Proposal: NYR/CAR deal (again)

[FireGorton]

I misread your offer. I thought you were sending a 1st + 2nd (which is a bit of an overpay) for Bean. Not down with sending a 2nd + Bean for the 22OA though.

That’s fine but strange you think Bean has more value than Skjei a guy you traded for

 

[GoldiFox]

That’s fine but strange you think Bean has more value than Skjei a guy you traded for

Why would that be strange? It is possible, maybe even likely, that NYR wanted Bean in the Skjei deal and Carolina only offered their 1st.

To a team like NJ or Ottawa - Jake Bean on his ELC with 5 more years of cost-control may be more desirable than Skjei making $5.25 million.

 

[cwede]

That’s fine but strange you think Bean has more value than Skjei a guy you traded for

as we see all the time,trade value is not absolute, it is dependent on timing and situation
- veterans who would not merit high picks during off-season, or before january, get picked up for high picks in february/march
- but then, often, as teams plan offseason retool, potential high impact prospects might yield more return than in-season

 

[FireGorton]

Why would that be strange? It is possible, maybe even likely, that NYR wanted Bean in the Skjei deal and Carolina only offered their 1st.

To a team like NJ or Ottawa - Jake Bean on his ELC with 5 more years of cost-control may be more desirable than Skjei making $5.25 million.

Lol what does NJ or Ottawa have to do with Canes GM thinking Bean isn’t an NHL Dman? They had injuries like you said but felt the need to get a long term piece in Skjei with Slavin and Gardiner on the roster already for the foreseeable future. I disagree Bean has more value than Skjei but you are welcome to your opinion

 

[usekakkorightquinn]

Bean has played 2 NHL games and he's 22. If he had the value of Skjei he would have made the NHL full time at least a year ago. I wouldn't put too much into his AHL points. Carolina traditionally has a high scoring AHL team.

 

[bernmeister]

Bean has played 2 NHL games and he's 22. If he had the value of Skjei he would have made the NHL full time at least a year ago. I wouldn't put too much into his AHL points. Carolina traditionally has a high scoring AHL team.

Bean has potential
Skjei is proven value, even if that value continues to be more precisely assessed

 

[Nikishin Go Boom]

Bean has played 2 NHL games and he's 22. If he had the value of Skjei he would have made the NHL full time at least a year ago. I wouldn't put too much into his AHL points. Carolina traditionally has a high scoring AHL team.

since none of this is true, what else do you have for excuses?