Idk i don't think you can just blame Boucher for everything wrong with this team or eith individual players. Paul's been up and down for a few years and this year it's been more up than down. He's scratched often and needs to play. Waivers is the only way he goes down.
Let's be clear. Paul has size, speed and strength. But he has 2 goals and 1 assist in his last 31 nhl games. It isn't working. He's just not producing.
Smith by comparison has 5 goals and 19 points in 43 games and is +3.
It is appropriate to blame Boucher for how he has handled paul. Multiple ottawa reporters and fans have been critical of Boucher for this exact thing. He had paul called up and scratched him, sent him back down called him up again and scratched him. He wouldn't ever scratch pyatt pr pajaarvi fr him even though he is a better player. He would get in the lineup and play fine just to get scratched the next few games. He would get 5 minutes a game even though his play suggested he deserved much more ice time.
Boucher has been publicly mocked by the TSN1200 crew for all these decisions. Steve warne, Steve lloyd and shawn Simpson often claimed how incompetent it was that paul was scratched.
Boucher has never liked paul. He is probably still bitter that his baby Tom pyatt was waived and traded in favor of keeping paul.
Boucher is certainly to blame for this decision. Boucher is a hack and should ho back to whatever league he came from. He isn't an NHL coach and only incompetent gm like dorion would still listen to him