The Athletic NHL99: Alexander Mogilny’s brilliance and his curious absence from the Hall of Fame

Jim Bob

RIP RJ
Feb 27, 2002
56,201
35,362
Rochester, NY

In the century-plus history of the NHL, only six players have ever scored more than 75 goals in a season. It’s an almost incomprehensible feat, especially in today’s era when a player even nudging 60 is seen as a stunning achievement. To get there, a player needs to score nearly a goal per game over the course of a full season, a level of production that even legendary scorers like Mike Bossy, Alexander Ovechkin, Pavel Bure and Jaromir Jagr never reached.

Of the six players to top 75 goals, five are in the Hockey Hall of Fame. Three of them — Phil Esposito, Teemu Selanne and Brett Hull — made it in as soon as they became eligible. Two more, Wayne Gretzky and Mario Lemieux, made it even sooner, with the Hall waiving its three-year waiting period to induct them early.

The sixth member of the 75-goal club isn’t in the Hall of Fame at all. Not yet, anyway, despite over a decade of eligibility. It stands as one of the Hall’s most inexcusable oversights, and we need to talk about it. But to tell the story of Alexander Mogilny — who comes it at No. 89 on our list of the top 100 players in modern NHL history — we have to go back further than that monster 1992-93 season. We need to go back to the beginning, to the story of how a 20-year-old phenom changed the NHL forever.

Add in the decision Alex made to come and play in the NHL, and this may be the worst case of someone having to wait too long to get into the HHOF.
 

MOGlLNY

Registered User
Jan 5, 2008
11,185
10,496
Absolutely criminal he’s not in. Not only does he have the numbers alone but IMO he could’ve played 5 games with 0 points in the NHL and he should be in for what he risked breaking the Iron Curtain.

Russians are critical for the story of the NHL and he was the first to defect
 
Last edited:

WhereAreTheCookies

Registered User
Feb 16, 2022
3,150
5,351
Top Shelf
Seeing Lindros and Kariya get in and not Mogilny is also a bit of a slap in the face to him and his legacy. I guess you could argue that Lindros has a Hart and Pearson, but Kariya has 2 Byng's and that's it. Mogilny has a Byng and a cup along with more points and goals in almost the exact same number of games. That's not even mentioning the Sedins and Alfredsson.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldgoalie

MilkshakeMan

Registered User
Apr 22, 2022
261
193
He absolutely deserves to be in.

I never saw him on the Sabres, but I remember his later career with NJ/TOR and he was still really good. The only knock on him was he wasn't good in the defensive zone - but there are plenty of forwards who are in the HOF who played like that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sabresfansince1980

elchud

Registered User
Nov 1, 2015
3,106
1,930
I think its because he can't get an Uber to drive him from Russia to Toronto
 

WhereAreTheCookies

Registered User
Feb 16, 2022
3,150
5,351
Top Shelf
If it wasn't for Teemu Selanne, I think Mogilny would be in. But Selanne was the rookie phenom, and thus the fact that Mogilny also scored 76 goals that year has become treated like a footnote.
People definitely still ooh and ahh over Selanne's rookie season. People seem to forget he was 22 years old already and Mogilny was only 23 so there wasn't some huge age gap. Also, some knock Mogilny for never approaching near that number again, but his 2nd highest was 55 while Selanne's 2nd highest was 52. Selanne just had the longer and less injury filled career, and was probably a little more consistent.
 

Chainshot

Give 'em Enough Rope
Sponsor
Feb 28, 2002
150,735
100,636
Tarnation
People definitely still ooh and ahh over Selanne's rookie season. People seem to forget he was 22 years old already and Mogilny was only 23 so there wasn't some huge age gap. Also, some knock Mogilny for never approaching near that number again, but his 2nd highest was 55 while Selanne's 2nd highest was 52. Selanne just had the longer and less injury filled career, and was probably a little more consistent.

They also gloss over that he fractured his leg on a backcheck that year in the playoffs and returned earlier than anyone thought the following season.
 

missingmika

Registered User
Dec 9, 2006
4,521
1,831
If it wasn't for Teemu Selanne, I think Mogilny would be in. But Selanne was the rookie phenom, and thus the fact that Mogilny also scored 76 goals that year has become treated like a footnote.

The guy we got for Mogilny has a classic highlight on Selanne:

 

beerme1

Registered User
Jun 27, 2011
949
488
Something stinks with Almo not being it. Stinks rotten. For the NFL and also a similar criminality that Steve Tasker is not in. But at least you can argue they never had a special teams player elected. Mogilny not being in is just ridiculously stupid. Hockey fans in general, but in particular Buffalo, NJ and Toronto will tell you.
 

Zman5778

Moderator
Oct 4, 2005
25,039
22,285
Cressona/Reading, PA
Something stinks with Almo not being it. Stinks rotten. For the NFL and also a similar criminality that Steve Tasker is not in. But at least you can argue they never had a special teams player elected. Mogilny not being in is just ridiculously stupid. Hockey fans in general, but in particular Buffalo, NJ and Toronto will tell you.
Hockey media is just about as vindictive as baseball media. Alex was always a bit of a jerk towards media.

While the selection committee isn't all media.....I'm sure a few push hard against him being voted in
 
  • Like
Reactions: jd1970

Chainshot

Give 'em Enough Rope
Sponsor
Feb 28, 2002
150,735
100,636
Tarnation
The guy we got for Mogilny has a classic highlight on Selanne:



And after breaking his face on Selanne's helmet, the first game for him back with the full mask on to protect his broken cheekbone was against the Jets. Peca has balls one can still see from space.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad