YourARumour]

Hahahaha. You just made it easy to resign Barrie at a great cap hit. Plus I think it's the average of 5 years so anything over 5 pushes the average and compensation up.

If it was 'easy' bud they would have already done it

 

[Rebuilt]

If the Oilers want Barrie there is no doubt LD is going the other way. Maybe LD and Reinhart for Barrie and Compher.

How about Landeskog for Fayne and Kassian instead.

We dont want Barrie at these intelligence insulting prices. Keep him.

 

[snipes]

This thread wasn't made by an Avs fan. We will just repeat what every fan has said to Oiler fans that want our young stud dmen, overpay or go away.

Fair point.

I'm a reasonable poster and like reasonable chat. What do you think about RNH and 2017 1st (unprotected) for Barrie?

 

[Mighty Makar]

How about Landeskog for Fayne and Kassian instead.

We dont want Barrie at these intelligence insulting prices. Keep him.

Have a look at the thread in the Oilers board about the Hall/Larsson trade. Oiler fans are crushed. You think you're going to get Barrie for peanuts?

 

[MakeCgyGreatAgain]

Yes because we here on HF Boards decide what the deal is.

edit: In fact, forget the offer sheet. Keep Barrie. Dont worry about our players.

Concentrate on Barrie.

I've said that to other poster myself and the response I get is this is a fantasy forum. So take it with a grain of salt and don't waste your time trying to make anyone feel stupid for posting in this forum

 

[Mighty Makar]

Fair point.

I'm a reasonable poster and like reasonable chat. What do you think about RNH and 2017 1st (unprotected) for Barrie?

I'd do it.

 

[snipes]

I'd do it.

It stings, but I would do it too. It's an overpayment by the Oilers, but one that's worth doing in my view.

 

[Homesick]

I like the idea of getting rid of Iggy and his contract, but I don't like having Fayne for another two years. I don't think Nurse is worth Barrie, so if that '17 1st isn't protected, I'd think about it.

I'm so sick of draft picks I'd do that one or a '17 and '18 unprotected 1sts with Fayne for Barrie and Iginla

 

[Pierce Hawthorne]

Fair point.

I'm a reasonable poster and like reasonable chat. What do you think about RNH and 2017 1st (unprotected) for Barrie?

Meh, I dont like it still and would rather keep Barrie, but if the Avs are intent on trading him(I dont think they are) I would probably learn to get on board with this trade.


The thing about that 2017 1st is if the Oils added both Barrie and Larsson to that Defense next year, they are easily a playoff team or at least a bubble playoff team. That pick goes from possibily being a Top 5/7 pick to probably being in the bottom half of the draft. So it doesn't really hold all that much value.

 

[AMDZen]

He wasn't and still isn't, as shown by the reaction of hockey insiders and NHL fans alike. Chiarelli made a bad trade. Period.

All the more reason that Chiarelli would overpay once again for Barrie if he wanted him also. Barrie is worth more than Larsson was and would be more so if Chiarelli wanted him.

Thus, the Avs want Draisatl for Barrie

 

[Mighty Makar]

It stings, but I would do it too. It's an overpayment by the Oilers, but one that's worth doing in my view.

If this trade did happen, and you signed Lucic, how do you think you guys will go next season? I don't think you'll sign Demers after you landed Barrie.

 

[snipes]

Meh, I dont like it still and would rather keep Barrie, but if the Avs are intent on trading him(I dont think they are) I would probably learn to get on board with this trade.


The thing about that 2017 1st is if the Oils added both Barrie and Larsson to that Defense next year, they are easily a playoff team or at least a bubble playoff team. That pick goes from possibily being a Top 5/7 pick to probably being in the bottom half of the draft. So it doesn't really hold all that much value.

That's a fair point. It's a risk/reward pick. It could be a top 5/lottery pick or it could be a mid to late 1st round pick.

Both sides take risk on it. I mean if it ends up RNH, then the Oilers suck next year and you guys win the lottery and end up with Nolan Patrick, that's a massive win for COL.

 

[LTIR]

Just like Larsson wasn't worth Hall.

By that logic Landeskog isnt worth Klafbom

Everyone knows Oilers overpaid by a lot to land Larson.. Hall>>Larsson

 

[YourARumour]

We can't move Nuge cause if something happens to Dria or McD (either injury or production wise) We Are Dead in the water again . Hence offer sheet, if they match they match , off to next one

 

[Homesick]

Meh, I dont like it still and would rather keep Barrie, but if the Avs are intent on trading him(I dont think they are) I would probably learn to get on board with this trade.


