NHL19 Overall Ratings Predictions

[Potty John]

Gaudreau 90 - Monahan 87 - Ferland 83
Tkachuk 85 - Backlund 85 - Frolik 82
Bennett 81 - Jankowski 81 - Brouwer 78
Lazar 77 - Shore 79 - Hathaway 77

Foo - 75 Mangiapane - 77

Giordano 88 - Hamilton 87
Brodie 85 - Hamonic 83
Kulak 79 - Stone 81

Wotherspoon 78

Smith 84
Rittich 79
Gillies 78

 

[NickH8]

Bertuzzi (78) - Zetterberg (83) - Nyquist (82)
Helm (79) - Larkin (84) - Mantha (83)
Abdelkader (80) - Nielsen (80) - Athanasiou (80)
Witkowski (75) - Glendening (77) - Frk (79)

Kronwall (82) - Green (82)
Ericsson (80) - Daley (82)
DeKeyser (80) - Jensen (78)
Ouellet (76)

Howard (83)
Coreau (75)

In the system:
Rasmussen (70)
Svechnikov (74)
Cholowski (70)
Hronek (74)
Hicketts (72)
Turgeon (74)

 

[JBose7]

Ummm Back-to-Back Art Ross Trophy wins, possible Back-To-Back Ted Lindsay Awards all at the age of 21. In terms of NOW, McDavid is better. In terms of career, Crosby has him on it for now. It's just a matter of time if McDavid keeps getting the scoring titles and awards.

I think the only thing McDavid is better than Crosby ratings wise is Speed. Other than that Offensive Awarenees is equal. Defensive awareness Crosby is better. Physical Strength Crosby. Agility is equal. So point is McDavid will win regular season awards all the time because of how the league is structured during the regular season. Its a young mans game. But in critical games or clutch games? Crosby has poise and raises his game and makes his teammates better. So if anything i give them equal ratings except for in skating speed, poise, physical strength

 

[Deku]

Sens roster will probably change a decent amount, so I'll just go with what we currently have

Stone 88
Duchene 86
Hoffman 85
Dzingel 82
Ryan 82
Pageau 81
Smith 80
Pyatt 79
Gaborik 79
Paajarvi 78
White 78
Burrows 77
Chlapik 76
McCormick 76

Karlsson 90
Chabot 82
Ceci 82
Wideman 80
Boro 79
Wolanin 76
Claesson/Harpur 75

Anderson 81/Condon 79

 

[Pens8771]

No, he deserves more than an 81!!

Come on! He’s a beast!

I actually thought I was generous here. He's a limited player offensively and plays an exclusive 3rd pairing role.

 

[Beezeral]

Barkov- 86 Ovr PWF that has mediocre defensive grades.

 

[LamorielloAndSon]

Lee (87) - Tavares (91) - Bailey (87)
Beauvillier (84) - Barzal (89) - Eberle (87)
Bellows (78 but amazing shot)- Nelson (81) - Hosang (78 but amazing skating)
Ladd (80) - Cizikas (79) - Clutterbuck (79)
Johnston (78)

Leddy (86) - Boychuk (83)
de Haan (85) - Pulock (84)
Hickey (81) - pelech (81)
Mayfield (79)

Grubaurer (84)
Soderstrom (81)

Have a feeling there is no NHL 19 though

 

[Shad]

Toews 97

 

[Pens8771]

Toews 97

Leadership and demeanor alone should put him at a 99. We'll ignore he's only topped 70 points one time in his career.....top 100 for sure. SMH

 

[Pens8771]

Lee (87) - Tavares (91) - Bailey (87)
Beauvillier (84) - Barzal (89) - Eberle (87)
Bellows (78 but amazing shot)- Nelson (81) - Hosang (78 but amazing skating)
Ladd (80) - Cizikas (79) - Clutterbuck (79)
Johnston (78)

Leddy (86) - Boychuk (83)
de Haan (85) - Pulock (84)
Hickey (81) - pelech (81)
Mayfield (79)

Grubaurer (84)
Soderstrom (81)

Have a feeling there is no NHL 19 though

You're over rating almost everyone on your team by at least 1-2 points. As you have it, the NYI have a top squad on the nhl.

