Pwnasaurus
Registered User
We are pleased to present the all-time draft - Baseball Edition.
Essentially, the game will follow the same well-refined format as the hockey all-time draft. It is designed primarily as a fun competition, but of greater importance is to honor the history of baseball and the players that have shaped the game, from the early beginnings to the present day.
The format is quite simple. A drafting order will be randomly generated. This draft order will reverse every second round (snake draft).
Each team will draft a complete roster, with a total of 25 players and one manager (grand total of 26 draft picks). Each team should have a starter at each position (1B, 2B, SS, 3B, CF, RF, LF, C), as well as a full starting rotation of 5 and a closer. There will also be no DH included within the rosters.
Your goal is to assemble the best possible roster, choosing from any player who has ever played baseball, at any level, anywhere in the world. At the conclusion of the draft, regular season voting will be conducted by your peers in the draft (possibly others, such as spectators who happen to follow the draft and participate in discussion). From these voting results we will determine our regular season standings, and then the playoffs begin!
I'll split the draft into 2 leagues, then playoffs will behave in this fashion after regular season concludes.
Playoff Format
Each playoff round will last a week for discussion of the matchups and for each team to state its case, at which point more votes are taken. In this case you vote for the winner of the series and how many games it will take. This continues until we have determined our champion.
Rules
1. NEVER mention an undrafted player. It is poor etiquette. If quoting a source about a player you’re drafting, simply substitute the undrafted player with XXXX XXXX.
2. The time limit changes throughout the draft. This will be how it runs:
Round 1-2: 24 Hour Time Limit
Round 3-7: 12 Hour Time Limit
Round 8-21: 8 Hour Time Limit
Round 22-26: 4 Hour Time Limit
If you are not sure whether you will be available to make your pick within the allotted time, please send a list of players to someone who will be there for that time. This way the draft can progress nicely.
3. You MUST send a private message to the next GM to alert them that it is their turn. This is mandatory and it is crucial to the draft going smoothly. You should also change your board preferences so that you receive an email when you receive a PM. Many have found that this ensures that when it's your turn, you know as soon as possible.
4. Please be advised that it is MANDATORY to vote if you expect to participate in the next All-Time Draft. Put some effort into it. It's only fair that the best team wins. You can make your votes based on whatever criteria are important to you, but we are all expected to have an open mind and listen to the arguments for why each roster is better.
5. The draft is 26 rounds long. Each team will make 26 picks with one player at each position and one manager alongside extra bench players.
6. Trades are allowed, but are certainly not essential to winning or doing better. You can trade a player you've already drafted, as well as future picks. Trading conversations are always held via PM, but you may announce that you are shopping a pick or looking to move up/down to get the attention of other GMs. You must always trade one asset for another asset. (or 2 for 2, or 3 for 3, etc) (no 2-for-1 or 3-for-2 deals or else you wouldn't end up with 26 picks)
7. When making a pick, you should be posting at least three lines about the player. This can be in your own words or copied and pasted from a cited source. This is done for a couple of reasons: 1) To prove that you know something about him/have researched him. 2) To show the other GMs why this is a good pick.
8. DO NOT MENTION UNDRAFTED PLAYERS.
Co-Gm's are allowed and encouraged if you dont have as much knowledge of baseball. No more than 2 GM's to a team though.
If you select a player who played most of his career at lets say 1B but played for 2 years at LF, and choose him to play left field. You can draft him at both...however...this will downgrade the players ability. Its a risk that you can make but you have a better chance of winning if you have everyone at there natural position.
You will need to have atleast 1 Manager, 1 C, 1 1B, 1 2B, 1 3B, 1 SS, 1 LF, 1 CF, 1 RF, 5 SP, 3 RP including 1 closer. And again like the position players, if you move a reliever to a starter or vice versa, then that will affect how effective your player will be. NO DH
FOR PLAYOFFS IT WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED THAT VOTING IS DONE REGULARLY and if you want to stay for another Baseball ATD then it is a good idea to vote because it will give us the mindset that you care about the draft and not just your team.
Winner/Runnerup
1st Edition: Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)/BintZ (New York Mets)
2nd Edition: Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)/Chaosrevolver (Brooklyn Dodgers)
3rd Edition: Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)/Ranger Wolf (New York Highlanders)
4th Edition: Chaosrevolver (Chicago Cubs)/Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)
5th Edition: UL Washington (Brooklyn Superbas)/Pwnasaurus (Pittsburgh Crawfords)
6th Edition: Gootie (Chicago Whales)/Modo (Yomiuri Giants)
7th Edition: UL Washington (Chicago Orphans)/Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)
8th Edition: Darko (New York Yankees)/Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)
The Teams
1. Fish on The Sand - Cleveland Indians (American League)
2. JaysCyYoung - Toronto Maple Leafs (American League)
3. papershoes/Wrigley - Kansas City Athletics (American League)
4. Porn*/GIN ANTONIC - Toronto BJs (American League)
5. UL Washington - Brooklyn Bridegrooms (American League)
6. Darko - New York Yankees (American League)
7. bluesfan94 - St. Louis Stars (National League)
8. td_ice - Pittsburgh Pirates (National League)
9. 87and71 - Pittsburgh Porters (National League)
10. Gootie - Chicago Whales (American League)
11. Modo - Sioux City Cornhuskers (National League)
12. Pwnasaurus - St. Louis Cardinals (National League)
13. DisgruntledHawkFan - Montgomery Biscuits (National League)
14. ryan callahan - San Francisco Giants (National League)
15. GarbageGoal - Providence Steamrollers (American League)
16. Old Man Willie - Brooklyn Robins (National League)
17. Shawked - Chicago Black Sox (American League)
18. Winger For Hire - Homestead Grays (National League)
19. Vegeta - Detroit Tigers (American League)
20. le_sean - Montreal Royals (National League)
Round 1
1. Cleveland Indians - Babe Ruth - OF
2. Toronto Maple Leafs - Willie Mays - OF
3. Kansas City Athletics - Walter Johnson - SP
4. Toronto BJs - Ted Williams - OF
5. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Lefty Grove - SP
6. New York Yankees - Barry Bonds - OF
7. St. Louis Stars - Josh Gibson - C
8. Pittsburgh Pirates - Lou Gehrig - 1B
9. Pittsburgh Porters - Honus Wagner - SS
10. Chicago Whales - Ty Cobb - OF
11. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Sandy Koufax - SP
12. St. Louis Cardinals - Rogers Hornsby - 2B
13. Montgomery Biscuits - Christy Mathewson - SP
14. San Francisco Giants - Cy Young - SP
15. Providence Steamrollers - Hank Aaron - OF
16. Brooklyn Robins - Randy Johnson - SP
17. Chicago Black Sox - Roger Clemens - SP
18. St. Louis Stars - Grover Cleveland Alexander - SP
19. Pittsburgh Porters - Stan Musial - OF/1B
20. Montreal Royals - Tris Speaker - OF
Round 2
21. Montreal Royals - Satchel Paige - SP
22. Detroit Tigers - Alex Rodriguez - SS/3B
23. Homestead Grays - Eddie Collins - 2B
24. Chicago Black Sox - Mickey Mantle - OF
25. Homestead Grays - Rickey Henderson - OF
26. Providence Steamrollers - Nap Lajoie - 2B
