Ders Effect
Registered User
- Jul 27, 2015
- 29
- 0
More proof that Ocean County should not be called South Jersey, especially anywhere above Toms River.
More proof that Ocean County should not be called South Jersey, especially anywhere above Toms River.
According to the NYT baseball fan map (based on the number of Facebook fans each team has by zip code) the only part of Ocean County that could be said to be Philadelphia territory is Tuckerton/Little Egg Harbor, and even that's only 38% Phillies, 38% Yankees, and 10% Mets, so a plurality of NY fans.
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/04/24/upshot/facebook-baseball-map.html#10,39.683,-74.377
Likewise, their NBA fan map basically says the same thing.
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/05/12/upshot/basketball-map.html#9,39.856,-74.848
All of Ocean County except for Tuckerton/Little Egg Harbor are Knicks territory, and even there, there are more Knicks fans than Sixer fans, but there are more Laker fans than Knick fans.
Little Egg Harbor was taken from Burlington County and added to Ocean County, which was originally part of Monmouth County, so it all makes sense in the end.
More proof that Ocean County should not be called South Jersey, especially anywhere above Toms River.
The totals for yankees fans is pretty impressive in deep red Phillies country considering how hard it is to watch a yankees game in that terrority.
What's the deal with Sussex County? Is it a TV coverage thing? Maybe just small sample size?
I'm a Philadelphia sports fan in everything but hockey and though I'm not from New Jersey originally, I am from one of those Philly/NYC mixed fan areas (Lehigh Valley - which is in the Philadelphia TV market, so it doesn't get NYC area sports channels but it pretty much has always gotten the NYC area over-the-air channels like Channels 2, 4, 5, 7, 9, and 11 on cable systems, plus they are available over-the-air to some people). Here's my perceived breakdown by sport, particularly for the Lehigh Valley and NEPA (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre area), but for mixed fan areas in New Jersey as well. (With NJ it isn't so much the breakdown of Philly team vs NYC area team, but the relative popularity of the NYC area teams to each other.):
HOCKEY
*In the Lehigh Valley, the Flyers are dominant; there are few NYC area team fans. I'd guess the Rangers are slightly more popular than the Devils, and both are definitely more popular than the Islanders. When you get into Phillipsburg, it tilts more towards the Devils and Rangers, but the Flyers are still the most popular team there. I'm guessing you need to go as far east as Clinton (which is largely outside the Lehigh Valley sphere of influence, unlike Phillipsburg) to get a majority of Devils or Rangers fans over Flyers fans. In NEPA the Flyers are still quite a bit more popular than the Rangers or Devils, and the Penguins have probably become the second-most popular team there over the Rangers and Devils since they put their AHL affiliate in Wilkes-Barre in the late 1990s.
BASEBALL
*This is the sport where New York teams, particularly the Yankees, make the most inroads. The Phillies are definitely the most popular team in the Lehigh Valley, but the Yankees are a solid second, probably with somewhere between 30-40% as many fans as Phillies fans (i.e. Phillies have 2.5 to 3.3 times as many fans as the Yankees do). In NEPA, the Phils and Yanks have close to a 50/50 split; I'd guess the Yankees are slightly more popular. The most notable thing in both areas is how much more popular the Yankees are than the Mets; I don't think it would be an exaggeration to say there are 10 Yankees fans for every Mets fan in the Lehigh Valley. It probably isn't quite that extreme in NEPA, but I'd guess the ratio is at least 5:1 Yanks/Mets.
FOOTBALL
*The Giants are probably the second-most popular New York area team in eastern PA in any sport behind the Yankees. In the Lehigh Valley, Eagles fans dominate, but the Giants have a sizable minority of fans, probably on the order of 20-25% of Eagles fans. In NEPA, the Eagles/Giants fan ratio probably is something like 2:1 in favor of the Eagles. Much like the baseball comparison but not at as an extreme level, the Giants are much more popular than the Jets in both the Lehigh Valley and NEPA, probably something like 4:1 or 5:1 in both areas. The other notable thing is how many ****tsburgh Squealers, I mean Pittsburgh Steelers fans there are in both areas; I'd guess the Steelers rank ahead of the Giants (and Jets) in both areas, especially NEPA (but only slightly ahead in the Lehigh Valley), and aren't too far behind the Eagles in popularity in NEPA.
BASKETBALL
*This is a sport that doesn't register with a lot of people, especially in NEPA. The 76ers are definitely more popular than the Knicks (or Nets) in the Lehigh Valley, and probably somewhat more popular than the Knicks in NEPA. As in other sports, the Manhattan-based and/or longer-established NYC area team (Knicks) is significantly more popular than the "new" team (Nets).
I've spent quite a bit of time in the Lehigh Valley lately, but I've never lived there, so I don't claim to be anything close to an expert. That said, I saw a lot more Yankees paraphernalia than anything to do with Philadelphia. Hats, shirts, bumper stickers, you name it. I'm thinking that the Lehigh Valley is trending towards NY vis-a-vis PHI, similar to Central New Jersey. As more New Yorkers migrate to those areas, and as locals are more likely to be able to watch New York teams on TV, they'll gravitate more towards them. People who have deep roots in the area and old timers will still stubbornly support their Philadelphia teams, but the future seems to be dim for them.
Don't know anything about the local hockey scene in Phillipsburg, Easton, Allentown, or Bethlehem so I won't comment on the Devils popularity in those towns.
It's definitely more affordable in LV than in NJ, so I can see why people move there... and it's not a very far drive, either.
Hunt the Wumpus? Holy crap that just gave me a weird childhood flashback.
What you may also be seeing if you are a New York sports fan and particularly a Yankees fan is a lot more Yankees stuff than stuff for other New York area teams in the Lehigh Valley. Among the New York area's 9 NFL/MLB/NBA/NHL teams, the Yankees definitely ARE the most popular team in the Lehigh Valley.
Nah, I'm a Mets fan. Hate the Yankees, but hate the Phillies more.
Only New York team I hate more than their Philadelphia alternative is the Rangers.
No Mets fans in LV, that much is obvious.
Yankees gear is everywhere though. Can't even say it's hip hop culture or whatever, because the LV doesn't seem very hip hop to say the least.
Clinton is clearly Devils first, Rags 2nd, hardly any Flyers fans around there.
Phillipsburg area used to lean heavier towards the Flyers in the 80s/90s but now there are many Devils fans there, I'd call it majority Devils overall just from knowing a few Devils fans who live out there and what they tell me.
If we can get a perennial strong team again that makes Cup runs you will see a ton of Devils fans coming out of the woodwork all across the state with the exception of the counties in the shadows of Philly (Ex: Camden, Gloucester) and southwest (Salem, Cumberland).
As far as PA goes, a lot of people from NJ & NY have moved out there in the last decade so it's not a shock anymore to see cars with PA tags and Devils fans in them.
Especially in the Easton/Bethlehem and Stroudsburg areas.