 

[LamorielloAndSon]

You're over rating almost everyone on your team by at least 1-2 points. As you have it, the NYI have a top squad on the nhl.

And before injuries last year they were having the best season in isles history losing boychuk and dehaan and replacing them with siedenberg aho and mayfield while halak and greiss were already having terrible seasons is enough to make them fall off the deep end no matter how much leddy looked to be in Norris contender form in the first 20 games

 

[ColbyChaos]

Saad(85)-Toews(87)-Hinostroza(80)
DeBrincat(84)-Schmaltz(84)-Kane(92)
Sikura(79)-Anisimov(83)-DuClair(80)
Hayden(78)-Kampf(77)-Kahun(56*)
Edjsell(78)

Kahun is a euro FA so given the EA trend he will probably be somehow worse than chl players rating wise at the start of the game then bumped to the mid 70s if he sticks.

Keith(87)-Murphy(85)
Seabrook(83)-Oesterle(81)
Rutta(81)-Forsling(79-80)
Hillman (76)


Crawford(91)
Forsberg(79)
Delia(78)

 

[Pens8771]

And before injuries last year they were having the best season in isles history losing boychuk and dehaan and replacing them with siedenberg aho and mayfield while halak and greiss were already having terrible seasons is enough to make them fall off the deep end no matter how much leddy looked to be in Norris contender form in the first 20 games

That's why they play 82 games and not 20. they scored 80 points and were 17 points out of a playoff spot. The loss of boychuk and dehaan wouldn't have made that up. In a league where over half the teams make the playoffs, if you don't make it, you don't have a good team.

 

[n00bxQb]

That's why they play 82 games and not 20. they scored 80 points and were 17 points out of a playoff spot. The loss of boychuk and dehaan wouldn't have made that up. In a league where over half the teams make the playoffs, if you don't make it, you don't have a good team.

Chicago won the cup in 2010. In 2011, on the last day of the regular season, Chicago lost early in the day to Detroit and Dallas had an opportunity to clinch a playoff spot in literally the last game of the regular season, but lost to Minnesota. Chicago easily could've missed the playoffs that season despite a 97-point regular season. And they would go on to win the cup in 2013 and 2015.

Los Angeles finishes 40-27-15 in 2012, wins the Stanley Cup. Los Angeles finishes 40-27-15 in 2015, misses the playoffs.

 

[LamorielloAndSon]

That's why they play 82 games and not 20. they scored 80 points and were 17 points out of a playoff spot. The loss of boychuk and dehaan wouldn't have made that up. In a league where over half the teams make the playoffs, if you don't make it, you don't have a good team.

That's why anyone should be able to see how important veteran defensive dmen are, there's no denying that the isles are a very good team with boychuk and dehaan

 

[Pens8771]

Chicago won the cup in 2010. In 2011, on the last day of the regular season, Chicago lost early in the day to Detroit and Dallas had an opportunity to clinch a playoff spot in literally the last game of the regular season, but lost to Minnesota. Chicago easily could've missed the playoffs that season despite a 97-point regular season. And they would go on to win the cup in 2013 and 2015.

Los Angeles finishes 40-27-15 in 2012, wins the Stanley Cup. Los Angeles finishes 40-27-15 in 2015, misses the playoffs.

My point still stands, each year is different but bottom line, if you dont make the playoffs in the NHL you are below the 50th percentile meaning at a minimum a below average team. In the case of the NYI last year they were a poor team by all accounts. A team could score 100 points, if they don't make the playoffs they stink....it's all relative.

 

[SouthGeorge]

DDA is a 100 overall. None of this matters.

 

[Pens8771]

That's why anyone should be able to see how important veteran defensive dmen are, there's no denying that the isles are a very good team with boychuk and dehaan

A very good team in what regard? So boychuk and dehaan are worth 25+ points being fully healthy? That what it would take to get into the playoffs for NYI.

Boychuk had 18 points in 58 games and De Haan had 12 points in 23 games (whopping 1g)....these aren't exactly Norris canadate numbers.

There are 20+ teams in the nhl that are better today and you're probably going to lose your best player.

You say there is "no denying that the NYI are a very good team" get a grip. A couple of good forwards and a couple of veteran (aging) dmen don't equal a good team. This team, as of now, is a bottom dweller and the player rankings should reflect that.