27. San Francisco Giants - Tom Seaver - SP
28. Montgomery Biscuits - Mike Schmidt - 3B
29. St. Louis Cardinals - Bob Gibson - SP
30. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Ken Griffey Jr - OF
31. Chicago Whales - Greg Maddux - SP
32. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Pedro Martinez - SP
33. Pittsburgh Pirates - Warren Spahn - SP
34. Brooklyn Robins - Carl Yastrzemski - OF
35. New York Yankees - Joe DiMaggio - OF
36. Detroit Tigers - Jimmie Foxx - 1B
37. Toronto BJs - Johnny Bench - C
38. Kansas City Athletics - Eddie Mathews - 3B
39. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe Morgan - 2B
40. Cleveland Indians - Steve Carlton - SP
Round 3
41. Cleveland Indians - Cal Ripken - SS
42. Toronto Maple Leafs - George Brett - 3B
43. Kansas City Athletics - Yogi Berra - C
44. Toronto BJs - Ernie Banks - SS
45. Detroit Tigers - Kid Nichols - SP
46. New York Yankees - Hank Greenberg - 1B
47. Brooklyn Robins - Bob Feller - SP
48. Pittsburgh Pirates - Roy Campanella - C
49. Detroit Tigers - Nolan Ryan - SP
50. Chicago Whales - Jackie Robinson - 2B
51. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Roberto Clemente - OF
52. St. Louis Cardinals - Duke Snider - OF
53. Montgomery Biscuits - Albert Pujols - 1B
54. Montreal Royals - Frank Robinson - OF
55. Providence Steamrollers - Eddie Plank - SP
56. Homestead Grays - Jim Palmer - SP
57. Chicago Black Sox - Mel Ott - OF
58. Homestead Grays - Chipper Jones - 3B/OF
59. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Miguel Cabrera - 1B/3B
60. San Francisco Giants - Whitey Ford - SP
Round 4
61. San Francisco Giants - Mickey Cochrane - C
62. Pittsburgh Porters - Joe Jackson - OF
63. St. Louis Stars - Oscar Charleston - OF
64. Chicago Black Sox - Brooks Robinson - 3B
65. Montreal Royals - Carl Hubbell - SP
66. Providence Steamrollers - Gaylord Perry - SP
67. Brooklyn Robins - Al Kaline - OF
68. Montgomery Biscuits - Tom Glavine - SP
69. Kansas City Athletics - Mike Mussina - SP
70. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Don Drysdale - SP
71. Chicago Whales - Ed Walsh - SP
72. Pittsburgh Porters - Mariano Rivera - RP
73. St. Louis Cardinals - Rube Waddell - SP
74. St. Louis Stars - Smokey Joe Williams - SP
75. New York Yankees - Mordecai Brown - SP
76. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Reggie Jackson - OF
77. Toronto BJs - Curt Schilling - SP
78. Pittsburgh Pirates - Juan Marichal - SP
79. Toronto Maple Leafs - Clayton Kershaw - SP
80. Cleveland Indians - Wade Boggs - 3B
Round 5
81. Cleveland Indians - Charlie Gehringer - 2B
82. Toronto Maple Leafs - Ferguson Jenkins - SP
83. Pittsburgh Pirates - Pop Lloyd - SS
84. Toronto BJs - John Smoltz - SP/RP
85. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Arky Vaughan - SS
86. New York Yankees - Robin Roberts - SP
87. Homestead Grays - Ivan Rodriguez - C
88. St. Louis Cardinals - Harmon Killebrew - 1B/3B
89. Detroit Tigers - Rollie Fingers - RP
90. Chicago Whales - Gary Carter - C
91. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Pete Rose - IF/OF
92. Kansas City Athletics - Jeff Bagwell - 1B
93. Montgomery Biscuits - Roberto Alomar - 2B
94. San Francisco Giants - Barry Larkin - SS
95. Providence Steamrollers - Bill Dickey - C
96. Brooklyn Robins - Cool Papa Bell - OF
97. Chicago Black Sox - Phil Niekro - SP
98. St. Louis Stars - Ryne Sandberg - 2B
99. Pittsburgh Porters - Frank Thomas - 1B
100. Montreal Royals - Johnny Mize - 1B
Round 6
101. Brooklyn Robins - Rod Carew - 2B/1B
102. Detroit Tigers - Turkey Stearnes - OF
103. Homestead Grays - Addie Joss - SP
104. Chicago Black Sox - Mike Piazza - C
105. Montreal Royals - Craig Biggio - 2B
106. Providence Steamrollers - Jim Edmonds - OF
107. San Francisco Giants - Larry Walker - OF
108. Montgomery Biscuits - Derek Jeter - SS
109. St. Louis Cardinals - Tony Gwynn - OF
110. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Manny Ramirez - OF
111. Chicago Whales - Roy Halladay - SP
112. Pittsburgh Porters - Hoyt Wilhelm - SP/RP
113. Pittsburgh Pirates - Kevin Brown - SP
114. St. Louis Stars - Luke Appling - SS
115. New York Yankees - Carlton Fisk - C
116. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Mark McGwire - 1B
117. Toronto BJs - Ichiro Suzuki - OF
118. Kansas City Athletics - Robin Yount - SS/OF
119. Toronto Maple Leafs - Harry Heilmann - OF
120. Cleveland Indians - Hal Newhouser - SP
Round 7
121. Cleveland Indians - Tim Raines - OF
122. Toronto Maple Leafs - Willie McCovey - 1B
123. Kansas City Athletics - Lou Whitaker - 2B
124. Toronto BJs - Kirby Puckett - OF
125. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Frankie Frisch - 2B
126. New York Yankees - Bert Blyleven - SP
127. Brooklyn Robins - Adrian Beltre - 3B
128. Pittsburgh Pirates - Willie Stargell - 1B/OF
129. Pittsburgh Porters - Home Run Baker - 3B
130. Chicago Whales - Ron Santo - 3B
131. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Biz Mackey - C/SS
132. St. Louis Cardinals - Al Simmons - OF
133. Montreal Royals - Dennis Eckersley - RP/SP
134. San Francisco Giants - Scott Rolen - 3B
135. Providence Steamrollers - George Sisler - 1B
136. St. Louis Stars - Tim Keefe - SP
137. Chicago Black Sox - Ozzie Smith - SS
138. Homestead Grays - Jim Thome - 1B
139. Detroit Tigers - Ralph Kiner - OF
140. Montgomery Biscuits - Billy Wagner - RP
Round 8
141. Montgomery Biscuits - John Clarkson - SP
142. Pittsburgh Pirates - Paul Molitor - 3B/2B
143. Pittsburgh Pirates - Vladimir Guerrero - OF
144. Chicago Black Sox - Don Sutton - SP
145. St. Louis Stars - Dan Brouthers - 1B
146. Providence Steamrollers - Billy Williams - OF
147. San Francisco Giants - Billy Hamilton - OF
148. Montreal Royals - Alan Trammell - SS
149. St. Louis Cardinals - Dizzy Dean - SP
150. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Dazzy Vance - SP
151. Chicago Whales - Joe Medwick - OF
152. Pittsburgh Porters - Carlos Beltran - OF
153. Homestead Grays - Cristobal Torriente - OF
154. Brooklyn Robins - Jim Bunning - SP
155. New York Yankees - George Davis - SS
156. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Goose Gossage - RP
157. Toronto BJs - Andy Pettite - SP
158. St. Louis Cardinals - Bruce Sutter - RP
159. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe Cronin - SS
160. Cleveland Indians - Mike Trout - OF
Round 9
161. Cleveland Indians - Gabby Hartnett - C
162. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe Mauer - C
163. Kansas City Athletics - Lefty Gomez - SP
164. Toronto BJs - Trevor Hoffman - RP
165. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Johan Santana - SP
166. New York Yankees - Lee Smith - RP
167. St. Louis Stars - Old Hoss Radbourn - SP
168. Homestead Grays - Nomar Garciaparra - SS
169. Pittsburgh Porters - Joe Gordon - 2B
170. Chicago Whales - Don Mattingly - 1B
171. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Troy Tulowitzki - SS
172. Kansas City Athletics - Lou Brock - OF
173. Montgomery Biscuits - Dan Quisenberry - RP
174. San Francisco Giants - Jeff Kent - 2B
175. Providence Steamrollers - Tom Henke - RP
176. Brooklyn Robins - Jonathan Papelbon - RP
177. Chicago Black Sox - Francisco Rodriguez - RP
178. Detroit Tigers - Robinson Cano - 2B
179. Detroit Tigers - Bret Sabrehagen - SP
180. Montreal Royals - Stan Coveleski - SP
Round 10
181. Montreal Royals - Albert Belle - OF
182. Detroit Tigers - Sammy Sosa - OF
183. Homestead Grays - Catfish Hunter - SP
184. Chicago Black Sox - Rafael Palmeiro - 1B
185. Brooklyn Robins - Chase Utley - 2B
186. Providence Steamrollers - Rick Reuschel - SP
187. San Francisco Giants - Cap Anson - 1B
188. Montgomery Biscuits - Andre Dawson - OF
189. St. Louis Cardinals - Buck Leonard - 1B
190. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Sparky Lyle - RP
191. Chicago Whales - Gary Sheffield - OF
192. Pittsburgh Porters - John Franco - RP