The thing about that 2017 1st is if the Oils added both Barrie and Larsson to that Defense next year, they are easily a playoff team or at least a bubble playoff team. That pick goes from possibily being a Top 5/7 pick to probably being in the bottom half of the draft. So it doesn't really hold all that much value.

Never bet on the Oilers

 

[GirardSpinorama]

Fair point.

I'm a reasonable poster and like reasonable chat. What do you think about RNH and 2017 1st (unprotected) for Barrie?

I wouldn't be upset with the value, but would be terrified with how the team's offense will go down when their best puck mover gets moved. Sometimes, value is not all you want in a trade.

 

[snipes]

If this trade did happen, and you signed Lucic, how do you think you guys will go next season? I don't think you'll sign Demers after you landed Barrie.

Yeah we probably don't go after Demers in that situation. Barrie becomes the puck moving PP QB we were seeking.

We've always been seeking two RHD this offseason. Puck mover and shut down/defensive Dman would be ideal.

 

[snipes]

I wouldn't be upset with the value, but would be terrified with how the team's offense will go down when their best puck mover gets moved. Sometimes, value is not all you want in a trade.

Great point. Every team has their own contingent circumstances, and this alters objective value.

 

[AMDZen]

By that logic Landeskog isnt worth Klafbom

Everyone knows Oilers overpaid by a lot to land Larson.. Hall>>Larsson

Not sure how people think this is a point in favor of the Oilers. Yes, Chiarelli is clearly not that good at his job, making that trade is not the first evidence of this. So why couldn't Sakic rake him over the coals just like Shero did?

 

[thadd]

I think that Sakic and Roy are really anal on culture change.

That's why ROR is gone, that's why we've heard crazy insane rumours of the team being open to trading Duchene (I don't think it's happening) and I think that's why Barrie hasn't been resigned.

For the life of me I don't know what kind of culture change a team is insisting in going through when they've got a will to trade a d-man who's scored over 100 points over the past 2 seasons, but the will is obviously there since he hasn't been resigned yet.

I don't know anything about Andreas Martinsen, but I see him as a throw in so that both teams have an equal number of contracts at the end of this trade. I'd be cool with this trade but I'd hope Colorado would let Edmonton talk to Barrie about contract terms before making this trade. I'd be looking to lock him up at something like 6M X 6 years.

 

[Makar Goes Fast]

I think that Sakic and Roy are really anal on culture change.

That's why ROR is gone, that's why we've heard crazy insane rumours of the team being open to trading Duchene (I don't think it's happening) and I think that's why Barrie hasn't been resigned.

For the life of me I don't know what kind of culture change a team is insisting in going through when they've got a will to trade a d-man who's scored over 100 points over the past 2 seasons, but the will is obviously there since he hasn't been resigned yet.

I don't know anything about Andreas Martinsen, but I see him as a throw in so that both teams have an equal number of contracts at the end of this trade. I'd be cool with this trade but I'd hope Colorado would let Edmonton talk to Barrie about contract terms before making this trade. I'd be looking to lock him up at something like 6M X 6 years.

for that price colorado should already have the deal done

 

[GirardSpinorama]

I think that Sakic and Roy are really anal on culture change.

That's why ROR is gone, that's why we've heard crazy insane rumours of the team being open to trading Duchene (I don't think it's happening) and I think that's why Barrie hasn't been resigned.

For the life of me I don't know what kind of culture change a team is insisting in going through when they've got a will to trade a d-man who's scored over 100 points over the past 2 seasons, but the will is obviously there since he hasn't been resigned yet.

I don't know anything about Andreas Martinsen, but I see him as a throw in so that both teams have an equal number of contracts at the end of this trade. I'd be cool with this trade but I'd hope Colorado would let Edmonton talk to Barrie about contract terms before making this trade. I'd be looking to lock him up at something like 6M X 6 years.

Sakic and Roy would have LOVED to keep ROR. But not at 7.5 mill, which is what he eventually got. Nothing to do with culture what so ever.

 

[Toby Flenderson]

Barrie
Landeskog

For

Draisaitl
Nurse
Pouliot
2017 1st unprotected

????

 

[snipes]

Barrie
Landeskog

For

Draisaitl
Nurse
Pouliot
2017 1st unprotected

????

Pass.

Let's just keep it around Barrie.

 

[Drij]

Avs don't need the oilers trash