The ones you were complaining about him moving then filling in with cheap short term bodies: Girardi, Stepan and Sjkei. You were specifically saying it was bad to move those guys and fill their spots with cheap short term replacements. It wasn’t. Stepan and Sjkei both returned important assets.
Nothing about Smiths deal implies that they thought he was elite. He makes 4.3m, that’s not even close to what you pay an elite d-man. It’s a bad contract but you’re dramatizing the hell out of it.
I’m not even sure what you’re trying to get at with the bottom paragraph. My argument was that moving those guys and replacing them short-term with nothing guys is not a problem.
Wasn’t complaining about them in fact you were the one saying he had to dump bad contracts as if he didn’t create the situation in the first place.
Girardi was bought out with cheap replacement Brendan Smith at 4.3 lmao. People blamed AV for Desharnais getting minutes because they wanted Lias and Chytil over him at 18.....
I agree 4.3 is not elite money but people complained about Staal and Girardi who were atleast NHL level talent unlike their replacements in Smith and Johnson. My issue isn’t dumping them but their replacements are always garbage.
Can you explain why before this past season Gorton during a rebuild refused to play Tony D? He brought in Shatty,McQuaid which bumped him into 7Dman role. Once again AV got blamed for that some reason.
My last paragraph is people make excuses for Gorton’s short comings. People trying to justify why he signed Jack Johnson,Cody McLeod,Michael Haley,Brendan Smith,Adam McQuaid. Eric Staal trade people said what a great deal but AV ruined him even though he had a crappy season.
What bad contracts did Gorton have to deal with? If you are saying Girardi,Staal and Hank that was the cost of doing business for Stanley Cup run. The big money core now is Kreider,Trouba,Panarin and Shattenkirk’s dead cap space. The only one worth their value is Panarin. Gorton created the issue and hopefully the get a Cup soon since he went all in last year and this coming season with those moves.