193. Pittsburgh Pirates - Kent Tekulve - RP
194. St. Louis Stars - Mule Suttles - OF/1B
195. New York Yankees - Bobby Grich - 2B
196. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Thurman Munson - C
197. Toronto BJs - Graig Nettles - 3B
198. Kansas City Athletics - Paul Waner - OF
199. Toronto Maple Leafs - Goose Goslin - OF
200. Cleveland Indians - Luis Tiant - SP
Round 11
201. Cleveland Indians - Troy Percival - RP
202. Toronto Maple Leafs - Eddie Murray - 1B
203. St. Louis Cardinals - King Kelly - C/OF
204. Toronto BJs - Nellie Fox - 2B
205. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Smoky Joe Wood - SP
206. New York Yankees - Felix Hernandez - SP
207. St. Louis Stars - Ed Delahanty - OF
208. Pittsburgh Pirates - Zack Greinke - SP
209. Pittsburgh Porters - Orel Hershiser - SP
210. Chicago Whales - Omar Vizquel - SS
211. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Mike Marshall - RP
212. Kansas City Athletics - Lloyd Waner - OF
213. Montgomery Biscuits - Ted Simmons - C
214. San Francisco Giants - Lance Berkman - OF/1B
215. Providence Steamrollers - Luis Aparicio - SS
216. Brooklyn Robins - Jorge Posada - C
217. Chicago Black Sox - Justin Verlander - SP
218. Homestead Grays - Nap Rucker - SP
219. Detroit Tigers - Buster Posey - C
220. Montreal Royals - Ken Boyer - 3B
Round 12
221. Montreal Royals - Jim Kaat - SP
222. Detroit Tigers - Urban Shocker - SP
223. Toronto Maple Leafs - Billy Pierce - SP
224. Chicago Black Sox - Dustin Pedroia - 2B
225. Brooklyn Robins - Chief Bender - SP
226. Providence Steamrollers - Bob Lemon - SP
227. San Francisco Giants - Adam Wainwright - SP
228. Montgomery Biscuits - Pud Galvin - SP
229. St. Louis Cardinals - Lou Boudreau - SS
230. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Roger Connor - 1B
231. Chicago Whales - David Cone - SP
232. Pittsburgh Porters - Ron Guidry - SP
233. New York Yankees - Dave Righetti - RP/SP
234. St. Louis Stars - John Donaldson - SP
235. Pittsburgh Pirates - Richie Ashburn - OF
236. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Earl Averill - OF
237. Toronto BJs - Dwight Gooden - SP
238. Kansas City Athletics - John Wetteland - RP
239. Homestead Grays - Craig Kimbrel - RP
240. Cleveland Indians - Babe Adams - SP
Round 13
241. Cleveland Indians - Sadaharu Oh - 1B
242. Homestead Grays - Aroldis Chapman - RP
243. Kansas City Athletics - Early Wynn - SP
244. Toronto BJs - Todd Helton - 1B
245. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - John Hiller - RP
246. Pittsburgh Pirates - Randy Myers - RP
247. St. Louis Stars - Martin Dihigo - IF/OF/P
248. New York Yankees - David Wright - 3B
249. Pittsburgh Porters - Armando Benitez - RP
250. Chicago Whales - Robb Nen - RP
251. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Bobby Doerr - 2B
252. St. Louis Cardinals - Red Ruffing - SP
253. Montgomery Biscuits - Dave Winfield - OF
254. San Francisco Giants - Pee Wee Reese - SS
255. Providence Steamrollers - Dick Allen - 1B/3B
256. Brooklyn Robins - Jesse Orosco - RP
257. Chicago Black Sox - Luis Gonzalez - OF
258. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe McCarthy - MGR
259. Detroit Tigers - Edgar Martinez - 3B
260. Montreal Royals - Tug McGraw - RP
Round 14
261. Montreal Royals - Kenny Lofton - OF
262. Detroit Tigers - Madison Bumgarner - SP
263. Homestead Grays - Enos Slaughter - OF
264. Chicago Black Sox - C.C Sabathia - SP
265. Brooklyn Robins - Joe Sewell - SS
266. Providence Steamrollers - David Price - SP
267. San Francisco Giants - Wade Davis -RP
268. Montgomery Biscuits - Bernie Williams - OF
269. St. Louis Cardinals - Ron Perranoski - RP
270. Sioux City Cornhuskers - David Ortiz - 1B
271. Chicago Whales - Arthur Rhodes - RP
272. Pittsburgh Porters - Casey Stengel - MGR
273. Pittsburgh Pirates - Minnie Minoso - OF
274. St. Louis Stars - Ray Dandridge - 3B
275. New York Yankees - Joe Nathan - RP
276. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Wilbur Wood - RP/SP
277. Toronto BJs - Dale Murphy - OF
278. Kansas City Athletics - Hilton Smith - SP/RP
279. Toronto Maple Leafs - Sam Crawford - OF
280. Cleveland Indians - Tim Hudson - SP
Round 15
281. Cleveland Indians - Keith Foulke - RP
282. Toronto Maple Leafs - Tommy Bridges - SP
283. Kansas City Athletics - Greg Holland - RP
284. Toronto BJs - Sparky Anderson - MGR
285. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Zach Wheat - OF
286. New York Yankees - Eric Gagne - RP
287. Montreal Royals - Jeff Reardon - RP
288. Pittsburgh Pirates - Koji Uehara - RP
289. Pittsburgh Porters - Yadier Molina - C
290. Chicago Whales - Jason Isringhausen - RP
291. Sioux City Cornhuskers - John Candelaria - SP/RP
292. St. Louis Cardinals - Bill Terry - 1B
293. Montgomery Biscuits - Joe Torre - C/1B/3B
294. San Francisco Giants - Cole Hamels - SP
295. Providence Steamrollers - Todd Worrell - RP
296. Brooklyn Robins - Doug Jones - RP
297. Chicago Black Sox - Tony LaRussa - MGR
298. Homestead Grays - Kiki Cuyler - OF
299. Detroit Tigers - Willie Hernandez - RP
300. St. Louis Stars - Huston Street - RP
Round 16
301. St. Louis Stars - Bobby Shantz - RP
302. Detroit Tigers - B.J. Ryan - RP
303. Homestead Grays - Eddie Cicotte - SP
304. Chicago Black Sox - Brad Lidge - RP
305. Brooklyn Robins - Fred McGriff - 1B
306. Providence Steamrollers - Robin Ventura - 3B
307. San Francisco Giants - Rafael Soriano - RP
308. Montgomery Biscuits - Roy Face - RP
309. St. Louis Cardinals - Rob Dibble - RP
310. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Jack Morris - SP
311. Chicago Whales - Chris Carpenter - SP
312. Pittsburgh Porters - Waite Hoyt - RP/SP
313. Pittsburgh Pirates - Russell Martin - C
314. Montreal Royals - Bobby Abreu - OF
315. New York Yankees - Andruw Jones - OF
316. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Mark Eichhorn - RP
317. Toronto BJs - Tom Gordon - SP/RP
318. Kansas City Athletics - Jeff Nelson - RP
319. Toronto Maple Leafs - Firpo Marberry - RP/SP
320. Cleveland Indians - Larry Doby - OF
Round 17
321. Cleveland Indians - Walter Alston - MGR
322. Toronto Maple Leafs - Red Faber - SP
323. Kansas City Athletics - Francisco Cordero - RP
324. Toronto BJs - Lindy McDaniel - RP/SP
325. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Joe McGinnity - SP
326. New York Yankees - Bill Dahlen - SS/3B
327. St. Louis Stars - Ellis Kinder - RP/SP
328. Pittsburgh Pirates - Rick Aguilera - RP
329. Pittsburgh Porters - Andrew McCutchen - OF
330. Chicago Whales - Earl Weaver - MGR
331. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Vince Coleman - OF
332. St. Louis Cardinals - Ernie Lombardi - C
333. Montgomery Biscuits - Jason Giambi - 1B
334. San Francisco Giants - Jim McCormick - SP
335. Providence Steamrollers - Gary Lavelle - RP
336. Brooklyn Robins - Cliff Lee - SP
337. Chicago Black Sox - Jose Valverde - RP
338. Homestead Grays - Sergio Romo - RP
339. Detroit Tigers - John McGraw - MGR
340. Montreal Royals - Ben Zobrist - 2B/SS/OF
Round 18
341. Montreal Royals - Darrell Porter - C
342. Detroit Tigers - Bill Mazeroski - 2B
343. Homestead Grays - Masaichi Kaneda - SP
344. Chicago Black Sox - Jimmy Rollins - SS
345. Brooklyn Robins - Dan Plesac - RP
346. Providence Steamrollers - Bob Welch - SP
347. San Francisco Giants - Don McMahon - RP
348. Montgomery Biscuits - Steve Bedrosian - RP
349. St. Louis Cardinals - John McGraw - 3B/SS
350. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Bullet Joe Rogan - SP/OF
351. Chicago Whales - Juan Gonzalez - OF
352. Pittsburgh Porters - Joey Votto - 1B
353. Pittsburgh Pirates - Billy Herman - 2B
354. St. Louis Stars - Leon Day - SP
355. New York Yankees - Harry Brecheen - SP
356. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Hack Wilson - OF
357. Toronto BJs - Roger Maris - OF
358. Kansas City Athletics - Wes Ferrell - SP
359. Toronto Maple Leafs - Tony Oliva - OF
360. Cleveland Indians - Lance Parrish - C
