I started watching in 1995.
That was the year that “Captain Comeback” Jim Harbaugh nearly led unheralded Colts team to Super Bowl.
They were #5 seed and beat defending AFC champs Chargers and #1 seed Chiefs on the road.
They had a lead late vs Steelers in, what imo is one of the most underrated playoff games in NFL history, 1995 AFC title game.
Steelers drove 67 yards (aided by dropped int and 4th down conversion) and took the lead with a little over a minute left. Colts then get close enough for a hail marry. The pass lands between 4 Steelers defenders right into the chest of Colts WR Aaron Bailey....
... who drops it.
Talk about heart breaking. Anyway, I’ve been a Colts’ fan ever since.