 

[LamorielloAndSon]

A very good team in what regard? So boychuk and dehaan are worth 25+ points being fully healthy? That what it would take to get into the playoffs for NYI.

Boychuk had 18 points in 58 games and De Haan had 12 points in 23 games (whopping 1g)....these aren't exactly Norris canadate numbers.

There are 20+ teams in the nhl that are better today and you're probably going to lose your best player.

You say there is "no denying that the NYI are a very good team" get a grip. A couple of good forwards and a couple of veteran (aging) dmen don't equal a good team. This team, as of now, is a bottom dweller and the player rankings should reflect that.

With boychuk leddy was the Potential Norris candidate with mayfield he's a minus 40, with dehaan and boychuk the isles have a solid top 4 d and a top 3 offense in the league but yes let's act like aho will be playing 20 minutes a game and mayfield will be anything more than a number 7

 

[Shrimper]

I'm hoping they'll actually have some gaps between players this year.

 

[Floopaze]

Kovalchuk (83) - kopitar (91) - brown (84)

Pearson (83) - carter (86) - toffoli (84)

Iafallo (81) - kempe (82) - Lewis (78)

Mitchell (76) - Thompson (75) - clifford (77)


Vilardi (72)
Rieder (79)


Forbort (82) - doughty (92)

Muzzin (86) - ladue (77)

Martinez (83) - phanuef (81)


Folin (78)
Gravel (79)
Fantenberg (74)
Macdermid (72)
Brickley (73)


Quick (89) - Campbell (74)


Budaj (78)

 

[um]

Hard to predict EA's ratings, so I'll just do what I think they should be:

Ovechkin (93) - Kuznetsov (90) - Wilson (82)
Vrana (79) - Backstrom (90) - Oshie (85)
Connolly (78) - Eller (83) - Burakovsky (81)
Stephenson (77) - *Beagle (78) - Pelly (77)
Walker (75), Boyd (75), Gersich (74)

Orlov (87) - Niskanen (87)
*Kempny (81) - Carlson (89)
*Orpik (79) - Djoos (77)
Bowey (76)

Holtby (90)
Copley (74)
Samsonov (76)

* May not be back.

 

[ZedCanadian]

RNH(85)-McJesus(94)-Rattie(75)
Vanek(83)-Draisy(88)-Pulj(81)
Lucic(81)-Strome(81)-Caggiula(76)
Aberg(75)-Khaira(78)-Kassian(77)
Pakarinen(75), Yamamoto(76), Benson(67), McLeod(63)

Klefbom(84)-Larsson(83)
Sekera(82)-Russell(78)
Nurse(83)-Benning(80)
Bear(72), Bouchard(75), Jones(67)

RNH - High Top 6
McJesus - Medium Franchise
Draisy - Medium Elite
Pulj - Low Elite
Yamamoto - Medium Elite
Benson - High Top 9
McLeod - Medium Bottom 6
Klefbom - Low Elite
Larsson - High Top 4
Nurse - High Top 4
Benning - Medium Top 6
Bear - Medium Top 4
Bouchard - Medium Elite
Jones - Medium Top 6

Tried to be the least biased possible

 

[FinnishCoyote]

Keller 86 - Stepan 84 - Panik 81
Galchenyuk 84 - Strome 79 - Fischer 81
Perlini 81 - Dvorak 82 - Crouse 77
Cousins 78 - Kruger 77 - Dauphin 75

OEL 87 - Demers 82
Golikoski 83- Hjalmarsson 83
Golikoski 82 - Connauton 80
Lyubushkin 74

Raanta 85
Kuemper 82

 

[Evocable Manager]

Schwartz (87)-Schenn(86)-Tarasenko(91)
Steen(85)-Berglund(83)-Soshnikov (81)
Jaskin(81)-Barbashev(80)-Thompson(78)
Sobotka(80)-Brodziak(81)-Thorburn(75)
Sanford(78)

Edmundson(83)-Pietrangelo(90)
Dunn(82)-Parayko(88)
Bouwmeester(78)-Bortuzzo(80)
Gunnarsson(78)

Allen(82)
Hutton(83)

Rookies for next year (possibly)
Thomas(81)
Kyrou(80)
Husso(78)

That's as currently constructed. Wow, were terrible.