Round 19
361. Cleveland Indians - Roberto Hernandez - RP
362. Toronto Maple Leafs - Jeff Montgomery - RP
363. Kansas City Athletics - Kerry Wood - SP/RP
364. Toronto BJs - Jack Glasscock - SS
365. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Hanley Ramirez - SS
366. New York Yankees - Keith Hernandez - 1B
367. St. Louis Stars - Héctor Espino - OF
368. Pittsburgh Pirates - Jon Matlack - SP
369. Pittsburgh Porters - Jon Lester - SP
370. Chicago Whales - Tony Fernandez - SS/3B/2B
371. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Joe Hoerner - RP
372. St. Louis Cardinals - Al Hrabosky - RP
373. Montgomery Biscuits - Michael Young - SS/3B/2B
374. San Francisco Giants - Jose Bautista - OF/3B
375. Providence Steamrollers - Jim Rice - OF
376. Brooklyn Robins - Ron Cey - 3B
377. Chicago Black Sox - Mark Teixeira - 1B
378. Homestead Grays - Max Lanier - SP
379. Detroit Tigers - Norm Cash - 1B
380. Montreal Royals - Bill Freehan - C
Round 20
381. Montreal Royals - Ted Lyons - SP
382. Detroit Tigers - Gene Garber - RP
383. Homestead Grays - Katsuya Nomura - C
384. Chicago Black Sox - Heath Bell - RP
385. Brooklyn Robins - Moises Alou - OF
386. Providence Steamrollers - Placido Polanco - 2B/3B
387. San Francisco Giants - Tommy John - SP
388. Montgomery Biscuits - Cesar Cedeno -OF
389. St. Louis Cardinals - Max Carey - OF
390. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Rod Beck - RP
391. Chicago Whales - Torii Hunter - OF
392. Pittsburgh Porters - Matt Williams - 3B
393. Pittsburgh Pirates - Jimmy Dykes - 3B/2B
394. St. Louis Stars - Stu Miller - RP/SP
395. New York Yankees - Gene Tenace - C
396. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Carlos Delgado - 1B
397. Toronto BJs - Fernando Valenzuela - P
398. Kansas City Athletics - Will Clark - 1B
399. Toronto Maple Leafs - Vida Blue - SP
400. Cleveland Indians - John Olerud - 1B
Round 21
401. Cleveland Indians - Steve Kline - RP
402. Toronto Maple Leafs - Mike Timlin - RP
403. Kansas City Athletics - Bobby Bonilla - 3B/OF
404. Toronto BJs - Victor Martinez - C/1B
405. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Tony Lazzeri -2B
406. New York Yankees - Pete Browning - OF
407. St. Louis Stars - Wally Schang - C/OF
408. Pittsburgh Pirates - Lenny Dykstra - OF
409. Pittsburgh Porters - Takashi Saito - RP
410. Chicago Whales - Andrew Miller - RP
411. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Connie Mack - MGR
412. St. Louis Cardinals - Bob Stanley - RP
413. Montgomery Biscuits - David Wells - SP
414. San Francisco Giants - Buck Ewing - C
415. Providence Steamrollers - Rick Dempsey - C
416. Brooklyn Robins - Elston Howard - C
417. Chicago Black Sox - Brian McCann - C
418. Homestead Grays - Rabbit Maranville - SS/2B
419. Detroit Tigers - Chuck Klein - OF
420. Montreal Royals - Darrell Evans - 3B/1B
Round 22
421. Montreal Royals - Orlando Cepeda - 1B/OF
422. Detroit Tigers - Mike Cuellar - SP
423. Homestead Grays - Steve Garvey - 1B
424. Chicago Black Sox - Derek Lowe - SP/RP
425. Brooklyn Robins - Chuck Finley - SP
426. Providence Steamrollers - Paul Lindblad - RP
427. San Francisco Giants - Kenley Jansen - RP
428. Montgomery Biscuits - Norm Charlton - RP
429. St. Louis Cardinals - Bill Foster - SP
430. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Maury Wills - SS
431. Chicago Whales - Jason Kendall - C
432. Pittsburgh Porters - Roger Bresnahan - C
433. Pittsburgh Pirates - Charlie Keller - OF
434. St. Louis Stars - Toby Harrah - 3B/SS
435. New York Yankees - Willie Randolph - 2B
436. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Dave Stieb - SP
437. Toronto BJs - Chuck Knoblauch - 2B
438. Kansas City Athletics - Mickey Tettleton - C
439. Toronto Maple Leafs - Steve Howe - RP
440. Cleveland Indians - Al Brazle - RP/SP
Round 23
441. Cleveland Indians - Tony Phillips - OF/2B/3B/SS
442. Toronto Maple Leafs - Vada Pinson - OF
443. Kansas City Athletics - Julio Franco - SS/2B/1B
444. Toronto BJs - Brian Giles - OF
445. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Deacon White - 3B/C
446. New York Yankees - Brad Ziegler - RP
447. St. Louis Stars - Rube Foster - MGR
448. Pittsburgh Pirates - Teddy Higuera - SP
449. Pittsburgh Porters - Noodles Hahn - SP
450. Chicago Whales - Matt Holliday - OF
451. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Rick Honeycutt - RP
452. St. Louis Cardinals - Joe Torre - MGR
453. Montgomery Biscuits - Tim Wakefield - SP
454. San Francisco Giants - Bruce Bochy - MGR
455. Providence Steamrollers - Willie Wilson - OF
456. Brooklyn Robins - Bert Campaneris - SS
457. Chicago Black Sox - Brian Wilson - RP
458. Homestead Grays - Ryan Braun - OF/3B
459. Detroit Tigers - Evan Longoria - 3B
460. Montreal Royals - Darren O'Day - RP
Round 24
461. Montreal Royals - Mike Stanton - RP
462. Detroit Tigers - Joakim Soria - RP
463. Homestead Grays - Tony Watson - RP
464. Chicago Black Sox - Ian Kinsler - 2B
465. Brooklyn Robins - Mike Adams - RP
466. Providence Steamrollers - Allie Reynolds - SP/RP
467. San Francisco Giants - Prince Fielder - 1B
468. Montgomery Biscuits - Luis Castillo - 2B
469. St. Louis Cardinals - Dwight Evans - OF
470. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Arlie Latham - 3B
471. Chicago Whales - Brian Fuentes - RP
472. Pittsburgh Porters - Elmer Flick - OF
473. Pittsburgh Pirates - Terry Forster - RP
474. St. Louis Stars - Jake Beckley - 1B
475. New York Yankees - Bobby Cox - MGR
476. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Bobby Bonds - OF
477. Toronto BJs - Jimmy Key - SP
478. Kansas City Athletics - Miguel Tejada - SS
479. Toronto Maple Leafs - Jim Sundberg - C
480. Cleveland Indians - Eric Chavez - 3B
Round 25
481. Cleveland Indians - Fred Lynn - OF
482. Toronto Maple Leafs - Gil McDougald - 2B/SS/3B
483. Kansas City Athletics - Miller Huggins - MGR
484. Toronto BJs - Otis Nixon - OF
485. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Virgil Trucks - SP/RP
486. New York Yankees - Jim Brewer - RP
487. St. Louis Stars - Don Mossi - RP/SP
488. Pittsburgh Pirates - Babe Herman - 1B/OF
489. Pittsburgh Porters - Bobby Wallace - SS/3B
490. Chicago Whales - Bret Boone - 2B
491. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Jacoby Ellsbury - OF
492. St. Louis Cardinals - Red Schoendienst - 2B
493. Montgomery Biscuits - Jim Leyland - MGR
494. San Francisco Giants - Dick Radatz - RP
495. Providence Steamrollers - Paul Konerko - 1B
496. Brooklyn Robins - Jose Vidro - 2B
497. Chicago Black Sox - Johnny Damon - OF
498. Homestead Grays - Reggie Smith - OF
499. Detroit Tigers - Darryl Strawberry - OF
500. Montreal Royals - Dick Williams - MGR
Round 26
501. Montreal Royals - Roy Oswalt - SP
502. Detroit Tigers - Joe Dugan - 3B/SS
503. Homestead Grays - Tommy Lasorda - MGR
504. Chicago Black Sox - Josh Donaldson - 3B
505. Brooklyn Robins - Leo Durocher - MGR
506. Providence Steamrollers - Danny Murtaugh - MGR
507. San Francisco Giants - Bobby Thigpen - RP
508. Montgomery Biscuits - Alfonso Soriano - 2B/OF
509. St. Louis Cardinals - Burleigh Grimes - SP
510. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Joe Girardi - C
511. Chicago Whales - Derrek Lee - 1B
512. Pittsburgh Porters - Dutch Leonard - SP/RP
513. Pittsburgh Pirates - Chuck Tanner - MGR
514. St. Louis Stars - Chet Lemon - OF
515. New York Yankees - Dummy Hoy - OF
516. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Fred Clarke - MGR
517. Toronto BJs - Clay Carroll - RP
518. Kansas City Athletics - Monte Irvin - OF
519. Toronto Maple Leafs - David Robertson - RP
520. Cleveland Indians - Moe Drabowsky - RP/SP
Essentially, the game will follow the same well-refined format as the hockey all-time draft. It is designed primarily as a fun competition, but of greater importance is to honor the history of baseball and the players that have shaped the game, from the early beginnings to the present day.
The format is quite simple. A drafting order will be randomly generated. This draft order will reverse every second round (snake draft).
Each team will draft a complete roster, with a total of 25 players and one manager (grand total of 26 draft picks). Each team should have a starter at each position (1B, 2B, SS, 3B, CF, RF, LF, C), as well as a full starting rotation of 5 and a closer. There will also be no DH included within the rosters.
Your goal is to assemble the best possible roster, choosing from any player who has ever played baseball, at any level, anywhere in the world. At the conclusion of the draft, regular season voting will be conducted by your peers in the draft (possibly others, such as spectators who happen to follow the draft and participate in discussion). From these voting results we will determine our regular season standings, and then the playoffs begin!
I'll split the draft into 2 leagues, then playoffs will behave in this fashion after regular season concludes.
Playoff Format
Each playoff round will last a week for discussion of the matchups and for each team to state its case, at which point more votes are taken. In this case you vote for the winner of the series and how many games it will take. This continues until we have determined our champion.
Rules
1. NEVER mention an undrafted player. It is poor etiquette. If quoting a source about a player you’re drafting, simply substitute the undrafted player with XXXX XXXX.
2. The time limit changes throughout the draft. This will be how it runs:
Round 1-2: 24 Hour Time Limit
Round 3-7: 12 Hour Time Limit
Round 8-21: 8 Hour Time Limit
Round 22-26: 4 Hour Time Limit
If you are not sure whether you will be available to make your pick within the allotted time, please send a list of players to someone who will be there for that time. This way the draft can progress nicely.
3. You MUST send a private message to the next GM to alert them that it is their turn. This is mandatory and it is crucial to the draft going smoothly. You should also change your board preferences so that you receive an email when you receive a PM. Many have found that this ensures that when it's your turn, you know as soon as possible.
4. Please be advised that it is MANDATORY to vote if you expect to participate in the next All-Time Draft. Put some effort into it. It's only fair that the best team wins. You can make your votes based on whatever criteria are important to you, but we are all expected to have an open mind and listen to the arguments for why each roster is better.
5. The draft is 26 rounds long. Each team will make 26 picks with one player at each position and one manager alongside extra bench players.
6. Trades are allowed, but are certainly not essential to winning or doing better. You can trade a player you've already drafted, as well as future picks. Trading conversations are always held via PM, but you may announce that you are shopping a pick or looking to move up/down to get the attention of other GMs. You must always trade one asset for another asset. (or 2 for 2, or 3 for 3, etc) (no 2-for-1 or 3-for-2 deals or else you wouldn't end up with 26 picks)
7. When making a pick, you should be posting at least three lines about the player. This can be in your own words or copied and pasted from a cited source. This is done for a couple of reasons: 1) To prove that you know something about him/have researched him. 2) To show the other GMs why this is a good pick.
8. DO NOT MENTION UNDRAFTED PLAYERS.
Co-Gm's are allowed and encouraged if you dont have as much knowledge of baseball. No more than 2 GM's to a team though.
If you select a player who played most of his career at lets say 1B but played for 2 years at LF, and choose him to play left field. You can draft him at both...however...this will downgrade the players ability. Its a risk that you can make but you have a better chance of winning if you have everyone at there natural position.
You will need to have atleast 1 Manager, 1 C, 1 1B, 1 2B, 1 3B, 1 SS, 1 LF, 1 CF, 1 RF, 5 SP, 3 RP including 1 closer. And again like the position players, if you move a reliever to a starter or vice versa, then that will affect how effective your player will be. NO DH
FOR PLAYOFFS IT WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED THAT VOTING IS DONE REGULARLY and if you want to stay for another Baseball ATD then it is a good idea to vote because it will give us the mindset that you care about the draft and not just your team.
Winner/Runnerup
1st Edition: Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)/BintZ (New York Mets)
2nd Edition: Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)/Chaosrevolver (Brooklyn Dodgers)
3rd Edition: Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)/Ranger Wolf (New York Highlanders)
4th Edition: Chaosrevolver (Chicago Cubs)/Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)
5th Edition: UL Washington (Brooklyn Superbas)/Pwnasaurus (Pittsburgh Crawfords)
6th Edition: Gootie (Chicago Whales)/Modo (Yomiuri Giants)
7th Edition: UL Washington (Chicago Orphans)/Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)
8th Edition: Darko (New York Yankees)/Pwnasaurus (St. Louis Cardinals)
The Teams
1. Fish on The Sand - Cleveland Indians (American League)
2. JaysCyYoung - Toronto Maple Leafs (American League)
3. papershoes/Wrigley - Kansas City Athletics (American League)
4. Porn*/GIN ANTONIC - Toronto BJs (American League)
5. UL Washington - Brooklyn Bridegrooms (American League)
6. Darko - New York Yankees (American League)
7. bluesfan94 - St. Louis Stars (National League)
8. td_ice - Pittsburgh Pirates (National League)
9. 87and71 - Pittsburgh Porters (National League)
10. Gootie - Chicago Whales (American League)
11. Modo - Sioux City Cornhuskers (National League)
12. Pwnasaurus - St. Louis Cardinals (National League)
13. DisgruntledHawkFan - Montgomery Biscuits (National League)
14. ryan callahan - San Francisco Giants (National League)
15. GarbageGoal - Providence Steamrollers (American League)
16. Old Man Willie - Brooklyn Robins (National League)
17. Shawked - Chicago Black Sox (American League)
18. Winger For Hire - Homestead Grays (National League)
19. Vegeta - Detroit Tigers (American League)
20. le_sean - Montreal Royals (National League)
Round 1
1. Cleveland Indians - Babe Ruth - OF
2. Toronto Maple Leafs - Willie Mays - OF
3. Kansas City Athletics - Walter Johnson - SP
4. Toronto BJs - Ted Williams - OF
5. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Lefty Grove - SP
6. New York Yankees - Barry Bonds - OF
7. St. Louis Stars - Josh Gibson - C
8. Pittsburgh Pirates - Lou Gehrig - 1B
9. Pittsburgh Porters - Honus Wagner - SS
10. Chicago Whales - Ty Cobb - OF
11. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Sandy Koufax - SP
12. St. Louis Cardinals - Rogers Hornsby - 2B
13. Montgomery Biscuits - Christy Mathewson - SP
14. San Francisco Giants - Cy Young - SP
15. Providence Steamrollers - Hank Aaron - OF
16. Brooklyn Robins - Randy Johnson - SP
17. Chicago Black Sox - Roger Clemens - SP
18. St. Louis Stars - Grover Cleveland Alexander - SP
19. Pittsburgh Porters - Stan Musial - OF/1B
20. Montreal Royals - Tris Speaker - OF
Round 2
21. Montreal Royals - Satchel Paige - SP
22. Detroit Tigers - Alex Rodriguez - SS/3B
23. Homestead Grays - Eddie Collins - 2B
24. Chicago Black Sox - Mickey Mantle - OF
25. Homestead Grays - Rickey Henderson - OF
26. Providence Steamrollers - Nap Lajoie - 2B
27. San Francisco Giants - Tom Seaver - SP
28. Montgomery Biscuits - Mike Schmidt - 3B
29. St. Louis Cardinals - Bob Gibson - SP
30. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Ken Griffey Jr - OF
31. Chicago Whales - Greg Maddux - SP
32. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Pedro Martinez - SP
33. Pittsburgh Pirates - Warren Spahn - SP
34. Brooklyn Robins - Carl Yastrzemski - OF
35. New York Yankees - Joe DiMaggio - OF
36. Detroit Tigers - Jimmie Foxx - 1B
37. Toronto BJs - Johnny Bench - C
38. Kansas City Athletics - Eddie Mathews - 3B
39. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe Morgan - 2B
40. Cleveland Indians - Steve Carlton - SP
Round 3
41. Cleveland Indians - Cal Ripken - SS
42. Toronto Maple Leafs - George Brett - 3B
43. Kansas City Athletics - Yogi Berra - C
44. Toronto BJs - Ernie Banks - SS
45. Detroit Tigers - Kid Nichols - SP
46. New York Yankees - Hank Greenberg - 1B
47. Brooklyn Robins - Bob Feller - SP
48. Pittsburgh Pirates - Roy Campanella - C
49. Detroit Tigers - Nolan Ryan - SP
50. Chicago Whales - Jackie Robinson - 2B
51. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Roberto Clemente - OF
52. St. Louis Cardinals - Duke Snider - OF
53. Montgomery Biscuits - Albert Pujols - 1B
54. Montreal Royals - Frank Robinson - OF
55. Providence Steamrollers - Eddie Plank - SP
56. Homestead Grays - Jim Palmer - SP
57. Chicago Black Sox - Mel Ott - OF
58. Homestead Grays - Chipper Jones - 3B/OF
59. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Miguel Cabrera - 1B/3B
60. San Francisco Giants - Whitey Ford - SP
Round 4
61. San Francisco Giants - Mickey Cochrane - C
62. Pittsburgh Porters - Joe Jackson - OF
63. St. Louis Stars - Oscar Charleston - OF
64. Chicago Black Sox - Brooks Robinson - 3B
65. Montreal Royals - Carl Hubbell - SP
66. Providence Steamrollers - Gaylord Perry - SP
67. Brooklyn Robins - Al Kaline - OF
68. Montgomery Biscuits - Tom Glavine - SP
69. Kansas City Athletics - Mike Mussina - SP
70. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Don Drysdale - SP
71. Chicago Whales - Ed Walsh - SP
72. Pittsburgh Porters - Mariano Rivera - RP
73. St. Louis Cardinals - Rube Waddell - SP
74. St. Louis Stars - Smokey Joe Williams - SP
75. New York Yankees - Mordecai Brown - SP
76. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Reggie Jackson - OF
77. Toronto BJs - Curt Schilling - SP
78. Pittsburgh Pirates - Juan Marichal - SP
79. Toronto Maple Leafs - Clayton Kershaw - SP
80. Cleveland Indians - Wade Boggs - 3B
Round 5
81. Cleveland Indians - Charlie Gehringer - 2B
82. Toronto Maple Leafs - Ferguson Jenkins - SP
83. Pittsburgh Pirates - Pop Lloyd - SS
84. Toronto BJs - John Smoltz - SP/RP
85. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Arky Vaughan - SS
86. New York Yankees - Robin Roberts - SP
87. Homestead Grays - Ivan Rodriguez - C
88. St. Louis Cardinals - Harmon Killebrew - 1B/3B
89. Detroit Tigers - Rollie Fingers - RP
90. Chicago Whales - Gary Carter - C
91. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Pete Rose - IF/OF
92. Kansas City Athletics - Jeff Bagwell - 1B
93. Montgomery Biscuits - Roberto Alomar - 2B
94. San Francisco Giants - Barry Larkin - SS
95. Providence Steamrollers - Bill Dickey - C
96. Brooklyn Robins - Cool Papa Bell - OF
97. Chicago Black Sox - Phil Niekro - SP
98. St. Louis Stars - Ryne Sandberg - 2B
99. Pittsburgh Porters - Frank Thomas - 1B
100. Montreal Royals - Johnny Mize - 1B
Round 6
101. Brooklyn Robins - Rod Carew - 2B/1B
102. Detroit Tigers - Turkey Stearnes - OF
103. Homestead Grays - Addie Joss - SP
104. Chicago Black Sox - Mike Piazza - C
105. Montreal Royals - Craig Biggio - 2B
106. Providence Steamrollers - Jim Edmonds - OF
107. San Francisco Giants - Larry Walker - OF
108. Montgomery Biscuits - Derek Jeter - SS
109. St. Louis Cardinals - Tony Gwynn - OF
110. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Manny Ramirez - OF
111. Chicago Whales - Roy Halladay - SP
112. Pittsburgh Porters - Hoyt Wilhelm - SP/RP
113. Pittsburgh Pirates - Kevin Brown - SP
114. St. Louis Stars - Luke Appling - SS
115. New York Yankees - Carlton Fisk - C
116. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Mark McGwire - 1B
117. Toronto BJs - Ichiro Suzuki - OF
118. Kansas City Athletics - Robin Yount - SS/OF
119. Toronto Maple Leafs - Harry Heilmann - OF
120. Cleveland Indians - Hal Newhouser - SP
Round 7
121. Cleveland Indians - Tim Raines - OF
122. Toronto Maple Leafs - Willie McCovey - 1B
123. Kansas City Athletics - Lou Whitaker - 2B
124. Toronto BJs - Kirby Puckett - OF
125. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Frankie Frisch - 2B
126. New York Yankees - Bert Blyleven - SP
127. Brooklyn Robins - Adrian Beltre - 3B
128. Pittsburgh Pirates - Willie Stargell - 1B/OF
129. Pittsburgh Porters - Home Run Baker - 3B
130. Chicago Whales - Ron Santo - 3B
131. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Biz Mackey - C/SS
132. St. Louis Cardinals - Al Simmons - OF
133. Montreal Royals - Dennis Eckersley - RP/SP
134. San Francisco Giants - Scott Rolen - 3B
135. Providence Steamrollers - George Sisler - 1B
136. St. Louis Stars - Tim Keefe - SP
137. Chicago Black Sox - Ozzie Smith - SS
138. Homestead Grays - Jim Thome - 1B
139. Detroit Tigers - Ralph Kiner - OF
140. Montgomery Biscuits - Billy Wagner - RP
Round 8
141. Montgomery Biscuits - John Clarkson - SP
142. Pittsburgh Pirates - Paul Molitor - 3B/2B
143. Pittsburgh Pirates - Vladimir Guerrero - OF
144. Chicago Black Sox - Don Sutton - SP
145. St. Louis Stars - Dan Brouthers - 1B
146. Providence Steamrollers - Billy Williams - OF
147. San Francisco Giants - Billy Hamilton - OF
148. Montreal Royals - Alan Trammell - SS
149. St. Louis Cardinals - Dizzy Dean - SP
150. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Dazzy Vance - SP
151. Chicago Whales - Joe Medwick - OF
152. Pittsburgh Porters - Carlos Beltran - OF
153. Homestead Grays - Cristobal Torriente - OF
154. Brooklyn Robins - Jim Bunning - SP
155. New York Yankees - George Davis - SS
156. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Goose Gossage - RP
157. Toronto BJs - Andy Pettite - SP
158. St. Louis Cardinals - Bruce Sutter - RP
159. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe Cronin - SS
160. Cleveland Indians - Mike Trout - OF
Round 9
161. Cleveland Indians - Gabby Hartnett - C
162. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe Mauer - C
163. Kansas City Athletics - Lefty Gomez - SP
164. Toronto BJs - Trevor Hoffman - RP
165. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Johan Santana - SP
166. New York Yankees - Lee Smith - RP
167. St. Louis Stars - Old Hoss Radbourn - SP
168. Homestead Grays - Nomar Garciaparra - SS
169. Pittsburgh Porters - Joe Gordon - 2B
170. Chicago Whales - Don Mattingly - 1B
171. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Troy Tulowitzki - SS
172. Kansas City Athletics - Lou Brock - OF
173. Montgomery Biscuits - Dan Quisenberry - RP
174. San Francisco Giants - Jeff Kent - 2B
175. Providence Steamrollers - Tom Henke - RP
176. Brooklyn Robins - Jonathan Papelbon - RP
177. Chicago Black Sox - Francisco Rodriguez - RP
178. Detroit Tigers - Robinson Cano - 2B
179. Detroit Tigers - Bret Sabrehagen - SP
180. Montreal Royals - Stan Coveleski - SP
Round 10
181. Montreal Royals - Albert Belle - OF
182. Detroit Tigers - Sammy Sosa - OF
183. Homestead Grays - Catfish Hunter - SP
184. Chicago Black Sox - Rafael Palmeiro - 1B
185. Brooklyn Robins - Chase Utley - 2B
186. Providence Steamrollers - Rick Reuschel - SP
187. San Francisco Giants - Cap Anson - 1B
188. Montgomery Biscuits - Andre Dawson - OF
189. St. Louis Cardinals - Buck Leonard - 1B
190. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Sparky Lyle - RP
191. Chicago Whales - Gary Sheffield - OF
192. Pittsburgh Porters - John Franco - RP
193. Pittsburgh Pirates - Kent Tekulve - RP
194. St. Louis Stars - Mule Suttles - OF/1B
195. New York Yankees - Bobby Grich - 2B
196. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Thurman Munson - C
197. Toronto BJs - Graig Nettles - 3B
198. Kansas City Athletics - Paul Waner - OF
199. Toronto Maple Leafs - Goose Goslin - OF
200. Cleveland Indians - Luis Tiant - SP
Round 11
201. Cleveland Indians - Troy Percival - RP
202. Toronto Maple Leafs - Eddie Murray - 1B
203. St. Louis Cardinals - King Kelly - C/OF
204. Toronto BJs - Nellie Fox - 2B
205. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Smoky Joe Wood - SP
206. New York Yankees - Felix Hernandez - SP
207. St. Louis Stars - Ed Delahanty - OF
208. Pittsburgh Pirates - Zack Greinke - SP
209. Pittsburgh Porters - Orel Hershiser - SP
210. Chicago Whales - Omar Vizquel - SS
211. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Mike Marshall - RP
212. Kansas City Athletics - Lloyd Waner - OF
213. Montgomery Biscuits - Ted Simmons - C
214. San Francisco Giants - Lance Berkman - OF/1B
215. Providence Steamrollers - Luis Aparicio - SS
216. Brooklyn Robins - Jorge Posada - C
217. Chicago Black Sox - Justin Verlander - SP
218. Homestead Grays - Nap Rucker - SP
219. Detroit Tigers - Buster Posey - C
220. Montreal Royals - Ken Boyer - 3B
Round 12
221. Montreal Royals - Jim Kaat - SP
222. Detroit Tigers - Urban Shocker - SP
223. Toronto Maple Leafs - Billy Pierce - SP
224. Chicago Black Sox - Dustin Pedroia - 2B
225. Brooklyn Robins - Chief Bender - SP
226. Providence Steamrollers - Bob Lemon - SP
227. San Francisco Giants - Adam Wainwright - SP
228. Montgomery Biscuits - Pud Galvin - SP
229. St. Louis Cardinals - Lou Boudreau - SS
230. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Roger Connor - 1B
231. Chicago Whales - David Cone - SP
232. Pittsburgh Porters - Ron Guidry - SP
233. New York Yankees - Dave Righetti - RP/SP
234. St. Louis Stars - John Donaldson - SP
235. Pittsburgh Pirates - Richie Ashburn - OF
236. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Earl Averill - OF
237. Toronto BJs - Dwight Gooden - SP
238. Kansas City Athletics - John Wetteland - RP
239. Homestead Grays - Craig Kimbrel - RP
240. Cleveland Indians - Babe Adams - SP
Round 13
241. Cleveland Indians - Sadaharu Oh - 1B
242. Homestead Grays - Aroldis Chapman - RP
243. Kansas City Athletics - Early Wynn - SP
244. Toronto BJs - Todd Helton - 1B
245. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - John Hiller - RP
246. Pittsburgh Pirates - Randy Myers - RP
247. St. Louis Stars - Martin Dihigo - IF/OF/P
248. New York Yankees - David Wright - 3B
249. Pittsburgh Porters - Armando Benitez - RP
250. Chicago Whales - Robb Nen - RP
251. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Bobby Doerr - 2B
252. St. Louis Cardinals - Red Ruffing - SP
253. Montgomery Biscuits - Dave Winfield - OF
254. San Francisco Giants - Pee Wee Reese - SS
255. Providence Steamrollers - Dick Allen - 1B/3B
256. Brooklyn Robins - Jesse Orosco - RP
257. Chicago Black Sox - Luis Gonzalez - OF
258. Toronto Maple Leafs - Joe McCarthy - MGR
259. Detroit Tigers - Edgar Martinez - 3B
260. Montreal Royals - Tug McGraw - RP
Round 14
261. Montreal Royals - Kenny Lofton - OF
262. Detroit Tigers - Madison Bumgarner - SP
263. Homestead Grays - Enos Slaughter - OF
264. Chicago Black Sox - C.C Sabathia - SP
265. Brooklyn Robins - Joe Sewell - SS
266. Providence Steamrollers - David Price - SP
267. San Francisco Giants - Wade Davis -RP
268. Montgomery Biscuits - Bernie Williams - OF
269. St. Louis Cardinals - Ron Perranoski - RP
270. Sioux City Cornhuskers - David Ortiz - 1B
271. Chicago Whales - Arthur Rhodes - RP
272. Pittsburgh Porters - Casey Stengel - MGR
273. Pittsburgh Pirates - Minnie Minoso - OF
274. St. Louis Stars - Ray Dandridge - 3B
275. New York Yankees - Joe Nathan - RP
276. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Wilbur Wood - RP/SP
277. Toronto BJs - Dale Murphy - OF
278. Kansas City Athletics - Hilton Smith - SP/RP
279. Toronto Maple Leafs - Sam Crawford - OF
280. Cleveland Indians - Tim Hudson - SP
Round 15
281. Cleveland Indians - Keith Foulke - RP
282. Toronto Maple Leafs - Tommy Bridges - SP
283. Kansas City Athletics - Greg Holland - RP
284. Toronto BJs - Sparky Anderson - MGR
285. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Zach Wheat - OF
286. New York Yankees - Eric Gagne - RP
287. Montreal Royals - Jeff Reardon - RP
288. Pittsburgh Pirates - Koji Uehara - RP
289. Pittsburgh Porters - Yadier Molina - C
290. Chicago Whales - Jason Isringhausen - RP
291. Sioux City Cornhuskers - John Candelaria - SP/RP
292. St. Louis Cardinals - Bill Terry - 1B
293. Montgomery Biscuits - Joe Torre - C/1B/3B
294. San Francisco Giants - Cole Hamels - SP
295. Providence Steamrollers - Todd Worrell - RP
296. Brooklyn Robins - Doug Jones - RP
297. Chicago Black Sox - Tony LaRussa - MGR
298. Homestead Grays - Kiki Cuyler - OF
299. Detroit Tigers - Willie Hernandez - RP
300. St. Louis Stars - Huston Street - RP
Round 16
301. St. Louis Stars - Bobby Shantz - RP
302. Detroit Tigers - B.J. Ryan - RP
303. Homestead Grays - Eddie Cicotte - SP
304. Chicago Black Sox - Brad Lidge - RP
305. Brooklyn Robins - Fred McGriff - 1B
306. Providence Steamrollers - Robin Ventura - 3B
307. San Francisco Giants - Rafael Soriano - RP
308. Montgomery Biscuits - Roy Face - RP
309. St. Louis Cardinals - Rob Dibble - RP
310. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Jack Morris - SP
311. Chicago Whales - Chris Carpenter - SP
312. Pittsburgh Porters - Waite Hoyt - RP/SP
313. Pittsburgh Pirates - Russell Martin - C
314. Montreal Royals - Bobby Abreu - OF
315. New York Yankees - Andruw Jones - OF
316. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Mark Eichhorn - RP
317. Toronto BJs - Tom Gordon - SP/RP
318. Kansas City Athletics - Jeff Nelson - RP
319. Toronto Maple Leafs - Firpo Marberry - RP/SP
320. Cleveland Indians - Larry Doby - OF
Round 17
321. Cleveland Indians - Walter Alston - MGR
322. Toronto Maple Leafs - Red Faber - SP
323. Kansas City Athletics - Francisco Cordero - RP
324. Toronto BJs - Lindy McDaniel - RP/SP
325. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Joe McGinnity - SP
326. New York Yankees - Bill Dahlen - SS/3B
327. St. Louis Stars - Ellis Kinder - RP/SP
328. Pittsburgh Pirates - Rick Aguilera - RP
329. Pittsburgh Porters - Andrew McCutchen - OF
330. Chicago Whales - Earl Weaver - MGR
331. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Vince Coleman - OF
332. St. Louis Cardinals - Ernie Lombardi - C
333. Montgomery Biscuits - Jason Giambi - 1B
334. San Francisco Giants - Jim McCormick - SP
335. Providence Steamrollers - Gary Lavelle - RP
336. Brooklyn Robins - Cliff Lee - SP
337. Chicago Black Sox - Jose Valverde - RP
338. Homestead Grays - Sergio Romo - RP
339. Detroit Tigers - John McGraw - MGR
340. Montreal Royals - Ben Zobrist - 2B/SS/OF
Round 18
341. Montreal Royals - Darrell Porter - C
342. Detroit Tigers - Bill Mazeroski - 2B
343. Homestead Grays - Masaichi Kaneda - SP
344. Chicago Black Sox - Jimmy Rollins - SS
345. Brooklyn Robins - Dan Plesac - RP
346. Providence Steamrollers - Bob Welch - SP
347. San Francisco Giants - Don McMahon - RP
348. Montgomery Biscuits - Steve Bedrosian - RP
349. St. Louis Cardinals - John McGraw - 3B/SS
350. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Bullet Joe Rogan - SP/OF
351. Chicago Whales - Juan Gonzalez - OF
352. Pittsburgh Porters - Joey Votto - 1B
353. Pittsburgh Pirates - Billy Herman - 2B
354. St. Louis Stars - Leon Day - SP
355. New York Yankees - Harry Brecheen - SP
356. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Hack Wilson - OF
357. Toronto BJs - Roger Maris - OF
358. Kansas City Athletics - Wes Ferrell - SP
359. Toronto Maple Leafs - Tony Oliva - OF
360. Cleveland Indians - Lance Parrish - C
Round 19
361. Cleveland Indians - Roberto Hernandez - RP
362. Toronto Maple Leafs - Jeff Montgomery - RP
363. Kansas City Athletics - Kerry Wood - SP/RP
364. Toronto BJs - Jack Glasscock - SS
365. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Hanley Ramirez - SS
366. New York Yankees - Keith Hernandez - 1B
367. St. Louis Stars - Héctor Espino - OF
368. Pittsburgh Pirates - Jon Matlack - SP
369. Pittsburgh Porters - Jon Lester - SP
370. Chicago Whales - Tony Fernandez - SS/3B/2B
371. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Joe Hoerner - RP
372. St. Louis Cardinals - Al Hrabosky - RP
373. Montgomery Biscuits - Michael Young - SS/3B/2B
374. San Francisco Giants - Jose Bautista - OF/3B
375. Providence Steamrollers - Jim Rice - OF
376. Brooklyn Robins - Ron Cey - 3B
377. Chicago Black Sox - Mark Teixeira - 1B
378. Homestead Grays - Max Lanier - SP
379. Detroit Tigers - Norm Cash - 1B
380. Montreal Royals - Bill Freehan - C
Round 20
381. Montreal Royals - Ted Lyons - SP
382. Detroit Tigers - Gene Garber - RP
383. Homestead Grays - Katsuya Nomura - C
384. Chicago Black Sox - Heath Bell - RP
385. Brooklyn Robins - Moises Alou - OF
386. Providence Steamrollers - Placido Polanco - 2B/3B
387. San Francisco Giants - Tommy John - SP
388. Montgomery Biscuits - Cesar Cedeno -OF
389. St. Louis Cardinals - Max Carey - OF
390. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Rod Beck - RP
391. Chicago Whales - Torii Hunter - OF
392. Pittsburgh Porters - Matt Williams - 3B
393. Pittsburgh Pirates - Jimmy Dykes - 3B/2B
394. St. Louis Stars - Stu Miller - RP/SP
395. New York Yankees - Gene Tenace - C
396. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Carlos Delgado - 1B
397. Toronto BJs - Fernando Valenzuela - P
398. Kansas City Athletics - Will Clark - 1B
399. Toronto Maple Leafs - Vida Blue - SP
400. Cleveland Indians - John Olerud - 1B
Round 21
401. Cleveland Indians - Steve Kline - RP
402. Toronto Maple Leafs - Mike Timlin - RP
403. Kansas City Athletics - Bobby Bonilla - 3B/OF
404. Toronto BJs - Victor Martinez - C/1B
405. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Tony Lazzeri -2B
406. New York Yankees - Pete Browning - OF
407. St. Louis Stars - Wally Schang - C/OF
408. Pittsburgh Pirates - Lenny Dykstra - OF
409. Pittsburgh Porters - Takashi Saito - RP
410. Chicago Whales - Andrew Miller - RP
411. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Connie Mack - MGR
412. St. Louis Cardinals - Bob Stanley - RP
413. Montgomery Biscuits - David Wells - SP
414. San Francisco Giants - Buck Ewing - C
415. Providence Steamrollers - Rick Dempsey - C
416. Brooklyn Robins - Elston Howard - C
417. Chicago Black Sox - Brian McCann - C
418. Homestead Grays - Rabbit Maranville - SS/2B
419. Detroit Tigers - Chuck Klein - OF
420. Montreal Royals - Darrell Evans - 3B/1B
Round 22
421. Montreal Royals - Orlando Cepeda - 1B/OF
422. Detroit Tigers - Mike Cuellar - SP
423. Homestead Grays - Steve Garvey - 1B
424. Chicago Black Sox - Derek Lowe - SP/RP
425. Brooklyn Robins - Chuck Finley - SP
426. Providence Steamrollers - Paul Lindblad - RP
427. San Francisco Giants - Kenley Jansen - RP
428. Montgomery Biscuits - Norm Charlton - RP
429. St. Louis Cardinals - Bill Foster - SP
430. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Maury Wills - SS
431. Chicago Whales - Jason Kendall - C
432. Pittsburgh Porters - Roger Bresnahan - C
433. Pittsburgh Pirates - Charlie Keller - OF
434. St. Louis Stars - Toby Harrah - 3B/SS
435. New York Yankees - Willie Randolph - 2B
436. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Dave Stieb - SP
437. Toronto BJs - Chuck Knoblauch - 2B
438. Kansas City Athletics - Mickey Tettleton - C
439. Toronto Maple Leafs - Steve Howe - RP
440. Cleveland Indians - Al Brazle - RP/SP
Round 23
441. Cleveland Indians - Tony Phillips - OF/2B/3B/SS
442. Toronto Maple Leafs - Vada Pinson - OF
443. Kansas City Athletics - Julio Franco - SS/2B/1B
444. Toronto BJs - Brian Giles - OF
445. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Deacon White - 3B/C
446. New York Yankees - Brad Ziegler - RP
447. St. Louis Stars - Rube Foster - MGR
448. Pittsburgh Pirates - Teddy Higuera - SP
449. Pittsburgh Porters - Noodles Hahn - SP
450. Chicago Whales - Matt Holliday - OF
451. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Rick Honeycutt - RP
452. St. Louis Cardinals - Joe Torre - MGR
453. Montgomery Biscuits - Tim Wakefield - SP
454. San Francisco Giants - Bruce Bochy - MGR
455. Providence Steamrollers - Willie Wilson - OF
456. Brooklyn Robins - Bert Campaneris - SS
457. Chicago Black Sox - Brian Wilson - RP
458. Homestead Grays - Ryan Braun - OF/3B
459. Detroit Tigers - Evan Longoria - 3B
460. Montreal Royals - Darren O'Day - RP
Round 24
461. Montreal Royals - Mike Stanton - RP
462. Detroit Tigers - Joakim Soria - RP
463. Homestead Grays - Tony Watson - RP
464. Chicago Black Sox - Ian Kinsler - 2B
465. Brooklyn Robins - Mike Adams - RP
466. Providence Steamrollers - Allie Reynolds - SP/RP
467. San Francisco Giants - Prince Fielder - 1B
468. Montgomery Biscuits - Luis Castillo - 2B
469. St. Louis Cardinals - Dwight Evans - OF
470. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Arlie Latham - 3B
471. Chicago Whales - Brian Fuentes - RP
472. Pittsburgh Porters - Elmer Flick - OF
473. Pittsburgh Pirates - Terry Forster - RP
474. St. Louis Stars - Jake Beckley - 1B
475. New York Yankees - Bobby Cox - MGR
476. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Bobby Bonds - OF
477. Toronto BJs - Jimmy Key - SP
478. Kansas City Athletics - Miguel Tejada - SS
479. Toronto Maple Leafs - Jim Sundberg - C
480. Cleveland Indians - Eric Chavez - 3B
Round 25
481. Cleveland Indians - Fred Lynn - OF
482. Toronto Maple Leafs - Gil McDougald - 2B/SS/3B
483. Kansas City Athletics - Miller Huggins - MGR
484. Toronto BJs - Otis Nixon - OF
485. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Virgil Trucks - SP/RP
486. New York Yankees - Jim Brewer - RP
487. St. Louis Stars - Don Mossi - RP/SP
488. Pittsburgh Pirates - Babe Herman - 1B/OF
489. Pittsburgh Porters - Bobby Wallace - SS/3B
490. Chicago Whales - Bret Boone - 2B
491. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Jacoby Ellsbury - OF
492. St. Louis Cardinals - Red Schoendienst - 2B
493. Montgomery Biscuits - Jim Leyland - MGR
494. San Francisco Giants - Dick Radatz - RP
495. Providence Steamrollers - Paul Konerko - 1B
496. Brooklyn Robins - Jose Vidro - 2B
497. Chicago Black Sox - Johnny Damon - OF
498. Homestead Grays - Reggie Smith - OF
499. Detroit Tigers - Darryl Strawberry - OF
500. Montreal Royals - Dick Williams - MGR
Round 26
501. Montreal Royals - Roy Oswalt - SP
502. Detroit Tigers - Joe Dugan - 3B/SS
503. Homestead Grays - Tommy Lasorda - MGR
504. Chicago Black Sox - Josh Donaldson - 3B
505. Brooklyn Robins - Leo Durocher - MGR
506. Providence Steamrollers - Danny Murtaugh - MGR
507. San Francisco Giants - Bobby Thigpen - RP
508. Montgomery Biscuits - Alfonso Soriano - 2B/OF
509. St. Louis Cardinals - Burleigh Grimes - SP
510. Sioux City Cornhuskers - Joe Girardi - C
511. Chicago Whales - Derrek Lee - 1B
512. Pittsburgh Porters - Dutch Leonard - SP/RP
513. Pittsburgh Pirates - Chuck Tanner - MGR
514. St. Louis Stars - Chet Lemon - OF
515. New York Yankees - Dummy Hoy - OF
516. Brooklyn Bridegrooms - Fred Clarke - MGR
517. Toronto BJs - Clay Carroll - RP
518. Kansas City Athletics - Monte Irvin - OF
519. Toronto Maple Leafs - David Robertson - RP
520. Cleveland Indians - Moe Drabowsky - RP/SP
Last edited: